Hagrids Motorbike vs. Cosmic Rewind

[WondersOfLife]

Now THIS is a good poll.

I voted for Hagrids....

1). I don't get motion sickness on Hagrid's
2). It feels like a longer, more grand, experience to me.
3). There is at least a few animatronics.
4). You cannot easily see I giant box in the sky from the land.
5). It fits the land that the ride is represented in.


The only thing Guardians has as a one up for me is it is plus sized friendly.

 

[Married5Times]

so according to you I'm disqualified from commenting on dialogue and performances because I have not been on the attraction yet(which I actually have 2x already... but just for kicks I'll let you run with it)

but the performances are delivered to us via screens in the queue, no? and my computer uses, well, a screen.

Yep, those performances sure do come alive and become Oscar-worthy on Disney's large screen compared to my notebook. My computer just doesn't do it justice.

 

[Married5Times]

4). You cannot easily see I giant box in the sky from the land.

yes, Rewind's frontage is no Cadillac Range, Flight of Passage or Hogsmead castle.............it's the opposite of something wonderful to look

 

[JusticeDisney]

so according to you I'm disqualified from commenting on dialogue and performances because I have not been on the attraction yet(which I actually have 2x already... but just for kicks I'll let you run with it)

but the performances are delivered to us via screens in the queue, no? and my computer uses, well, a screen.

Yep, those performances sure do come alive and become Oscar-worthy on Disney's large screen compared to my notebook. My computer just doesn't do it justice.

You seem angry. LOL!

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

Now THIS is a good poll.

I love polls.

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

yes, Rewind's frontage is no Cadillac Range, Flight of Passage or Hogsmead castle.............it's the opposite of something wonderful to look

So maybe the poll should be Guardians vs Transformers?

 

[JT3000]

Couldn’t disagree more. I’ve ridden Guardians multiple times and I think the story line is great and the acting is much better than most attractions. Of course, at the end of the day, who really cares about anything other than the actual ride itself, which we found to be amazing. Hagrid’s is awesome too, but it’s not a one of a kind like Guardians.

Guardians isn't the only spinning coaster. There are a lot of them. Also, as themed entertainment (themed to an IP, no less), I think a lot of people would care about more than just the ride.

 

[JusticeDisney]

Guardians isn't the only spinning coaster. There are a lot of them. Also, as themed entertainment (themed to an IP, no less), I think a lot of people would care about more than just the ride.

It’s the only one in WDW and Universal and those were the places being discussed.

 

[JT3000]

It’s the only one in WDW and Universal and those were the places being discussed.

You didn't specify location, you just said "one-of-a-kind." There are no other attractions at either resort that do everything Hagrid's does. Using this criteria, they're both "one-of-a-kind."

 

[celluloid]

Nah, you’re dead wrong. I’m starting think you haven’t even experienced the ride.

The poster is not desd wrong. It's bad, particularly the reactions from the main cast on the left. The direction of pov acting and addressing audience is different from cinematic. The actors are skilled but it is different. It would have helped if the main screen with Eson had been produced to some degree first so the cast could have reacted to it.

Also, the screens in Guardians are poorly hidden or rather not seem less. They just stop and go to show building. Short.throw projectors are great, but some space and starfields.shkuod have been present on the floor.l,particularly of the first scene.

Also, Groot is barely in it besides the one line in preshow. Odd.

 

[marni1971]

One of them fits in its surroundings.

It’s the only one in WDW and Universal and those were the places being discussed.

Gringotts doesn’t have controlled spin?

 

[Married5Times]

Gringotts doesn’t have controlled spin?

of course Gringots mine carts rotate.............and I was going to point that out but I became too angry during the discussion earlier that I lost track.

for some reason there be a lot of "angry bro's" around these parts particularly when Counselor stops by.

 

[JusticeDisney]

You didn't specify location, you just said "one-of-a-kind." There are no other attractions at either resort that do everything Hagrid's does. Using this criteria, they're both "one-of-a-kind."

I didn’t have to specify. It was clear what was being discussed. Guardians is one of a kind on these properties. Fact.

 

[JusticeDisney]

The poster is not desd wrong. It's bad, particularly the reactions from the main cast on the left. The direction of pov acting and addressing audience is different from cinematic. The actors are skilled but it is different. It would have helped if the main screen with Eson had been produced to some degree first so the cast could have reacted to it.

Also, the screens in Guardians are poorly hidden or rather not seem less. They just stop and go to show building. Short.throw projectors are great, but some space and starfields.shkuod have been present on the floor.l,particularly of the first scene.

Also, Groot is barely in it besides the one line in preshow. Odd.

I think he’s dead wrong. Anyway, it’s subjective and to each his/her own.

 

[JusticeDisney]

One of them fits in its surroundings.


Gringotts doesn’t have controlled spin?

Nothing even close to what Guardians does. Apples and oranges.

 

[marni1971]

Nothing even close to what Guardians does. Apples and oranges.

Not according to the poll currently.…

So. How come it’s apples and oranges?

 

[marni1971]

of course Gringots mine carts rotate.............and I was going to point that out but I became too angry during the discussion earlier that I lost track.

for some reason there be a lot of "angry bro's" around these parts particularly when Counselor stops by.

You can’t talk logically to some people.

“Everyone’s got an opinion but mine is right”.

 

[Tbone1723]

Both phenomenal, IMO. But I went with Guardians because I haven’t ridden anything like it before.

What have you ridden even remotely comparable to hagrids? lol

 

[JusticeDisney]

Not according to the poll currently.…

So. How come it’s apples and oranges?

You’re combining different questions. Anyway, if you think that Gringotts and Guardians give the rider the same experience, that’s certainly your right. I will respectfully disagree, however.

 

[JusticeDisney]

What have you ridden even remotely comparable to hagrids? lol

Tron is remotely comparable. Maybe you just haven’t ridden that yet though. LOL!