This is why Universal does not include Express Pass at all their hotels. The 3 top tier hotels are the only ones that have it included with stay. Otherwise availability is limited and is by purchase only, based on specific date and park. But it absolutely could be done at Disney with a few tweaks. And the money it generates would be cash Disney currently does not capture. It would have to be a pay to play option with limited availability but it is feasible. It could be included in some higher level packages but otherwise require purchasing for either length of stay or specific dates/parks, but with a tiered cost based on resort level and/or number of FP per day. Disney should make it available for purchase by everyone but give a significant enough discount based on resort level to be considered a valuable perk, and thereby an incentive for onsite stays and higher level resort bookings. Limited capacity would of course have to be maintained in order to (a) have significantly shorter wait times for FP to have perceived value to guests who are now paying for the privilege and (b) mitigate negative impact to standby wait times.
For me, this would be worth the cost if I no longer have to schedule ride times. If I still had to schedule every ride, much of the value would be lost and I would still consider it an inferior product.
Okay, I thought you were picturing Universal Express Unlimited which even if just limited to the deluxe resorts at Disney, would become a problem based on the number of those rooms available vs. e-ticket attractions.
What you really just mean is some different system without return windows and limits and with some sort of pay(extra)-to-play option.
I could see them raising prices and including it for "free" in some of the top rooms on property but if they were to start making it a discounted thing for on-property guests, that would encourage people to start pulling out calculators which is the last thing Disney wants.
The only way Disney can compete with their rooms if they aren't willing to play ball on competitive pricing, is on the exclusivity of their offerings which until now is what they've been doing on some level. For whatever weird reason, that's what they seem keen to cut back on, suddenly.
Likewise, while I'm sure there is something they
could do for a paid fastpass option, the Devil's in the details.
You say it would be worth the price to you but what's the price?
Universal Express as a standalone is $70 a day to skip the lines once and $90 for all-day line skipping in parks where the normal "standby" lines aren't typically all that bad to begin with. (relative to WDW, anyway)
Would you pay $70-$90 a day at Disney in addition to admission price?
Based on typical crowd levels, I bet a
ton of people would - way more than Universal which creates a whole new set of guest satisfaction problems for Disney so moving on:
Would you pay $140-$180 a day per person?
$280-$360 per person in addition to admission price?
At what price point would it not seem worth it to you, personally?
Remember, Disney already
does offer this today in the form of their private VIP tours with pricing between $425-$600 an hour with a 7 hour minimum:
https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/events-tours/private-vip-tours/
If that's worth it to you, they've already got you covered.