Just typed the same exact response as you about these 2 attractions. I never see them as walk ons.
Yeah, I will usually jump on Astro if I see a short queue (other than rope drop when my priorities are higher).
I dunno, I'm not ruling out the possibility that I will buy Genie+, because I HAVE jumped through other crazy WDW hoops before (inside HS by 7am for Rise), but this one feels icky.
Before we enter any queue, we vaguely ask, "Is this worth the XX min wait?" Time = $. If I'm paying $30/hour to be at WDW, something that saves an hour of my time might be worth paying $30. But now I know I'm going to ask the reverse, "Is this 3.5minute ride worth a $15/minute upcharge?" (3 people/$15 each/3 min)
Then I know I will ask myself, "If I'm not actually going on rides, why are we paying $30/hour to be at WDW?"
I've paid to stay at Universal's onsite hotels for unlimited express pass, but that only ends up costing about $7.70/ hour for all of us, and there are
no annoying restrictions. We just go on everything as many times as we want without waiting more than about 15 min.
So I want to know, will Genie+ = walk-on? Or will Genie+ waits = what FP waits were? How quickly will WDW refund me if my wait is longer, cause we all know Space Mountain is old. WDW rides are not nearly as reliable as they used to be! A big upcharge better = a quick refund as soon as WDW can't deliver a short wait.
And this upcharge STILL has the BIG problem of making me jump through hoops to use it. I am paying WDW an upcharge to have my time restricted. Will WDW give us a refund if we are stuck on the monorail and can't get to Space in time?