I think bumping this thread each holiday season is fine and dandy, since apparently it is OK and has become defensible by many fans for EPCOT to remain a lifeless, drab, gray, entity during the holidays with a spot of cheer here and there hidden deep in its Dystopian recesses.
What crummy luck for this to be your first holiday(s) at WDW. Really crummy.
It looks like this happened during a time I was busy at work and not paying attention to Disney on the internetz and this makes me retroactively sad.
Anyhoo, true anecdote from just a couple of weeks ago. We're spending a couple of days on property the week before Christmas before visiting all the weirdos that comprise our respective families. We were planning on visiting resorts, looking at pretties, and doing a few off kilter things without entering the parks. In June we will be activating APs and with that timing we will get 3 trips of significance out of them before letting them expire. Anyway, I mentioned the new turrets to the family and showed them the lights. They agreed it looked pretty....they remember Osborne and even though this may be its last year they were still comfortable with just dorking around property. I then turned to the wife. I said, "Remember the two trips we made when we were in graduate school in 1994 and 1996? What if EPCOT were decorated now like it was then?" She said, "I'd insist you buy one day park hoppers (note: she is the ultimate deal finder, she knows this is the exact opposite of a good deal) and that we spend a day walking around looking at decorations in the parks."