When was this? In the summer of 12 we were staying at the poly. When we checked in and went to our room there was yellow liquid in the toilet. I immediately called the front desk and without asking they offered to comp me 1/2 a nights room or switch the room. I took the discount and the room was cleaned within 30 mins.
Last spring I had an issue at a deluxe. Disney called me at home after my stay and paid for my wife and I to stay at another deluxe in a concierge water view room for 4 nights and put us on a VIP list so whenever we stay at that resort we get upgraded to concierge. Not all if their service is bad, I'd say my experience has been exemplary.
Your experiences are really troubling though. Does Disney still offer customer service classes, because if so, it sounds like some of their CMs need to take them.
....there has been a distinct and noticeable decline in Customer Service ...at WDW ....from the way that it had been ...over the past 3 years. Now ...is it coincidence ...or was it a different mode of training ...to wean guests off the
"we expect the world ...and you will provide it" attitude? It's as if a new corporate 'line' has been drawn for employees to toe ...because the bottom-line is all that matters now.
....5 yrs ago ..at POP ...my wife was holding onto the hinge side of the bathroom door frame ...when youngest daughter started to close the door. Wife's fingertips ...ring, middle, index fingers ...got crushed. Middle finger nail broke off just above cuticle line ...other 2 fingers ...smashed pretty bad. I called front desk ....and a paramedic team ...and the resort manager and assistant were at our room in 4 minutes!! They took care of my wife in stellar fashion. (I cringe when I tell this because she could have lost 3 fingertips!). Wife stayed at resort after she was calmed down and 'stable' ...I took youngest daughter to AK. Wife calls me ...there was then a big beetle type bug in the room ...she tells front desk ...they send an exterminator + assistant ...they move ALL the furniture ....check all drawers ...literally do the fine-tooth-comb treatment. No bug found (likely crawled in when paramedic had door propped open) ...but wife was worried it came thru air vent ...because renovation was going on in rooms above us. Manager then called her after the room was reassembled ...and asked her ..if she wanted to be relocated to another room ...no charge ...he'd even send a team of CM's to pack our stuff and move everything. Wife declined (with my urging ...because we had great location). When I got back ...she told me that every hour ...on the hour ...someone from concierge desk checked in on her to make sure all was okay (one time a female front desk CM they sent over ..popped open a can of soda for my wife ...because of difficulty holding it). Wife finally mustered enough composure to go to Concierge desk and thank the manager and staff ....and to buy some Advil at POP store. Manager told her that he was comping us a 1-1/2 days ...because her experience was "clearly not Magical" ...(between the accident and then the bug.)
....I wrote a glowing thank you letter to Disney after that ...because even though they comped us the room ...it was the extra effort displayed by the CM's to respond so quickly, and then actually check in on my wife repeatedly that I really focused on.
...skip ahead to 2012 ...and when the 'standard' in room fridges don't keep the soda (and beer cold) ...I'm told, "Well they really aren't fridges ...they're really 'coolers'. No apology ...no effort to see if it's really malfunctioning.
...then this year ...a completely y-attitude CM at check-in set the mood for the whole trip ...when she gave grief about room location request ...and getting credited for non-working fridge.
...it's as if they have been told, "Don't 'give away' service ....we're in this for the bottom-line". It's very noticeable when the CM's that you expect to go above and beyond ...start to do the minimum just to get by. We experience that at the rides, the shows, and the eating venues .....and it seems to be the "in" trend lately at WDW.