JDM
New Member
If only this sort of diligence was more prevalent....I think this forum would be a lot better off.
But then, I'm just a "newbie"......
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
hall of presidents
- Thread starter chels26
- Start date
If only this sort of diligence was more prevalent....I think this forum would be a lot better off.
But then, I'm just a "newbie"......
smayco
New Member
While I do sometimes find the film boring, I just love watching the animatronics. I see something new each time...they whisper to each other, Lincoln checks his notes, etc. My 8yo son LOVES this attraction; it's actually his favorite!, so we wouldn't ever skip it even if we wanted to. :animwink:
~Sue
~Sue
CBOMB
Active Member
Rick Nelson "Garden Party".Interestingly, I've taken a lot of criticism for being too diligent. You can't please everyone, so, you've got to please yourself.
:lookaroun My age is showing...again. :lol:
RiversideBunny
New Member
What if the animatronic characters were various figures from the Colonial period rather than just presidents?
Guests could see, for instance, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, etc. discussing the need to establish an independent nation and how it should be done. Maybe the setting could be a tavern or an assembly room in Williamsburg, VA.
I think that focusing on the Colonial period, circa 1776, would be much more interesting and would fit in better with the theme of Liberty Square in the MK.
:king: Whoops. No more king --->
Guests could see, for instance, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, etc. discussing the need to establish an independent nation and how it should be done. Maybe the setting could be a tavern or an assembly room in Williamsburg, VA.
I think that focusing on the Colonial period, circa 1776, would be much more interesting and would fit in better with the theme of Liberty Square in the MK.
:king: Whoops. No more king --->
What if the animatronic characters were various figures from the Colonial period rather than just presidents?
Guests could see, for instance, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, etc. discussing the need to establish an independent nation and how it should be done. Maybe the setting could be a tavern or an assembly room in Williamsburg, VA.
I think that focusing on the Colonial period, circa 1776, would be much more interesting and would fit in better with the theme of Liberty Square in the MK.
:king: Whoops. No more king --->
The American Adventure at Epcot encompasses alot of those issues. I think it would be a great idea personally because I enjoy the educational aspect with my entertainment, but unfortunately, Im in the minority these days....
RSoxNo1
Well-Known Member
Why not turn into Letterman's bit, "Great Moments in Presedential Speeches"?
In all seriousness though, the novelty of seeing every president of the United States together communicating has worn off a bit. Perhaps the living character initiative needs to find it's way into the hall of presidents. Historical re-enactors do it all the time, why not have Q&A with certain presidents? Sure, it would be ill conceived to have Q&A with some of the more recent presidents, but with some of the founding fathers it could be quite interesting. Of course, you always run the risk of inappropriate questions, but you technically have that with other interactive shows as well.
In all seriousness though, the novelty of seeing every president of the United States together communicating has worn off a bit. Perhaps the living character initiative needs to find it's way into the hall of presidents. Historical re-enactors do it all the time, why not have Q&A with certain presidents? Sure, it would be ill conceived to have Q&A with some of the more recent presidents, but with some of the founding fathers it could be quite interesting. Of course, you always run the risk of inappropriate questions, but you technically have that with other interactive shows as well.
BiggerTigger
Well-Known Member
Both are good ideas but I think to "plus it" they should get the secret service involved. Say through embrionic cell research they brought back all the past and current presidents for a meeting. But there is a threat against national security and in the middle of the speaches secret service sweeps in with smoke filling the room and lights flashing and Jack Baurer saves the day (in 24 hours.) :lol:What if the animatronic characters were various figures from the Colonial period rather than just presidents?
Guests could see, for instance, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, etc. discussing the need to establish an independent nation and how it should be done. Maybe the setting could be a tavern or an assembly room in Williamsburg, VA.
I think that focusing on the Colonial period, circa 1776, would be much more interesting and would fit in better with the theme of Liberty Square in the MK.
:king: Whoops. No more king --->
hrcollectibles
Active Member
Hey! No thread hijacking allowed.
May you receive many year of a million dream prizes on your next trip to see the mouse
Thank you
RiversideBunny
New Member
I don't think Walt would be shocked to see that things evolve.
He expected it.
Look at the changes in the way Mickey and Donald and some others appear over the years.
He would like to see WDW remain as a wholesome place that continues to attract families who find it enjoyable. That means it must be a dynamic, rather than static, place.
He expected it.
Look at the changes in the way Mickey and Donald and some others appear over the years.
He would like to see WDW remain as a wholesome place that continues to attract families who find it enjoyable. That means it must be a dynamic, rather than static, place.
wdwCC
New Member
No I doubt he would be shocked. If they were to be that quick to change things, Carousel of Progress for example, would have been replaced a while ago. I think attractions Walt had a hand in, are less prone to replacement.I don't think Walt would be shocked to see that things evolve.
He expected it.
Look at the changes in the way Mickey and Donald and some others appear over the years.
He would like to see WDW remain as a wholesome place that continues to attract families who find it enjoyable. That means it must be a dynamic, rather than static, place.
JimboJones123
Well-Known Member
I think they should do HoP vs AA Rock-Um-Sock-Um-Robots. Bring the characters together and let them duke it out. Who would win, Presidents or American Icons? But be sure to add Elvis to team AA before hand. Oh, and Walt himself. They are a bit short handed.
jt04
Well-Known Member
:snore:
(sorry this is kinda late)(but).. when i started this thread i soo did not mean for it to get into a huge political debate. for that, i am sorry. Come one guys, this is a Walt Disney World site. Where we come together and appreciate one anothers obsessions. We should have a rule here, separation of DISNEY and state. If were gonna talk about HoP or any other thing then talk about it in Disney form.
jt04
Well-Known Member
GrumpyFan
Well-Known Member
You may be onto something.
But, instead of 24 HOURS, it would have to be 24 MINUTES. Regardless, you're on the right track. It could be fun, and definitely pull in the younger crowd.
Maybe, along these lines they could give the CMs working the attraction Black suits, dark sunglasses, and ear pieces dressed like Secret Service agents. Then in the pre-show they would "clear" everyone for a "special meeting" with the current and former presidents regarding an urgent matter involving national security that threatens to destroy this nation.
Emerald Rose
Member
I was just at Hall of Presidents mid-July and there was pretty good attendance. I was meeting some of my family in front of it and also saw pretty good attendance in and out also. Not full to capacity, but a steady stream of visitors. Good 75% full. I love HOP. I find it inspiring and a relaxing way to rest in the cool a/c for a bit. I always visit when we go to MK. The gift shop outside is nice too. All in all, I would be very disappointed if it closed.
IROC it
Member
When my kids are with me we do not miss HOP...
On my anniversary trip last year, we skipped it only because we were only there for one day...
My kids, 7 and 5, son and daughter respectively, absolutely love the HOP.
I actually get teary eyed... but hey, I love my country... and I love my country's history... I know the story line is a bit glamorized to be certain, but hey it's better than no HOP.
I will never miss HOP on any given year that I go... maybe on a trip, but if we go on multiple trips per year only.
Ironically, I've been to Epcot 3 times in the past 2 years... and have still never gone to AA - something about Mark Twain and Benjamin just don't seem to lure me in...
But I will try it out on the next trip... which may be this Christmas (trying to decide between a family DLR trip or a WDW trip for the holidays).
And FWIW, while I thought DLR's Innoventions/CoP total merge/rewrite was cool - they better not ever remove the COP from WDW's MK... Only upgrade the final scene a half decade and it's just great...
BTW- the kids love the COP too...
Trust me not all kids are so high strung on seeing Pixar only... It's in their upbringing - and personally, our TV and DVD player gets turned off from time to time... and sometimes we even tell the kids "no" when they ask for a new movie or toy or gadget that combines the two... We encourage them to know what life is... real life. We watch the news with them, and answer their questions... Just as Walt said in an interview, or intro, when Alice in Wonderland was about to be released, "Kids today are curious... about the world in which they live... people... places..." -something like that... Walt knew something that we all need to remember, and that is this: Kids are hungry for the facts. So give them the facts.
Sure there's a time and place for just pure "thrills and spills" and just a "show." But there is also a time for education and history lessons... And you don't get any combo of those aspects at say... Paramount, or Six Flags parks or the like.
Only in Disney Parks do you find a healthy balance of both.
I'm glad Walt saw the park finished (as his wife said at the dedication) -if only in his visionary mind's eye. He knew what he was doing.
If park management knows what's best, they will only seek to upgrade, while keeping the general integrity and purpose of, the HOP.
I trust it will be around for my grandkid's kids... so long as we have an America at least.
Long live the USA... hang the Que... well no, not really... WDW needs the Brits' money flow.:animwink: (BTW - anyone ever wonder if the Brits get offended in Liberty Square? I spoke with a fine chap in the line for Soarin' this last June and he seemed to not want to discuss the good ol' revolutionary era. Perhaps this is why the focus of the HOP is more on the Civil War?? Hmmm. I wonder if that plays a role at all...)
Anyway, I'm glad I've seen the HOP since '76.:sohappy: Ironic anniversary year, eh?
On my anniversary trip last year, we skipped it only because we were only there for one day...
My kids, 7 and 5, son and daughter respectively, absolutely love the HOP.
I actually get teary eyed... but hey, I love my country... and I love my country's history... I know the story line is a bit glamorized to be certain, but hey it's better than no HOP.
I will never miss HOP on any given year that I go... maybe on a trip, but if we go on multiple trips per year only.
Ironically, I've been to Epcot 3 times in the past 2 years... and have still never gone to AA - something about Mark Twain and Benjamin just don't seem to lure me in...
But I will try it out on the next trip... which may be this Christmas (trying to decide between a family DLR trip or a WDW trip for the holidays).
And FWIW, while I thought DLR's Innoventions/CoP total merge/rewrite was cool - they better not ever remove the COP from WDW's MK... Only upgrade the final scene a half decade and it's just great...
BTW- the kids love the COP too...
Trust me not all kids are so high strung on seeing Pixar only... It's in their upbringing - and personally, our TV and DVD player gets turned off from time to time... and sometimes we even tell the kids "no" when they ask for a new movie or toy or gadget that combines the two... We encourage them to know what life is... real life. We watch the news with them, and answer their questions... Just as Walt said in an interview, or intro, when Alice in Wonderland was about to be released, "Kids today are curious... about the world in which they live... people... places..." -something like that... Walt knew something that we all need to remember, and that is this: Kids are hungry for the facts. So give them the facts.
Sure there's a time and place for just pure "thrills and spills" and just a "show." But there is also a time for education and history lessons... And you don't get any combo of those aspects at say... Paramount, or Six Flags parks or the like.
Only in Disney Parks do you find a healthy balance of both.
I'm glad Walt saw the park finished (as his wife said at the dedication) -if only in his visionary mind's eye. He knew what he was doing.
If park management knows what's best, they will only seek to upgrade, while keeping the general integrity and purpose of, the HOP.
I trust it will be around for my grandkid's kids... so long as we have an America at least.
Long live the USA... hang the Que... well no, not really... WDW needs the Brits' money flow.:animwink: (BTW - anyone ever wonder if the Brits get offended in Liberty Square? I spoke with a fine chap in the line for Soarin' this last June and he seemed to not want to discuss the good ol' revolutionary era. Perhaps this is why the focus of the HOP is more on the Civil War?? Hmmm. I wonder if that plays a role at all...)
Anyway, I'm glad I've seen the HOP since '76.:sohappy: Ironic anniversary year, eh?