yensidtlaw1969
Well-Known Member
In fairness, what exactly were they supposed to do? As you said, the OT characters were aging. The Force Awakens basically was a recreation of A New Hope, to a fault - much more shared DNA there than any of the prequels had. Agreed that bad writing let down the newer generation cast and people didn't actually take to them, but when tickets were selling and toys were selling it wasn't irrational for Disney to think they had something.GE is like the rest of the prequels... scorned because the company was making a strategic choice to try to create new space for the stories with new characters... instead of just 'recreate the old movies'. They had aging characters from the OT, they banked on their new cast and new timeline. A move that was hobbled by the fact the public didn't embrace the new cast and timeline.
I applaud their direction, they just bet on the wrong horse. The leaders were going to force that team to win.. and the public wasn't having it.
Luckily we have new creative leads in SW who actually know what makes for good star wars content.
The other factor is that they nearly overcome this with Rise of the Resistance, which is (by all accounts other than one or two) an absolute smash. As if the answer is, as ever, to make a thing that's so good on its own it transcends the source material. A version of Rise based around the original trilogy would certainly also be popular, Rise as built is so popular that the needle doesn't have much space to move. It's really everything else in the land that's the problem because none of it hits the way Rise does.