Differences Between Disneyland and WDW

Agent

New Member
Original Poster
A few months ago, I asked for opinions on the differences between the two parks. I am finally back and have a chance to post a report on what I noticed.

First - Disneyland is far more charming and intimate than WDW (which is grander and more enveloping). I was really surprised by this. I knew it was smaller, but Disneyland doesn't feel smaller (at least to me). I don't know how to explain it except to say that it seems like Disneyland gets all the money for nice queues and building facades, while WDW gets kind of shorted on that end.

I did not get to ride a couple of rides I wanted to ride (Lincoln [it was closed], Monorail, Disneyland Railroad, Pinocchio, Its a Small World and the Submarine Ride), but that just means I have to go back. :) It was absolute fun for me to ride Mr. Toad (even if it isn't as "wild" as the old WDW version). I took a picture just before we got on and sent it to my brother. He was very jealous.

Differences in rides between the parks:

Space Mountain - winner is Disneyland. I have ridden it at WDW countless times but it didn't include the soundtrack or anything that adds to the Disneyland version. I can't imagine that it would be a big fix to add to the WDW version. Also liked the side-by-side design. I wish WDW would go back to the 4 seat design rather than the current 3 seater, or use this 6 seat design, if possible. If it had not had that feature, my youngest son would not have ridden it as I wouldn't have been able to sit next to him. In the end he was yelling, "This is awesome" as we were riding, so he didn't need me, but he would not have gotten in the car if it was the WDW setup.

Pirates - Again, I have to go with the Disneyland version. The only thing it needed was the smell of burning embers and the illusion would have been complete. At the end scene you have stuff hanging from the ceiling rather than just seeing a plain painted ceiling at the top. It just adds to the experience and is missing from WDW. Yes, the ride at WDW is longer, but this one is still better.

Star Tours - My kids dragged me on this, even though I told them it was the same as in DHS. And I was right. Same thing. You've been to one, you've been to both of them.

Haunted Mansion - My eldest son and I went on this together while my wife and youngest went on the Canoes. Shorter, but still fun. I think I have to go with WDW on this one.

Now for other rides, The aforementioned Canoes. My wife and son had a blast on them. The cast members were great and lots of fun according to my wife.

Indiana Jones. Where do I start. Just an awesome ride. We rode standby (45 minute wait - not bad at all) and were ready to go by the time we boarded the "truck." I didn't realize how intense the ride would be, but my youngest came through it all right. Really a fun ride. I haven't ridden Dinosaur at Animal Kingdom yet, but my understanding it is it the same ride system. Now I have a reason to go to WDW - to ride Dinosaur and make a comparison. Really a fun ride. Almost like a roller coaster.

Now for DCA. This park gets a lot of grief. Maybe that was well deserved before Cars Land opened. Even now, it is not a full day park. We rode every ride but two (Soarin' and Tower of Terror, both of which we have ridden at WDW) and we were still done by 5:00. We went back for the 9:00 World of Color show. Now time for my first real complaint. We bought 2 of the Mouse Ears that are timed to go off with the show. One ended up not working. I know we could have taken them back, but by that point, the show was about to start. Also, we seemed to be the only ones with these hats. Call me crazy, but maybe if DCA lowered the price a bit on these things ($25/each) they would have more people buy them and thus have a more complete effect. They would make up losses in decreasing the price by an increase in the sales of the hats. Anyhow, economics lesson over. Plus we did get to see the fireworks at Disneyland when we left the park.

There is still some work to be done. Maybe there doesn't need to be a bakery tour. Change it our with something else. I did check out the Fantasy Faire model section. It was cool, but could have used some filling out with some more behind the scenes stuff.

Cars Land was awesome. Yes, Radiator Springs is basically a next generation Test Track, but it is fun. I wish they had the technology or the money to allow your car to really change colors when in Ramone's shop. That would be a cool addition.

Mater's ride was basically a "Whip" with the additional effect of a figure 8 in the track. Lots of fun. I am not a big "Larry the Cable Guy" fan, but the stuff he said while loading and unloading the ride was pretty funny (not to mention his song, "Dad Gum" the words of which are all "dad gum").

Luigi's ride was fun as well. Nice to see that they were able to reinvent an older ride that didn't work previously into something that is fairly smooth in operation.

Paradise Pier - It is what it says it is, a throwback to boardwalk amusement parks. Of course Walt Disney built Disneyland to get away from these types of parks and their barkers (which are present at DCA and various locations at WDW) in the first place. But I digress. The rides, as re-themed are fine. The roller coaster is fun and the other rides are also enjoyable. Word of warning - the swinging cars in the Ferris Wheel REALLY swing. We had to watch Cast Members clean out a car after one person lost their lunch in the car.

Little Mermaid - Good dark ride, but not great. Peter Pan at WDW beats it (disclosure, I love Peter Pan at WDW). I think the Imagineers have started to lose themselves in the technology and forgotten the story. Yes all the best parts from the movies are there, but it just seems to be missing something.

Monsters, Inc. - Okay, I was ready to enjoy this ride. It is horrible. The characters are like early first generation animatronics without an major articulation. They are saying lines, but their mouths don't move. Yes their are some cool effects, like Randall disappearing or changing colors, but that is about it. The best effect they have is at the end of the ride when you meet Roz. What she says seems to change based on what is happening in your car. For instance, in the car in front of me, there was a woman in the front seat. Roz said something about the woman in the front seat. I filmed the whole ride for my brother because my Niece and nephews are huge Monsters, Inc. fans. I had my camera up to get a shot of her talking and she said, "Oh great. Another camera." The individual statements were a great addition, even if they are canned and someone just hits a button for the appropriate line. Unless you can see no wrong with Monsters, Inc. or Monsters U, avoid this ride.

Like I said, due to circumstances beyond control, our day at Disneyland was curtailed and some of the stuff we wanted to do, we couldn't do. We just have to go back.

If you have any questions, post them and I will do my best to answer them.

Also, as an aside, if you like sushi, there is a hole in the wall place called "Tokyo Love." It is excellent. I am not affiliated with the restaurant in any way. My wife loves sushi and we hadn't had it in Southern California yet. We looked this place up, it had great reviews, and deservedly so. Check it out if you get the chance. Don't let the exterior fool you.
 

TuffyCatt

Active Member
We just got back from our first trip to Disneyland too! I liked reading your comparisons and opinions, thanks for sharing!

First - Disneyland is far more charming and intimate than WDW (which is grander and more enveloping). I was really surprised by this. I knew it was smaller, but Disneyland doesn't feel smaller (at least to me). I don't know how to explain it except to say that it seems like Disneyland gets all the money for nice queues and building facades, while WDW gets kind of shorted on that end.

Huh...I definitely agree with you about Disneyland being more intimate and charming, but I felt the exact opposite about the queue situation. Most of Disneyland's queues seemed to be outdoors (since they are able to enjoy more...cooperative...weather than Florida! :)) and didn't seem to be gussied up too much. WDW world seemed to generally have more indoor and much more elaborate queues, in my opinion. I missed this occasionally at Disneyland, but really not much. Interesting that we have different opinions!

Monsters, Inc. - Okay, I was ready to enjoy this ride. It is horrible. The characters are like early first generation animatronics without an major articulation. They are saying lines, but their mouths don't move. Yes their are some cool effects, like Randall disappearing or changing colors, but that is about it. The best effect they have is at the end of the ride when you meet Roz. What she says seems to change based on what is happening in your car. For instance, in the car in front of me, there was a woman in the front seat. Roz said something about the woman in the front seat. I filmed the whole ride for my brother because my Niece and nephews are huge Monsters, Inc. fans. I had my camera up to get a shot of her talking and she said, "Oh great. Another camera." The individual statements were a great addition, even if they are canned and someone just hits a button for the appropriate line. Unless you can see no wrong with Monsters, Inc. or Monsters U, avoid this ride.

Oh man, I disagree! I liked this ride a lot! It was like newer version of some of the charming dark rides at Disneyland. Monster's Inc. isn't my favorite Pixar movie, but I like it a lot, so maybe I'm a little biased!

After our first trip, we can't wait to head back to Disneyland either!
 

Agent

New Member
Original Poster
Pirates in MK is around eight minutes at Pirates in DL is around sixteen minutes.
Really? Huh. Are there fewer scenes at DL? One thing I have noticed at WDW is that it seems as though they have increased the speed through which you go through the ride. Not going to pull a skier, but still faster than I remember.
 

Agent

New Member
Original Poster
We just got back from our first trip to Disneyland too! I liked reading your comparisons and opinions, thanks for sharing!



Huh...I definitely agree with you about Disneyland being more intimate and charming, but I felt the exact opposite about the queue situation. Most of Disneyland's queues seemed to be outdoors (since they are able to enjoy more...cooperative...weather than Florida! :)) and didn't seem to be gussied up too much. WDW world seemed to generally have more indoor and much more elaborate queues, in my opinion. I missed this occasionally at Disneyland, but really not much. Interesting that we have different opinions!



Oh man, I disagree! I liked this ride a lot! It was like newer version of some of the charming dark rides at Disneyland. Monster's Inc. isn't my favorite Pixar movie, but I like it a lot, so maybe I'm a little biased!

After our first trip, we can't wait to head back to Disneyland either!

I liked Monsters, Inc, but not as much as, say, Peter Pan (but it is one of my favorite rides). It just seemed like it was older technology and let me down.

As for the queues, I just found them more entertaining. Part of that may have been that we rarely waited more than 20 minutes for a ride, so we were able to get on pretty quickly.
 

Travel Junkie

Well-Known Member
Really? Huh. Are there fewer scenes at DL? One thing I have noticed at WDW is that it seems as though they have increased the speed through which you go through the ride. Not going to pull a skier, but still faster than I remember.

The Opposite. DL has more scenes than WDW. The first portion of the DL ride does not exist in WDW. There is also 2 drops at DL opposed to 1 in WDW.

The reason why most people like DL's Pirates so much better once they have seen both is that they essentially cut the 1st act out of WDW's. It's like starting a movie a 1/3 of the way through.
 

Californian Elitist

Well-Known Member
Really? Huh. Are there fewer scenes at DL? One thing I have noticed at WDW is that it seems as though they have increased the speed through which you go through the ride. Not going to pull a skier, but still faster than I remember.

MK's has fewer. The entire intro in DL's is missing in MK's version.
 

Agent

New Member
Original Poster
The Opposite. DL has more scenes than WDW. The first portion of the DL ride does not exist in WDW. There is also 2 drops at DL opposed to 1 in WDW.

The reason why most people like DL's Pirates so much better once they have seen both is that they essentially cut the 1st act out of WDW's. It's like starting a movie a 1/3 of the way through.

That makes sense. I found it to be more enveloping/engaging as well.
 

fractal

Well-Known Member
Thanks for your comparison! I agree with DL being more charming and intimate. In fact, the first time I walked into DL it was a bit shocking for me. I also enjoyed the upkeep and the excellent condition of the park.

Space I enjoyed more in DL ( but not Tommorowland as a whole ), agree with HM and Pirates ( it is much longer in DL ). Indy is awesome!

I was a bit surprised with your assessment of DCA as a "half day park". My thoughts were that it was one of the best Disney Parks I've been in. This is what I wrote about DCA after my visit last summer;

"Now on to what I consider an amazing themepark – Disney’s California Adventure, or as I like to call it;
DHS on steroids.


Consider the lineup of major attractions;

Soarin’ over California – maintained in wonderful condition.
California Screaming – one of the most thrilling Disney rollercoasters
Tower of Terror – though not as good as DHS
Tough to be a Bug
Grizzly Rapids
Toy Story Midway Mania
The Little Mermaid
Muppets 3D
Turtle Talk with Crush!
Monster’s Inc. Mike & Sulley
Add to that - CarsLand, which is the best thing Disney has done in a long time. If you are a fan of Disney themeing and details, CarsLand can’t be beat. Radiator Springs Racer is an awesome E-Ticket and the atmosphere of that land is literally pulsating.

The cherry on top is World of Color. Although I didn’t see it, the reviews for this show are outstanding.

The park itself is such a pleasure to walk through. It’s airy and open and allows you to slow down and take it all in. Buena Vista street is vibrant and the old time band driving around in the classic convertible really sets the “Classic Hollywood” theme. It’s also a great park to photograph. You wouldn’t catch me dead in the Mickey Ferris wheel but man is it fun to shoot."


Thanks again for your thoughts; I hope to make it back out there someday!
 
Last edited:

ajrwdwgirl

Premium Member
I agree with your comments on Space Mountain and that Pirates is better at DL. I don't even bother with Space Mt in WDW anymore, it is so bumpy and I don't liked the seating (although this doesn't bother me with the Matterhorn), and so many more scenes in Pirates at DL makes it more fun!
 

Agent

New Member
Original Poster
Thanks for your comparison! I agree with DL being more charming and intimate. In fact, the first time I walked into DL it was a bit shocking for me. I also enjoyed the upkeep and the excellent condition of the park.

Space I enjoyed more in DL ( but not Tommorowland as a whole ), agree with HM and Pirates ( it is much longer in DL ). Indy is awesome!

I was a bit surprised with your assessment of DCA as a "half day park". My thoughts were that it was one of the best Disney Parks I've been in. This is what I wrote about DCA after my visit last summer;

"Now on to what I consider an amazing themepark – Disney’s California Adventure, or as I like to call it;
DHS on steroids.


Consider the lineup of major attractions;

Soarin’ over California – maintained in wonderful condition.
California Screaming – one of the most thrilling Disney rollercoasters
Tower of Terror – though not as good as DHS
Tough to be a Bug
Grizzly Rapids
Toy Story Midway Mania
The Little Mermaid
Muppets 3D
Turtle Talk with Crush!
Monster’s Inc. Mike & Sulley
Add to that - CarsLand, which is the best thing Disney has done in a long time. If you are a fan of Disney themeing and details, CarsLand can’t be beat. Radiator Springs Racer is an awesome E-Ticket and the atmosphere of that land is literally pulsating.

The cherry on top is World of Color. Although I didn’t see it, the reviews for this show are outstanding.

The park itself is such a pleasure to walk through. It’s airy and open and allows you to slow down and take it all in. Buena Vista street is vibrant and the old time band driving around in the classic convertible really sets the “Classic Hollywood” theme. It’s also a great park to photograph. You wouldn’t catch me dead in the Mickey Ferris wheel but man is it fun to shoot."


Thanks again for your thoughts; I hope to make it back out there someday!


I actually liked DCA a lot, despite all the negative reviews. I guess I called it a half-day park for me because I had ridden the rides there and didn't feel the need to ride any of them again. This is unlike Pirates, Space Mountain, etc. I've ridden Tower of Terror (and am the only one in my family that enjoys that type of ride, so I wasn't going to make them wait on just me), Muppets 3D, Turtle Talk, Toy Story Midway Mania are all basically the same as their WDW counterpart (would have liked to do Soarin' but ran out of time - I know it is the same, but it is California after all). We missed Grizzly Rapids as it was down most of the day (or at least every time we tried). I agree with you about Cars Land. It makes the park. I can see how people were upset about the park before the refurb. I think it is safe to say that it is a good park to go to (certainly better than SeaWorld San Diego which my family hated). It was an enjoyable experience.

My only complaint about World of Color wasn't the show itself but the hats. Okay, one complaint about the show - can we show some cartoons that predate Little Mermaid? I understand it was the beginning of the Disney Renaissance, but what about the animated features that got them there? Snow White, Cinderella, etc. all received polite nods for a few seconds while Lion King gets the scene where Mufasa dies (not exactly an upper). A little more balance to show respect to what came before and to continue to generate interest in what came before would help these older movies.

Agreed about the park being fun to shoot. I wish I had my video camera for the Radiator Springs lighting ceremony. Very cool.
 

GiveMeTheMusic

Well-Known Member
Okay, one complaint about the show - can we show some cartoons that predate Little Mermaid? I understand it was the beginning of the Disney Renaissance, but what about the animated features that got them there? Snow White, Cinderella, etc. all received polite nods for a few seconds while Lion King gets the scene where Mufasa dies (not exactly an upper). A little more balance to show respect to what came before and to continue to generate interest in what came before would help these older movies.

WOC originally included a lengthy Alice in Wonderland segment that was cut by execs (Iger/Staggs, et al) for skewing "too old." It's a top down thing, unfortunately. You'll notice that there's some real love for the older classics in most of the new entertainment projects - Soundsational has a Three Caballeros unit, and the finale is Mary Poppins. Tokyo Disneyland's new parade has an Aristocats unit. So, they still manage to sneak them in.
 
Last edited:

Animaniac93-98

Well-Known Member
You'll notice that there's some real love for the older classics in most of the new entertainment projects -

Or just about anything the company does nowadays. You'll be lucky to see any mention of pre-Little Mermaid animated titles besides Snow White, Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty by default association of the Princess brand. And you can totally forget about the existance of live action titles.

Tokyo has Aristocat stuff thanks to Hello, Kitty Marie. Soundsational also has some Jungle Book characters.
 

Cosmic Commando

Well-Known Member
Or just about anything the company does nowadays. You'll be lucky to see any mention of pre-Little Mermaid animated titles besides Snow White, Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty by default association of the Princess brand. And you can totally forget about the existance of live action titles.

Tokyo has Aristocat stuff thanks to Hello, Kitty Marie. Soundsational also has some Jungle Book characters.
... then you have MSEP, whose most recent character (if you count Tink as part of Peter Pan) is Elliot and Pete from Pete's Dragon. Yikes.
 

Animaniac93-98

Well-Known Member
... then you have MSEP, whose most recent character (if you count Tink as part of Peter Pan) is Elliot and Pete from Pete's Dragon. Yikes.

Elliot was a brand new float built to promote the movie at the time of his 1977 debut. Other "new" Disney movies like Fox and the Hound and Return to Oz would get floats, but Elliot's the only one who stayed.

I agree it's the opposite, but I don't mind that. I have nothing against Peter Pan, Pete's Dragon, Pinocchio or others, but don't have the floats look their age.
 

Cosmic Commando

Well-Known Member
The Return to Oz float caught fire!

I agree: I like the parade on its own merits; the only thing particularly "wrong" with it is the contrast between it and everything else Disney does these days. No Nemo, no Toy Story, no floats from the 90's classics (I think Ariel dances with the other princesses, but still). Tokyo's Dreamlights is really what MSEP should be in 2013: they have an awesome Genie float that changes colors and whatnot and they have the Nemos and the Toy Stories. Looking at DCA's/WDW's MSEP, Elliot is really the only float whose inclusion seems questionable today... and he's probably the best damn float in the parade. The rest are all classics (IIRC, doing this from memory) and TO HONOR AMERICA, of course.
 

TP2000

Well-Known Member
... then you have MSEP, whose most recent character (if you count Tink as part of Peter Pan) is Elliot and Pete from Pete's Dragon. Yikes.

No kidding. I think someone somewhere thinks they can get away with the Pete's Dragon reference because the film was nominated for an Oscar; 1977 Best Song Nomination, for Candle On The Water.

At least there isn't a Herbie Goes To Monte Carlo float, or a big section devoted to Freaky Friday. :cool:
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom