UNCgolf
Well-Known Member
I guess I fundamentally disagree that it no longer makes sense. Or at least that it ever was 100% cohesive with the rest of the park. It’s the entry experience and like the other three parks, the entry land’s main purpose is to squarely say “this is not your everyday life” and subtly “why don’t you buy something or get some food?”.
I see it as no different than entering through an aggrandized 1910s Midwest Main Street to then pass on to a medieval European castle & fair or a colonialist global south. Or passing under a modernist geodesic sphere to then experience pre-20th century pastiches of foreign countries and the US.
If we want to lament the slow killing of entertainment in the Hollywood Boulevard area, I think that’s well warranted. But to say the whole area is somehow now unwarranted because of the dearth of entertainment seems too far.
The whole park was built as such a blatant attempt to squash USF that it’s hard to buy into the notion that it had this noble ideal or cohesion on day one. I mean the park opened with Star Tour’s modern Sci-Fi set decor under construction just steps from a faux late 40s theater complex and a very 1980s stunt amphitheater.
I'm not saying it was 100% cohesive, but it was two clear areas. Hollywood (really the Los Angeles area in general because it wasn't all Hollywood) as the entrance area, and then a studio backlot. You essentially started in Los Angeles, and then transitioned into a backlot -- which you can do right now in actual Los Angeles.
It was also more than just entertainment. The shops themselves used to be themed and now they really aren't beyond the facades (although that's not really unique to DHS; MK has lost a lot of this too), and the park was full of things, including attractions, related to movie making. That's why the Indiana Jones stunt show is structured the way it is, and that's also why the Star Tours area looks the way it does. Now that that aspect of the park has essentially been excised, the Star Tours entrance, the stunt show framing, and even the soundstages don't make sense the way they once did.
It was definitely more cohesive than it is now, and, at least to me, it was better/more enjoyable park. Now it's just kind of a mishmash of unconnected areas -- which isn't automatically a disaster, as the Magic Kingdom is really this too on a fundamental level, but the MK has far more to do in its areas than DHS does.
EDIT: To be fair, that original theme wasn't going to work forever, and I'm not sure they had any good options once they started moving away from it. So much of the original design (like the things I mentioned above, e.g., the soundstages) was fundamentally rooted in that theme, and they just seem random now.
Last edited: