Agreed! FP+ did NOT force people to plan! LOL.
I LOVE planning. Before MDE I did the spreadsheet as well (laminated that ****** too, LOL). If I am being honest FP+ ADDED stress, and ruined part of my planning experience.
With a park hopper and the way we did our park days a dining reservation just meant you needed to at least be in or near that park at dinner, where we spent your day could be flexible based on crowds or change of mind.
As much as I love planning, I also like the ability to change it up if plans go awry. With FP+ I always felt like I was "locking down" another portion of my day.
In the paper FP days I don't think I once walked away from a trip without experiencing all the E-tickets rides we wanted.
Then again those were the days of hour long morning EMH and 3 hour long evening EMH.
Lots of factors at play here, I guess, but I will say this --- More top notch C, D & E ticket attractions cures a lot of woes.
DHS is a great example. TSMM a walk on or close to it the ENTIRE length of our trip. Could you imagine that a couple o' years back?