TrevorA
Active Member
- In the Parks
- Yes
Hey Kermit! I guess I want to put in my suggestions
Nice to see you, Quad! :wave:
---TrevorA
Hey Kermit! I guess I want to put in my suggestions
Hey Kermit! I guess I want to put in my suggestions.
Ok, first thing's first- I agree with everyone else. All you are doing is taking rides from other parks and bunching them together. Maybe one thing you should do is take some rides that have already been created and put them in, but also add your own rides. One thing you could do (with permission from the users) is put attractions in that were created on this forum.
Here are my comments on each land:
Mainstreet: this place is pretty much good! One thing though is maybe you could create some new type of transportation to be used along it, instead of the usual omnibus, fire truck, trolly, and horseless carriage. Also, how will Mainstreet be themed? Is it like Main Street USA? Or will you theme it to look like an old Croatian street? What you put in it truly depends on how you will theme it.
Adventureland: OK, first of all, I would like to (once again) stress theming. Everything you put into this land fits "adventure", but not all types of "adventure". If I was you, I would limit what I put in for maybe one or two themes. For example, I would make a theme jungle, where I put in jungle cruise, Tarzan Rocks!, Indiana Jones, Swiss Family Tree house, and Haunted Mansion. I may also want to put Flying Carpets in there, but maybe along the edge..."outside" of the jungle. Pirates of the Caribbean is a great ride, but may not fit in Adventureland. Of course, there are many ways you could do this, not to mention it would be great if there were some original ideas in this land!!
Wild Westernland: I see where you are going with Toy Story Midway Mania. Maybe one thing I would do is change it to maybe a western-version of it, calling it "Woody's Shooting Gallery" or something, where it can still be 3D and all, but it fits the land. Also, instead of Diamond Horseshoe revue and Fantasmic!, you could put something new and original. I would also love to see a new concept with the theme for what "western" really is. You need to remember that this is in Croatia, which means that an American frontier may not be the same as a Croatian frontier. Do some research, I'd be excited to see a whole new theme.
Critter Country: here's the deal- I agree with everyone else. CTX and Nemo do NOT go well with the theme of Critter Country. But, like you say, they probably can still go together with Splash Mountain, etc. Maybe you could change it to something new? What I'm saying is, make a new land, not Critter Country, but something entirely new that can connect it all together.
Fantasyland: :hurl: this needs work. No offense, but [1] there is too much going on, too many attractions compared to the rest of the park, and [2] nothing in here is original. Fantasyland creates a perfect opportunity for creating something new and creative, so try making your own stuff for this, or improving on things you have chosen. Have fun with it!
Mickey's Toontown: like Fantasyland, have fun with this one, don't make a usual toontown, try new things. You could probably find a new setting for the characters to live in, or some new environment to meet them. With Toontown, you have ultimate blue sky!!
Tomorrowland: I'm not going to put much in this one. You have good theming, but nothing original. Try new things, design new attractions. You don't just need what are at other parks, I would love to see originality.
As you can see, imagineering requires more than just putting rides together. As an imagineer, I would suggest the following things:
1)Theme- an entire land could change in mood, tone, and style just by a sudden change in theme. Think about it.
2)Originality- try making new things. There isn't much fun in imagineering if you don't have part of your mind in your projects. You are very creative, I bet you could find something cool to put in.
3)Balance- try not to put a huge amount of attractions in one land, but barely any in another. Also, avoid too much dining. I'm noticing 5-10 restaurants per land!!! Maybe you should limit it to 1 or 2, and work on fun ideas to go with the land
4)Detail :veryconfu- Haha I'm not sure what to call that one. Don't just design attractions and put them into lands. This really goes with theme. I would love to see detail in gardens, trashcans, food carts, bathrooms, fountains, etc.
I don't mean to offend you at all with any of my comments. These are just things to think about when you make new things. They are more meant to give you wiggle room and suggestions on improving, like constructive criticism. Have fun with this project!!
Quad422:wave:
What do you mean by that?
/\ It doesn't really, they can work in the same park but they need to be separated from each other and put into different lands. Imagine how weird it would be visiting the cartoon world of animals then suddenly be menaced by a life-like prehistoric monster.
This is how "Animal Kingdom/Critter Country" would feel like and look like.
http://images.businessweek.com/ss/06/05/theme_parks/image/splashmountain.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v401/merwea/SplashMountain.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_h5dtIEczaKk/R-xemZeI6uI/AAAAAAAAAB4/dMM_gk_0uSQ/s320/dinosaur.jpg
http://www.intercot.com/themeparks/animalkingdom/images/photos/countdown.gif
http://www.pbol.com/pechter/disney/disney_ak98/images/large/disani16.jpg
http://land.allears.net/blogs/photoblog/Canada_pavilion_in_Epcot.jpg
http://www.whimsicalworldtravel.com...2009/09/epcot.victoriagardens.susanspidle.jpg
http://static.panoramio.com/photos/original/1659123.jpg
http://adisneyworldsports.disney.go.com/media/dwws_v0220/en_US/pdf/NemoandFriends.jpg
http://davelandweb.com/indianvillage/images/50s/KTPBKYC_9_2_59_N13B.jpg
http://www.jtcent.com/disneyland/critter/images/crioutmsc1.jpg
Now picture all of that stuff overlooking this:
http://ocresort.freedomblogging.com/files/2009/12/islandandriver-300x251.jpg
How does that look to you guys, does that look like an Animal Kingdom?
/\ It doesn't really, they can work in the same park but they need to be separated from each other and put into different lands. Imagine how weird it would be visiting the cartoon world of animals then suddenly be menaced by a life-like prehistoric monster.
This is how "Animal Kingdom/Critter Country" would feel like and look like.
http://images.businessweek.com/ss/06/05/theme_parks/image/splashmountain.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v401/merwea/SplashMountain.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_h5dtIEczaKk/R-xemZeI6uI/AAAAAAAAAB4/dMM_gk_0uSQ/s320/dinosaur.jpg
http://www.intercot.com/themeparks/animalkingdom/images/photos/countdown.gif
http://www.pbol.com/pechter/disney/disney_ak98/images/large/disani16.jpg
http://land.allears.net/blogs/photoblog/Canada_pavilion_in_Epcot.jpg
http://www.whimsicalworldtravel.com...2009/09/epcot.victoriagardens.susanspidle.jpg
http://static.panoramio.com/photos/original/1659123.jpg
http://adisneyworldsports.disney.go.com/media/dwws_v0220/en_US/pdf/NemoandFriends.jpg
http://davelandweb.com/indianvillage/images/50s/KTPBKYC_9_2_59_N13B.jpg
http://www.jtcent.com/disneyland/critter/images/crioutmsc1.jpg
Now picture all of that stuff overlooking this:
http://ocresort.freedomblogging.com/files/2009/12/islandandriver-300x251.jpg
How does that look to you guys, does that look like an Animal Kingdom?
Yes, it does look like an Animal Kingdom.
I think u guys should just give up on trying to tell him what's wrong with the consistency of his park. He obviously isnt getting it
Just a few friendly point I would like to make :wave:Thanks for the comments. The Penguin Tiki Room was an abandoned concept for Tokyo Disneyland. I had the Croatian ride names instead of English because the ride names in EuroDisneyland are in French. TSMM in Wild Westernland was an idea I got from another guy's idea for Disneyland Canada. He put that ride in his Wild Westernland. CTX and Nemo fit into CC becuase I believe the word "critter" is a synonym for "animal." Dinosaurs and fish are animals, so they should belong in CC. In Tomorrowland, the theme is the future (Carousel of Progress, WEDWay PeopleMover), space (Space Mountain, Cosmo Jets), and transportation (World of Motion, Skyway). Other attractions in the area were modified (Meet the World, Eternal Seas) to fit the Croatian culture.
Do you understand now?
Just a few friendly point I would like to make :wave:
I really agree with everyone else about your critter country. Yes, critter loosely means animal and all of those attractions are centered around animals. However, you should consider the other elements of those attractions in terms of theming. The current critter country areas have a western/wilderness/cottage feel to theme. It will be impossible to utilize these facade types with attractions about nemo and dinosaurs. Even if you were to change the type of facade you use for buildings in this area, how could you do it in a way that would make sense with the attractions you are including. The buildings should be simular in some way. How would a cottage type building look by a building that looks like a museum (dinosaur). How do Australia and the ocean, Canada, time travel, and the wilderness with talking animals relate to one another? That would be like justifying putting the hall of presidents and dinosaurs in the same area because they are both about the past.
These attractions also have very different tones. Dinosaur is very life like and serious where as nemo and pooh are very imaginary and playful. This would be like having the tower of terror next to it's a small world.
And how does O' Canada fit with everything else? Again the tone is very different from the other attractions you are proposing. And correct me if I am wrong, but I don't think O Canada is about animals even if it contains them. Now, if you did a brother bear attraction (which takes place in Canadian wilderness) which is about the animal/human connection, that would be much more approprate for this area
I also do not feel that midway mania belongs in fronteirland. If you were to make your own version that focused on woodie and had a purely cowboy theme, that would be more appropriate. As it stand, midways and talking potatoes have nothing to do with the wild west. Again I say, consider ALL of the elements of an attraction and not just one.
More to come...
Please do not blow me up!
What?
Yes, it does look like an Animal Kingdom.
It seems that you just throw stuff together, and HOPE it might go together. (Sorry to say) I think yu have good ideas, butyou cloud them too much with an over poplation of attractions (most of which dont fit)
Why not try and think of your own ideas? Just saying.
As said before, it seems that sme ideas, like the Seas with Nemo and Friends, O Canada and CTX fit in. Yes they are "animals"but they arent "critters", Dinosaurs are scaled reptiles, Fish are well fish, and O Canada just kinda fits in... Sorry to say.
Im just tellling you what i think
Are you saying that critters have to be small and furry?
Yes Kermit, please defend your ideas in more detail. We all want to help you, and we all want to know what you're thinking so we CAN help you. Obviously not many of us agree with your ideas, we just want to hear what makes you agree with them. Like Crazy Harry said, please debate your beliefs about this resort with us with some good reasons.
Also critters are defined as "creatures," yes...but when you think of the word "critter" you don't think of dinosaurs, fish, or the Canadian wilderness. You usually think of the animals that one would find on such attractions as Splash Mountain or the Country Bear Jamboree, not Countdown to Extinction or the Seas with Nemo and Friends. The other part that we're disagreeing with you about on Critter Country/Animal Kingdom is that thematically it wouldn't work. Sure if it's themed to animals it would be one bizarre land. First of all it's located on the side of the Rivers of America which doesn't make any sense at all as two of the attractions don't even take place in America. Splash Mountain takes place in the post-war American South, so that makes sense. Countdown to Extinction takes place in the far-off future and is really undetermined in exact location. I guess it is in America though because in a way it's home of origin was "Dinoland, U.S.A." The Seas with Nemo and Friends obviously takes place in Australia, and last time I checked that is nowhere near the American frontier. O, Canada is technically in North America but not the United States of America. The Indian War Canoes I can understand so I'll leave those alone.
But basically picture yourself riding on top of the old riverboat. You look at all the Frontierland beauty then turn and see the beginnings of Critter Country. You see Splash Mountain and really think, "Wow this really is the frontier." But then suddenly the plant-life becomes all tropical and turns into a mesh between Future World and a State Museum. A dinosaur statue and a bunch of animatronic seagulls screeching "MINE" appear out of nowhere. Then the North American wilderness comes back but rather than being the wilderness of the American frontier, it's the wilderness of the Canadian frontier! And then London suddenly appears with Winnie the Pooh and Tigger too! As your boat leaves you turn around and think...huh?
Really it kind of just seems like you wanted those attractions in the park and just wanted to put them in somewhere, so you chose Critter Country. But the only ones that really fit in Critter Country are Splash Mountain and the Canoes. And I think you had Pooh's Hunny Hunt in there too, so I'll give you that one as well, as Disneyland made the unfortunate move of replacing the Country Bears with the Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh.
But the rest of them don't fit in at all...O, Canada is just wilderness-esque which would fit in with Critter Country if it was themed to something revolving around critters. So why don't you take the concept of O, Canada and turn it into something that's not about Canada. Something that fits in with the cartoonish-wilderness theme of Critter Country and turn it into something entirely different! You could do a lot with this, I know you can. As for the Seas with Nemo and Friends. Why don't you move that to a possible future second park? Or you can get rid of that particular attraction and create an entire new land beyond the berm of the park that is themed to underwater creatures. It could be a land that appears to be underwater but isn't, and it can have attractions from Finding Nemo, the Little Mermaid, and pretty much any other ocean-themed Disney movie out there. That may seem like a mesh-up of ideas, but really they work together because they're all in a land that would be able to make them work together. For Countdown to Extinction, if you really want that move it to Tomorrowland or just get rid of it all together. If you have an Indiana Jones ride already in the park, then it may clash with a very similar attraction. Not saying Indy has ever discovered dinosaurs before, it's just they have the same attraction vehicles (With different paint jobs) and they follow the EXACT SAME TRACK. I'm not even joking you, many people don't know that Countdown to Extinction (DINOSAUR) follows the same track layout as Indiana Jones Adventure in Disneyland in California and Tokyo DisneySea. After the failure remodeling of Tomorrowland back in 1998 or so, Disney found that it wasn't successful as they would have liked it to be (It was supposed to be the fabled "Tomorrowland 2055") so they started looking for ways to fix it up a bit. The first thing they wanted to do was bring some new life into the Primeval World diorama and get rid of Honey, I Shrunk the Audience which had just opened with the recent changes. They then came up with the idea of gutting the theater and turning it into the Dino Institute of California, being the extensive queue for a brand new version of Countdown to Extinction. The show building would have been beneath Space Mountain, called for the gutting of a storage building, stretched out a bit into the parade garage behind Main Street, and into the Primeval World Diorama. Passing trains would be able to see the time rovers filled with happy (And not-so-happy) guests rolling around the dinosaur-inhabited landscape as they attempt to make it home in time before an oncoming asteroid hits. The painted backdrop would be removed and an entire three dimensional jungle would be added, making the Primeval World darker (It would be dark, so think riding a train inside the Knott's Berry Farm Log Ride with dinosaurs in it), bigger, more realistic, and more exciting! The trains presence would be justified by a bunch of time traveling gear left carelessly along the edge of the Grand Canyon. The train would set off the machinery and cause them to go temporarily back in time to the age of dinosaurs. So Countdown to Extinction could work in Tomorrowland, but not in Critter Country.
Now I like you Kermit, you're a nice guy and a friend, and don't think of me or anyone else as a horrible bully, I'm just giving you my input and trying to help you out here.
None of your ideas are bad, they are good, we're just trying to help you out over here. When I created one of the very first open brainstorming threads back in 2008 over on Visions Fantastic (Disneyland Australia), I made it with the intention of bringing a bunch of Imagineers together to create one killer theme park/resort. I wanted to share a few of my ideas then have them come in and give me their input and share some of their own ideas. Then I would give them my input and they would give me their input, and so on so forth. By sometime last year (2009) we had an almost complete resort which had gone through what seemed to be multiple-changes. We started out with something pretty awesome, then turned it into something REALLY awesome by moving attractions to other parks, deleting things we didn't think that fit in too well with their surroundings, and even starting from scratch on some lands. And that is why there are have been so many open brainstorming threads to follow. The point of an open brainstorming thread is so that you and many others can come together and make one amazing project. Everyone on WDWMagic is a brilliant Imagineer and if we ALL got together to make one resort, I can only imagine what would come out of it. :animwink:
So please Kermit we're just trying to brainstorm with you, please share with us all of your thoughts on our questions. :animwink:
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.