That ADR thing is a pain in my tushie. Miss the good ole days when my WDW vacations didn't require multiple ADRS.
I prefer the Hopper because I'm pretty much a park warrior and like to stay out most of the day, but if you have young kids it may not be as big of a deal, especially if you need to return for naps and such.
That said, I do like having the option of escaping a park as it possibly gets crowded or I get kind of bored with it for the day. While we take advantage of EMH and use the DDP so we get ADRs, I find it beneficial to try to go to the parks in the morning that don't appear to be getting much bus traffic, and so far that usually pays off. But this strategy doesn't work quite as well with rigid scheduling.
I can also finish up AK and DHS, at least what I want to do in under 5-6 hours most of the time, and even that's pushing it, so the ability to travel over to MK or EPCOT is a must for me.
If I stayed at a Epcot Resort I would definitely do the hoppers for the dining aspect...but on our last stay with the hoppers we only used it twice during a 10 night stay at a +$300 cost.
Yes, I generally plan our entire vacation. That being said, I am not so rigid that I must stick to the plan without room for adjustment. We generally keep an idea of what we want to do, but don't mind switching it up if we decide on something else.
This is generally what we do. We do plan ADRs around what parks we'll be visiting but we've been known to change. We also plan around extra magic hours.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.