Mj 2.0!

Pongo

New Member
Uponastar said:
I rewatched Goblet of Fire last night.
I love that movie, but hate Dumbledore in it.
Dumbledore does not get angry and flustered and loud like that.
That is not him.

I like this Dumbledore much better than the old one.

I see him as someone that does get loud. The othe Dumbledore was to... mellow. Dumbledore should be mellow, but not about everything.

EDIT: I don't think the old Dumbledore would have done well in the final scene of Book Five.
 

Connor002

Active Member
Uponastar said:
I rewatched Goblet of Fire last night.
I love that movie, but hate Dumbledore in it.
Dumbledore does not get angry and flustered and loud like that.
That is not him.

I hated Dumbledore and I hated Voldemort in that movie.
Unfortunately, they're my favorite characters, so I was disappointed on two fronts.
 

Uponastar

Well-Known Member
Pongo said:
I like this Dumbledore much better than the old one.

I see him as someone that does get loud. The othe Dumbledore was to... mellow. Dumbledore should be mellow, but not about everything.

Wow!
We're definitely on different pages here.
I think Dumbledore should always be mellow.
Calm and sure.
That's him.
 

Connor002

Active Member
Dot said:
Wow!
We're definitely on different pages here.
I think Dumbledore should always be mellow.
Calm and sure.
That's him.

Let's gang up on Luke. :lookaroun
Grab your torches and pitchforks! :lookaroun
 

Pongo

New Member
Connor002 said:
I hated Dumbledore and I hated Voldemort in that movie.
Unfortunately, they're my favorite characters, so I was disappointed on two fronts.

Well, I didn't like Fleur or Krum. I thought the whole movie was just okay on HP standards.

The third is absolutely my favorite. Book and movie.
 

Pongo

New Member
Uponastar said:
Wow!
We're definitely on different pages here.
I think Dumbledore should always be mellow.
Calm and sure.
That's him.

Hm.

I just can't see Dumbledore being calm and fighing Voldemort at the same time...

I guess I picture him as a passionately passive, but will be aggressive when necessary type of wizard...
 

Pongo

New Member
Connor002 said:
I hated Fleur... Krum was almost as bad...
I dislike the movie. It has potential, but failed...

I didn't hate it... but i did expect more from it.

EDIT: And I'm glad they left out SPEW. I hated that storyline.
 

Uponastar

Well-Known Member
Pongo said:
Hm.

I just can't see Dumbledore being calm and fighing Voldemort at the same time...

I guess I picture him as a passionately passive, but will be aggressive when necessary type of wizard...

Calmly aggressive, maybe? :lol:
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom