Andrew C
You know what's funny?
Now, if I give you all a grape, will you stop arguing?
Is that natural behavior for most humans?
Now, if I give you all a grape, will you stop arguing?
Now, if I give you all a grape, will you stop arguing?
Is that natural behavior for most humans?
I don’t really see the distinction here. Birds don’t naturally answer questions in the wild. They have to be trained to do so the same way they would have to be trained to ride a bicycle.Depends how you define 'trick'. The show itself makes the distinction that they're not going to have the birds to 'unnatural' behavior like riding a tiny bicycle. So, none of those 'tricks.' But they do perform their natural behaviors at a learned cue... which can be called a trick if that's how you define trick.
Natural tricks: yes.
Unnatural tricks: no.
Now, if I give you all a grape, will you stop arguing?
I don’t really see the distinction here. Birds don’t naturally answer questions in the wild. They have to be trained to do so the same way they would have to be trained to ride a bicycle.
Have you asked all of them?Birds don’t naturally answer questions in the wild.
This is on the internet so it must be true.Why, just the other day I was taking a walk through the woods and heard several birds serenade me with "How Much is that Doggie in the Window". Very natural behavior for them.
Remember also that the talking/mimic segment is used as a lesson to the audience that birds are difficult pets and you shouldn't keep them as pets.
pretty humiliating for the animal
Have you asked all of them?
Well, now we have to define 'answer questions.' The birds aren't answering questions like humans do in conversations, although there are some parrots who, after a lifetime of training, seem to be able to give basic contextually correct answers, like gorillas who were taught sign language.
The birds with mimicry abilities learn to mimic all sorts of things, especially other bird and animal noises. If they're around humans, they mimic humans' speech, songs, and music. They're just being prompted with a reward to vocalize something they've heard. Just like the other birds are prompted to fly from here to there.
I suppose it would have been better for a show that presents the birds' natural behaviors to have a mimic show-off mimicking other birds.
This is different from say, training a bird to peck at certain keys on a musical keyboard to play at song. That would be an unnatural trick. But mimicking humans and anything else in their environment is a natural ability of mimic birds.
The payoff is at 1:45 to the end...
I think you must've been mistaken. The only song that birds can serenade you with is "The Tiki Tiki Tiki Room".Why, just the other day I was taking a walk through the woods and heard several birds serenade me with "How Much is that Doggie in the Window". Very natural behavior for them.
I think you must've been mistaken. The only song that birds can serenade you with is "The Tiki Tiki Tiki Room".
It seems like every time I see it there is a tour guide who interrupts. Very frustrating.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.