I know this isn't 3D, but that Drew Carey Sounds Dangerous show has to be the worst attraction in all of WDW! I can't understand why they even have it, the CM's are embarassed to present the show and I cringed the entire time! Oh yeah, and that Canada movie, don't get me started on that...
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
Least Favorite 3D Film
- Thread starter mkepcotmgmak
- Start date
I actually seem to have a problem with all of them. Maybe it is the way my brain is processing the images or something, but I do not always see the 3d effects, so I miss out a little bit on the shows. I read something about it having to do with stereo vision I think. Does anyone else have this problem?
DisneyBunny
Active Member
I'd rate the best worst shows differently. In terms of pure 3D magic, with all the cool special effects that the 3D brings (and not any surrounding 4D effects) I'd rate them (best to worst):
Philharmagic
It's Tough to Be a Bug
Muppetvision 3D
HISTA
However, if you wanted to look at the total package, which includes such things as, oh, i don't know... a PLOT, not to mention 4D elements like AAs and live actors, the list changes:
Muppetvision 3D
ITTBAB
Philharmagic
HISTA
The Muppets show will always hold a special place in my heart. Where else can you get AAs, 3D, and a live Sweetums?
Sure, Philharmagic is just a rehash of films, but it is still timeless, IMHO. Those films will never get old, in my mind.
HISTA is just too dated to really draw me in anymore. Not too many kids really recognize the franchise, and if they do, it's from the first film, not the insipid sequels. Plus, I can never manage to get the 3D to line up properly, and I always have a headache from trying to get my eyes to see the 3D.
Bottom line, I wouldn't cry if either ITTBAB, or HISTA were replaced with anything. Even if they weren't well done, dark rides, or fantastic plots. It would just be something new to see until that too gets old. All IMHO, of course.
Philharmagic
It's Tough to Be a Bug
Muppetvision 3D
HISTA
However, if you wanted to look at the total package, which includes such things as, oh, i don't know... a PLOT, not to mention 4D elements like AAs and live actors, the list changes:
Muppetvision 3D
ITTBAB
Philharmagic
HISTA
The Muppets show will always hold a special place in my heart. Where else can you get AAs, 3D, and a live Sweetums?
Sure, Philharmagic is just a rehash of films, but it is still timeless, IMHO. Those films will never get old, in my mind.
HISTA is just too dated to really draw me in anymore. Not too many kids really recognize the franchise, and if they do, it's from the first film, not the insipid sequels. Plus, I can never manage to get the 3D to line up properly, and I always have a headache from trying to get my eyes to see the 3D.
Bottom line, I wouldn't cry if either ITTBAB, or HISTA were replaced with anything. Even if they weren't well done, dark rides, or fantastic plots. It would just be something new to see until that too gets old. All IMHO, of course.
dazzer68
New Member
after going on philamagic this year for the first time it shows how dated the others are... the muppets is ok but loses the effect because it doesnt fit the screen..if a muppets coming forward half gets cut off out of frame so loses the effect..
hista is looking old and to be honest who cares ! most kids dont know what its about and it doesnt work any more and get rid of the monty python guy theres to much of him everywhere
pixar will hopefully now be making a good one with any luck that would be a great addition if its as good as philamagic which is fab!
hista is looking old and to be honest who cares ! most kids dont know what its about and it doesnt work any more and get rid of the monty python guy theres to much of him everywhere
pixar will hopefully now be making a good one with any luck that would be a great addition if its as good as philamagic which is fab!
surfsupdon
Well-Known Member
I think HISTA is phenomenal. The moving theater is a great touch, and I really enjoy "reconnecting" with the characters, even if Amy is absent! But I am a huge Honey/Shrunk the Kids Fan!! I enjoy this one more than Philharmagic too...call me nuts if you will...
On the other hand, b/c I was never a Muppets fan, I think their attraction is the worst 3-D film. In addition, I do not find the effects all that stupendous. It's the only 3-D attraction my family does not regularly experience. I've been on it twice. The others are usually every vacation!!
On the other hand, b/c I was never a Muppets fan, I think their attraction is the worst 3-D film. In addition, I do not find the effects all that stupendous. It's the only 3-D attraction my family does not regularly experience. I've been on it twice. The others are usually every vacation!!
Anybody remember Magic Journeys? I didn't like that one at all. It sounds weird, but clowns kinda freak me out, so 3D clowns...well...I'd much rather have the mice and snake from HISTA :animwink:
Philharmagic - Excellent!
Muppets - Really good (but I'm a big Muppet fan...)
HISTA - Enjoyed it, but it's probably time for something new
Tough to be a Bug - Haven't seen it (yet)
EO - Didn't see that one either
Philharmagic - Excellent!
Muppets - Really good (but I'm a big Muppet fan...)
HISTA - Enjoyed it, but it's probably time for something new
Tough to be a Bug - Haven't seen it (yet)
EO - Didn't see that one either
TheDisneyQueen
Member
HISTA is the worst, but PHILARMAGIC is the best 3d show ive ever seen
William Marsden
New Member
ScrapIron said:
pescador1f
Member
hista
so outdated looking, philharmagic is incredible.
so outdated looking, philharmagic is incredible.
Jekyll Baker
New Member
PoTCGuy said:
The only thing I remember from Magic Journeys is the Witch shooting lightning from her fingers (egad, 1983 was a loooong time ago).
I do think it is safe to say though, that WDW has a 3D movie for just about any body's taste.