I liked the older system better for two reasons. One, a printed souvenir
Two, not needing to plan practically every hour of every day for the privilege of waiting on a shorter line on basically three attractions. It should be enough to book a trip for an amusement park with rides running all day to get in and just be able to do them.
As it is now, maybe my preference is to walk the parks clockwise. If the only available fastpass 30 days out( or whatever your window happens to be) in the am (before noon) for Space Mountain, is at 9:30 am, I can't really do that. I need to do all kinds of extra planning including checking back through an app or website multiple times to see if I can book a fast pass for when I might want to actually go on the ride without an hour plus wait time.
On our last trip, I did just that. I had everything planned out for me and DW. Upon arrival, after purchasing the magic band and having it activated, all my fastpasses were somehow cancelled, but we didn't know that until we showed up at the first fast pass. I knew my first fasspass was for Splash at 11:00 o'clock based on memory and being told I was all set by the cast member upon purchase and activation of the magic band.
Why would I question it? Castmember told me I was all set. They took my money with a smile.
We showed up at Splash at 11:05 only to be turned away and told to go back to the Town Square at the foot of Main st. where they had special castmembers to help us. It was only because DW chose to not get a magic band, that her ticket still had the scheduled rides as evidence, since she is my DW that the special castmember was somehow able to re-schedule MOST of my fastpasses to be within 20 min. of those of DW, with some changes. As a result, we were instructed to both go in together only after both fastpass start times had started.
I know it's a complex system, but at the time, it had been up and running for at least a year.
Add to all of this that my Mom was down and wanted to kind of plan with us, but still do her own thing, so we provided her with our "scheduled" fastpasses weeks before and she scheduled her own rides on the fast pass system based on meeting up with us when our rides had ended. With the snafu of our fastpasses the day of, we needed to scramble to meet her since our schedules were now different than originally planned.
It's just not as much fun, anymore.
Did it all work out? Kind of. It wasn't the end of the world, but it forces a lot of planning for rides that go on all day for a system that can ultimately boot you out through no fault of yours after all of the strongly recommended planning.
It's not like these are excursions off a cruise ship with local sub-contracted providers at ports of call.
Call me old fashioned, but I'm also not a fan of everyone looking at smartphones all the time and this whole FP+ only seems to require it.