You don't have to leave the park if you have a HHN ticket. You'll wait in one of the designated holding areas until they start opening the houses. It's called Stay & Scream. This gives you a head start on the people waiting at the gate.
Can you elaborate on the designated holding areas? Where are they? Is there a place to sit and how long are you normally there?
Would you recommend waiting in the holding area or jumping out to city walk for an hour or so before the HHN event starts?
Always subject to change, but generally there are two: in Finnegans and the street beside it (where the Blues Brothers play), or the courtyard in front of ET. Some years you can also cut over from IoA and wait on the side street near Dispicable Me.
Finnegans has tables if you want to eat--otherwise, you can sit on the curbs or steps outside. A few benches around ET, as well.
You have to make your way to a holding area by 5:00, when the park closes. You are usually there until 5:45 or 5:50.
You're much better off in a holding area than CityWalk. The holding areas get in 15 to 30 minutes earlier than people in CityWalk. Also, you get to bypass the metal detectors by the front gate, which quickly build up huge lines. Last year was an odd year, but generally I'm able to hit 2, sometimes 3 houses before the general public is let in.
Would you recommend waiting in the holding area or jumping out to city walk for an hour or so before the HHN event starts?
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.