Thanks so much for taking time to discuss with us fans, Eddie! I've been here from the beginning. I hope you can bear with me for my comments/theory/question.
I came up with this question while thinking about the Carousel of Progress, actually. I love the CoP, but I understand why it's perpetually on the chopping block. I think that time has changed the way people relate to the attraction. When the show opened in 1964, many of the people in the audience were alive during the time periods portrayed by the early scenes. I think that's what CoP was meant to be... a lifetime of progress. My wife and I often have discussions from time to time similar to the
Mindset List: our kids won't know what TV static is, or that TV really used to be black and white, or why you click on a picture of a floppy disk to save something in Microsoft Office (or that before
those floppy disks, there actually were floppy disks that were floppy). It's not that those early scenes aren't good anymore, but the world around them changed. No one in the audience today remembers the turn of the century. What used to be nostalgia is now more like a museum piece. I would love to see a nostalgic 90's scene more in the middle of the show: the dial-up modem sound, the kid remarking how fast this new 56K modem is as the audience sees a simple picture load on his CRT screen bit-by-bit and then slowly come into focus like we all did in 1996.
I think this concept is why something like Steamboat Willie on MSUSA doesn't bother me, even though many online seem to hate it. When Disneyland opened, there were only 50 years between the time period of MSUSA and the present day. Put something from 1928 in the cinema, and it would have stuck out much more. It would be the difference between remembering when they were little kids and then seeing something from when they maybe had kids of their own. Today, logically we know the dates don't line up if we think about it, but we didn't
experience it. No one is up in arms in Fantasyland: "I can't believe they used this 12th century masonry right next to this 13th century heraldry!" We have that "aesthetic distance", both in time and miles, from the medieval European themes that dominate Fantasyland. With every year that goes by, we are getting further and further away from 1901.
Based on your experience with Main St. in DLP, I'd love to know how you think something like this may eventually apply to the idea of what a Main St., USA is. I know you tried to take MSUSA into the Roaring 20's; do you think elements outside of the original turn of the century timeframe could be folded in organically, just as a real town would grow and change? What do you think MSUSA will look like in the future?