I definitely agree it would be better than nothing. But there are many approaches they could take to have the ride operating at full capacity from the beginning of Early Entry - they could even have a separate EE BG lottery (which only resort guests would be eligible for) a few minutes before the general one. Disney choosing to forgo letting ~750 additional guests ride RotR would be a huge waste. If anything, this ride should be opening before everything else.
Imagine coming up with a special line system specifically for the purpose of handling uniquely high demand, and then using it as an excuse to restrict supply.
The majority of deluxe resorts have direct transportation to one of those two parks, so I'd expect at this point transportation factors in.I just don't understand leaving HS an AK out of the Deluxe Hours. Maybe if they offered hours there, as separate cost AH parties, but they are not even doing that. If you can open them 30 minutes early every day, you could keep them open later for 2 hours, once a week. When Deluxe hours were announced, I thought, this could be the benefit that makes on-site Deluxe "worth it" again. Then the details were announced...and nope (at least for us). Theoretically, if you check in on a Thursday and stay for 6 nights, you miss the MK one. For those of us with younger kids, the extra hours at Epcot are "eh". We'll most likely go to them but there won't be the same excitement factor any of the other 3 parks would bring.
Valid point, but WDW is 4 parks. The newest rides (for the most part) with the highest demand are left out.The majority of deluxe resorts have direct transportation to one of those two parks, so I'd expect at this point transportation factors in.
The whole reason for BGs in this case is that the ride isn’t reliable. They’ll never guarantee access to a resort guest during that half hour. The ride frequently doesn’t open with the park as it is.Even if only a couple hundred people ended up riding it would still be better than just not having it open at all, though.
Although depending on how many they called it could end up with a bottleneck and a longer wait than expected when the park first opens.
You're going to have to rope drop Test Track if you want to ride without paying or waiting.
The number of deluxe resorts with direct connections to DHS is similar to the number with connections to MK.The majority of deluxe resorts have direct transportation to one of those two parks, so I'd expect at this point transportation factors in.
It's considered a deluxe as is the swalphin for morning half EMH and night hourrsWhere would Shades Of Green fit into all this?
It's a stretch but I guess you can make that point.The number of deluxe resorts with direct connections to DHS is similar to the number with connections to MK.
I can directly swim to MK from Wilderness Lodge, so don’t leave that out.It's a stretch but I guess you can make that point.
The whole reason for BGs in this case is that the ride isn’t reliable. They’ll never guarantee access to a resort guest during that half hour. The ride frequently doesn’t open with the park as it is.
Resort guests can always purchase lightning access before off-site guests. What a perk! $80 for a family of four and you’re in!
They could theoretically just open the queue to anyone during Extra Magic Minutes if not for social media. Due to the internet, they’d be mobbed by day 3. So we have kind of forced their hand here.
Given that 7 hours or so of BGs routinely sell out in 6 or 7 seconds, there is little use in releasing 30 min of BGs to resort guests. They would need to just release the entire 7 am allotment to resort guests and have opted not to do so.It wouldn't be guaranteed access, though. Having it open doesn't guarantee access. I can't think of any operational reason not to do what I suggested.
If the ride isn't working, then obviously they woudn't call groups yet, the same way they don't when the park opens in that scenario.
You can't call a boarding group for people who aren't allowed into the park yet. It's just asking for fights every day at the front gateIt wouldn't be guaranteed access, though. Having it open and calling boarding groups doesn't guarantee access to anyone who doesn't have a boarding group. I can't think of any operational reason not to do what I suggested.
If the ride isn't working, then obviously they wouldn't call groups yet, the same way they don't when the park opens in that scenario.
Given that 7 hours or so of BGs routinely sell out in 6 or 7 seconds, there is little use in releasing 30 min of BGs to resort guests. They would need to just release the entire 7 am allotment to resort guests and have opted not to do so.
You can't call a boarding group for people who aren't allowed into the park yet. It's just asking for fights every day at the front gate
Karen staying offsite will give the poor CMs holding the rope blocking her from entering SO MUCH SCHNITZEL if her group is called and she can’t enter the park. It is simply not worth the headaches at the park entrance when the company already feels it is staffing enough rides for those 30 min. Not everything opens for early entry and that was always the case. The only option that would ever work (because it is most similar to EMH) is to just open the queue for early entry and then close it off to new people at park open and switch to VQ. Universal does this. This also prevents any issue if the ride simply isn’t ready to open. They never promised anything.Eh, I actually changed my mind. I still don't think there's any issue with calling boarding groups for people not allowed into the park yet -- that really doesn't matter in the slightest when it's such a small period of time -- but considering the window of time is so small, they wouldn't call more than a few boarding groups (if they were even able to open the ride).
They'd be calling less than a thousand people, and it's entirely possible that only a small percentage of them were actually staying on-site on any given day. It would be a waste of staffing to open the ride and have only a few dozen people ride it.
Karen staying offsite will give the poor CMs holding the rope blocking her from entering SO MUCH SCHNITZEL if her group is called and she can’t enter the park. It is simply not worth the headaches at the park entrance when the company already feels it is staffing enough rides for those 30 min. Not everything opens for early entry and that was always the case. The only option that would ever work (because it is most similar to EMH) is to just open the queue for early entry and then close it off to new people at park open and switch to VQ. Universal does this. This also prevents any issue if the ride simply isn’t ready to open. They never promised anything.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.