I can agree with the hotel vs motel argument, but I'm not buying the argument about transportation and proximity, nor the better restaurants. MK resorts are a long bus ride to AK. WL has boat access only to MK, no other transportation benefit. AKL has NO transportation benefit and is a long haul to MK. POP, AOA and CBR actually have skyliner stations on their resort property, whereas the BC/YC require a walk to the Epcot station to catch the skyliner. And, anyone can eat at Deluxe restaurants, so I don't see that as justification for paying more for the room.
We have stayed at all levels of resorts in WDW, and while AKL savanna view rooms are AMAZING (we got a sweet sale for our stay in 2002), the prices today for those rooms are not worth it to us, nor are the prices for the MK resorts (we stayed at the Poly in 2019). The extra hours perk does not justify the price for us. My $0.02, and YMMV.