Does Roy Disney and Stanley Gold dislike WDWMAGIC.COM? ?

[jmarc63]

Hey guys and gals I'm back for a while. at least. been back in school working hard so my time is limited, but Ihave to take tome time to speakout on this battle with Eisner, and Roy Disney and Stanley Gold and how they pushed them out.

Well Earlier Tonight I logged on to www.savedisney.com ,since they just got started there isn't much Information and what they plan to do, but there are links to there emails and at the bottom of the page the had links to "other Disney related web sites that might be of interest" with a listing of nine sites

But I am a bit miffed that they missed WDWMAGIC.COM, But I really question the fact that they included Jim Hills site.

Does the mean that Roy and Mr Gold are validating Jim Hills site? what does this omission mean to WDWMAGIC.COM fans?

I am not sure what conclusions to draw from this

what do you think??

 

[ogryn]

I think, as someone posted in another thread, that WDWMagic is not *actively* following all the latest news on the main site.

Or maybe WDWMagic's owners didn't want to be associated with that site?

 

[Shaman]

Originally posted by jmarc63
But I am a bit miffed that they missed WDWMAGIC.COM, But I really question the fact that they included Jim Hills site.

Does the mean that Roy and Mr Gold are validating Jim Hills site? what does this omission mean to WDWMAGIC.COM fans?

I am not sure what conclusions to draw from this
what do you think??

Jim Hill's site is better than wdwmagic.com..........yea right.......

I guess they either forgot about us....or wdwmagic.com wants no affiliation with savedisney.com.....remember while there is alot of great proof out there that seems to make that site legit...neither Roy or Stanley have said in public to refer to that site....so there is still some (a small percentage perhaps) doubt as to whether the site is legit....


:lookaroun

 

[DVC_Couple_PA]

I'm 99.9% sure the site is legit. I questioned it myself but when I did a "whois" search on the domain name, the registrant is indeed Shamrock Holdings.

 

[Mr D]

Ever since I first joined its apparent to me that most members here are not dead serious Disney fans. Sure they are here and have plenty of comments but not a majority of it is serious discussion. Basically IMHO WDWMagic is just another fan site with a younger age group for members.

For news there is little to look for here. For gathering support there isn't much here either. Not as much as I have seen elsewhere, and frankly from experiance there seems to be more of a pro-Eisner support here and even at Disboards.com.

If I were Roy I couldn't see much here with the lukewarm overall feeling it has.

OTOH if Miceage had a discusion board......

 

[imagineer boy]

I'm sure Roy and Stan just never have found WDWmagic before. When I E-mailed Roy and told him about his sight. Who knows, maybe he'll discover it.

 

[imagineer boy]

Originally posted by Mr D

For news there is little to look for here. For gathering support there isn't much here either. Not as much as I have seen elsewhere, and frankly from experiance there seems to be more of a pro-Eisner support here and even at Disboards.com.

Umm, WDWmagic is the #1 rumor sight in the internet. It posted the first picture of the inside of a Mission space pod. And its also the first one to post many new rumors.

 

[daoVinci]

It frustrated me, too, but I'm 100% sure the site's legit. As I posted elsewhere, I got a reply from Stan Gold (sgold@shamrock.com, not the link on the site) stating that they did in fact establish the site.

I, too, mentioned WDWMagic to them. However, the site went for more than a week after Roy's resignation with no updates to the News & Rumors page. And nothing, really about the story since "Roy Disney Resigns" on Dec. 1.

Also, SaveDisney.com hasn't been updated since it first appeared, so even if they have taken notice of us, they may just be too busy strategizing to add anything to the site right now. I really don't think it's meant as a slight against WDWMagic.com.

 

[Shaman]

Originally posted by Mr D
Ever since I first joined its apparent to me that most members here are not dead serious Disney fans. Sure they are here and have plenty of comments but not a majority of it is serious discussion. Basically IMHO WDWMagic is just another fan site with a younger age group for members.

For news there is little to look for here. For gathering support there isn't much here either. Not as much as I have seen elsewhere, and frankly from experiance there seems to be more of a pro-Eisner support here and even at Disboards.com.

If I were Roy I couldn't see much here with the lukewarm overall feeling it has.

OTOH if Miceage had a discusion board......

While I respect your opinion, I think WDWMAGIC.com is among the top, if not the best disney fan site out there. There has to be something that brings you back to site...cause I doubt if it were bad you would return to it and post on the forums....

When you say this site does not have dead serious Disney fans...you fail to mention what your defition for "dead serious Disney fan" is......I think you also fail to realize the huge amount of CMs (both past and present) that are members...and discard all great people that collect photos and info that combined with the information on the main site offer alot to all interested in Disney.....

To me no one beats WDWMAGIC.COM......but then again thats just my opinion.

 

[SpongeScott]

Originally posted by objr
While I respect your opinion, I think WDWMAGIC.com is among the top, if not the best disney fan site out there. There has to be something that brings you back to site...cause I doubt if it were bad you would return to it and post on the forums....

When you say this site does not have dead serious Disney fans...you fail to mention what your defition for "dead serious Disney fan" is......I think you also fail to realize the huge amount of CMs (both past and present) that are members...and discard all great people that collect photos and info that combined with the information on the main site offer alot to all interested in Disney.....

To me no one beats WDWMAGIC.COM......but then again thats just my opinion.

:sohappy:

And to Mr D, if you dislike this board so bad, why do you keep coming back? Seems like you would have written us off a long time ago.

 

[mkt]

Originally posted by Mr D
Ever since I first joined its apparent to me that most members here are not dead serious Disney fans. Sure they are here and have plenty of comments but not a majority of it is serious discussion. Basically IMHO WDWMagic is just another fan site with a younger age group for members.

For news there is little to look for here. For gathering support there isn't much here either. Not as much as I have seen elsewhere, and frankly from experiance there seems to be more of a pro-Eisner support here and even at Disboards.com.

If I were Roy I couldn't see much here with the lukewarm overall feeling it has.

OTOH if Miceage had a discusion board......

would we be more diehard if we were to show up at Eisners house with pitchforks and fire?

give me a break

 

[Erika]

Originally posted by objr
While I respect your opinion, I think WDWMAGIC.com is among the top, if not the best disney fan site out there. There has to be something that brings you back to site...cause I doubt if it were bad you would return to it and post on the forums....

When you say this site does not have dead serious Disney fans...you fail to mention what your defition for "dead serious Disney fan" is......I think you also fail to realize the huge amount of CMs (both past and present) that are members...and discard all great people that collect photos and info that combined with the information on the main site offer alot to all interested in Disney.....

To me no one beats WDWMAGIC.COM......but then again thats just my opinion.

Couldn't have said it better myself.

 

[Pixie Duster]

Good idea Rob

 

[Testtrack321]

The reason why wdwmagic.com isn't there is because it isn't a huge Eisner bashing site. Sure, we hate him here, but what has Steve written up on the site that would make him bad, such as Jim has done?

 

[Mr D]

Well I pretty much got the expected responce that there is some folks here that care so thus I retract my statements said earlier.

And yes WDWMagic is ahead of Disboards in rumors.

Sometimes I catch a lot more fish using dynomite... :lol:


My respects to the CM's that frequent here, without them it would indeed be a dull place.

Roy and Stanley are probably in a bit of a funk, DIS stock is heading up, profits are coming in from DVD sales and basically its hard to make Eisner look bad at the moment.

But time stands still for no man and things can change overnight.

 

[Bagheera]

Originally posted by Testtrack321
The reason why wdwmagic.com isn't there is because it isn't a huge Eisner bashing site. Sure, we hate him here, but what has Steve written up on the site that would make him bad, such as Jim has done?

And MousePlanet is a huge Eisner bashing site? Can you point out some of it to me? We go to great lengths to have fair, accurate reporting, thankyouverymuch.

 

[WDWFREAK53]

Originally posted by Mr D
basically its hard to make Eisner look bad at the moment.

I beg to differ :lookaroun

 

[pinkrose]

Originally posted by WDWFREAK53
I beg to differ :lookaroun

:lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[mkt]

Originally posted by WDWFREAK53
I beg to differ :lookaroun

well... I can't say it's a far stretch... they're both evil. At least MJ could dance.

 

[MouseMadness]

Originally posted by WDWFREAK53
I beg to differ :lookaroun

*dies* :lol:

That's one of those things that will have me giggling like an idiot at random moments while driving.