I pretty much totally disagree. If you are going to WDW with the intent of riding rides and seeing attractions, as most infrequent or semi-frequent visitors are, then the more efficient you are at doing that, the more you can do, and the better your vacation will be. This is essentially the logic behind touring plans. Fastpasses as they are now are a key component to touring. I find it ridiculous for anyone to say that a 10 minute wait at a (loosely) scheduled time is somehow worse than a 60 minute wait at any time. And when it comes to a potential system for getting the Fastpasses ahead of time, which would save me the time and energy of having to run around the parks, I think that would be great. I would think that anyone who is a fan of Fastpasses would be excited about this concept...
And, let me add that I was at WDW in the late 90s, with 4 parks and no Fastpasses, and we waited in line forever for the big attractions, missed minor attractions because we ran out of time, and were exhausted at the end of the day. Our most recent trip last month, which also included a 4 year old, was much easier and we got more done because we had a plan ahead of time, knew what attractions to hit first each day, and knew when to get Fastpasses if we needed. Unless you are a frequent visitor or spending a long time there, a WDW vacation is not filled with relaxation and spontaneity. If you're looking for those things, go to the beach, go fishing, take a hike, etc.