I didn't realize how much I hate the new FP+ and miss the old paper fastpasses until I went to DL two weeks before WDW this January and got to experience both (because DL still has the old system).
Paper FPs are SO MUCH BETTER. Yes, they require being strategic and fast to get from one ride to the next but that is a GOOD thing. Reward people who are willing to get there early and work for their fast passes! ;-) It also keeps the FP lines shorter because not everyone is organized enough to plot their course with FP's in mind. I was able to get 6 FPs for one day in DL. I've never been able to get more than 3 in WDW because by the time my three are done, there are none left to be had. And you aren't limited to only one "top tier" ride in DL - if you can get there and there are still FPs available, you get it. So you can get all your top choices done in a day - again, if you are strategic. So, I feel like the old FP system rewards us seasoned guests who know how to navigate the parks, whereas the current system just rewards people with a smartphone.
Also...I REALLY HATE having to plan out every second of my day 60 days in advance. I'm a planner, I like to plan. But this is even too much for me. And because of the tier system, it often leads to more walking back and forth and back and forth and back and forth....because I can't plan based on location, I can only plan based on ride popularity.
I think DL has the best of both worlds. Paper FPs BUT if you don't want to have to run through the parks to get them, pay $10 more for MaxPass and do it from your phone. Same day, though. I think that's perfect. We didn't wait on a line longer than 20 minutes when I went, and it was during peak time (Christmas break). We got there at rope drop and stayed till closing and did EVERYTHING, some things two times. And we didn't pay for MaxPass.