Cruise or Land Vacation

stefan74

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
If you had a choice of a Disney Resort land vacation with Deluxe Dining or a 7-day Disney Cruise to the Caribbean, which would you choose?

I am leaning towards the cruise but I am hoping to convince my family, some of which have never been on a cruise. The cruise is less expensive than the Resort Vacation and I think there is more flexibility. Has anyone been on the Fantasy? I am definitely getting a Verandah room but would like to know if the Concierge is worth it?

Any news, ideas or comments are appreciated.
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
Obviously my family are solid converts from the parks & resorts to the cruises. ;)

YES, I think the cruises are awesome vacations. I think Disney cruises are KILLER Disney vacations! It's all the fun & excitement of a parks trip but in a different way. There's just as much to go & do or you can walk a few minutes back to your stateroom for some relaxation. It's like the best of both kinds of vacations to me. There's definitely adventure to be had in new-to-you places. I love love love going to new places, doing new things, seeing stuff we never dreamed we'd see with our own eyes, and all of it with the awesome-level that Disney travel brings.

Just got off the Fantasy a week ago today. I was sick the whole trip and we didn't have the best weather when we wanted it most. That said, we still had an amazing time. We played with swarms of stingrays on a sandbar and snorkeled a coral garden in Grand Cayman. We drank drinks in a bar on the beach in Costa Maya/Mahahual with our 16 & 17 year olds (surreal having a drink in the public with your own kid for the first time) then standup paddleboarded in the rain. My brother had a Mexican cabbie who spoke maybe 3 English words doubled-over laughing when he rattled off the list of words he knew in Spanish....which all happened to be obscenties or otherwise non-family-friendly words. Embassador! We drove Xrail buggies thru the jungle, swam in a cenote, and held a golden eagle in Cozumel. We did stuff we never would've done if we hadn't gone and that's even with being sick the entire time! And, if the cruise was a flop, I don't suppose the husband and I would be choosing a do-over of the same ship on the same itinerary for our 20th anniversary in September! Right?! We left too much undone on the ship. So much we didn't get to do. We're going back to do it again!

I've sailed with Disney 5x now. Twice has been with verandah rooms and 3 times in concierge suites. I love love looooove concierge but it's a LOT of money. You don't have to spend that to have a fabulous time, trust me. Depending which sailing you're looking at there may be the possibility of scoring an upgrade the day of sailing at the port. September tends to be a slower time of year. You'd just need to keep an eye on your sailing on the DCL website, stay up-to-date on the availability of the concierge rooms. Book what you will be happy with then upgrade as a bonus if possible. Don't book something counting on the upgrade because you don't want to start off your cruise stuck in a room you didn't want. You know? If you upgrade at port, tho, you will not pay as much as if you booked it from the start. The higher the stateroom category you upgrade to, the deeper those savings can get. I've done port upgrades twice and the savings both times were really substantial over rack rate.

Don't forget to book another cruise while you're onboard! You'll get 10% off the base fare, 10% deposit (vs. 20%), and onboard credits for spending when you sail again. Even if you don't know when or if you want to sail again for sure, ask for a "placeholder". The agent onboard will find you the cheapest short cruise waaaaay out in the future that they can find and you'll pay the deposit for that. My family of 4 just booked a "placeholder" for a whopping $148 deposit. :D Then, when you figure out when you want to sail again you can have your placeholder moved keeping the benefits and paying the difference in deposit if any. Believe me, that 10% can save you some money! We moved an old placeholder to the 15-night Panama Canal next May and saved almost $900. :eek: Plus, an $1800 deposit would've been brutal! Yikes!

What sailing you looking at? We're just waiting to pull the trigger on the 9/14 Fantasy Western! :D
 

Tusportsfan

Member
The only boat we've not been on has been the Fantasy (and my daughter is PLEADING to correct this oversight ...), but I would not hesitate to recommend doing the cruise vs the parks. Everything Sweetpea said above about the best of both worlds (sounds like the idea for a song ...) is true.

And if you REALLY need to hit the parks for a couple of runs on Tower of Terror or Space Mountain, you could always look at a day or two in the parks before the cruise ....
 

stefan74

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Obviously my family are solid converts from the parks & resorts to the cruises. ;)

YES, I think the cruises are awesome vacations. I think Disney cruises are KILLER Disney vacations! It's all the fun & excitement of a parks trip but in a different way. There's just as much to go & do or you can walk a few minutes back to your stateroom for some relaxation. It's like the best of both kinds of vacations to me. There's definitely adventure to be had in new-to-you places. I love love love going to new places, doing new things, seeing stuff we never dreamed we'd see with our own eyes, and all of it with the awesome-level that Disney travel brings.

Just got off the Fantasy a week ago today. I was sick the whole trip and we didn't have the best weather when we wanted it most. That said, we still had an amazing time. We played with swarms of stingrays on a sandbar and snorkeled a coral garden in Grand Cayman. We drank drinks in a bar on the beach in Costa Maya/Mahahual with our 16 & 17 year olds (surreal having a drink in the public with your own kid for the first time) then standup paddleboarded in the rain. My brother had a Mexican cabbie who spoke maybe 3 English words doubled-over laughing when he rattled off the list of words he knew in Spanish....which all happened to be obscenties or otherwise non-family-friendly words. Embassador! We drove Xrail buggies thru the jungle, swam in a cenote, and held a golden eagle in Cozumel. We did stuff we never would've done if we hadn't gone and that's even with being sick the entire time! And, if the cruise was a flop, I don't suppose the husband and I would be choosing a do-over of the same ship on the same itinerary for our 20th anniversary in September! Right?! We left too much undone on the ship. So much we didn't get to do. We're going back to do it again!

I've sailed with Disney 5x now. Twice has been with verandah rooms and 3 times in concierge suites. I love love looooove concierge but it's a LOT of money. You don't have to spend that to have a fabulous time, trust me. Depending which sailing you're looking at there may be the possibility of scoring an upgrade the day of sailing at the port. September tends to be a slower time of year. You'd just need to keep an eye on your sailing on the DCL website, stay up-to-date on the availability of the concierge rooms. Book what you will be happy with then upgrade as a bonus if possible. Don't book something counting on the upgrade because you don't want to start off your cruise stuck in a room you didn't want. You know? If you upgrade at port, tho, you will not pay as much as if you booked it from the start. The higher the stateroom category you upgrade to, the deeper those savings can get. I've done port upgrades twice and the savings both times were really substantial over rack rate.

Don't forget to book another cruise while you're onboard! You'll get 10% off the base fare, 10% deposit (vs. 20%), and onboard credits for spending when you sail again. Even if you don't know when or if you want to sail again for sure, ask for a "placeholder". The agent onboard will find you the cheapest short cruise waaaaay out in the future that they can find and you'll pay the deposit for that. My family of 4 just booked a "placeholder" for a whopping $148 deposit. :D Then, when you figure out when you want to sail again you can have your placeholder moved keeping the benefits and paying the difference in deposit if any. Believe me, that 10% can save you some money! We moved an old placeholder to the 15-night Panama Canal next May and saved almost $900. :eek: Plus, an $1800 deposit would've been brutal! Yikes!

What sailing you looking at? We're just waiting to pull the trigger on the 9/14 Fantasy Western! :D


Thanks for all of the information!

I am looking at September 13, 2014 7-day cruise and I am going to get a Verandah room. I was reading your TR when you went on a cruise and you had mentioned a Supervisor's Desk. What time should I get to the port in order to get a good place in that line? I am going to be driving from Louisiana and stopping in Tallahassee the day before and I hope to get to the port around 10:30am the next morning. Is that too early?
 

wdwstateofmind

Well-Known Member
We've gone to the parks every year until this year we did a 7-night Fantasy with two nights at the Contemporary after...

With that being said, we're never going back to a WDW heavy vacation; DCL is worth every penny you'll spend on it...as someone said above after a cruise you'll find one or two nights at WDW is all you really need for that fix as your mind will still be on the Fantasy anyways...

Your place in boarding line also doesn't have to do with the time you show up...I've checked in as #15 while the person checking in next to us was #32...so if you're not concierge or castaway cay platinum I don't really know they assign the boarding #'s...
 

Disneyfalcon

Well-Known Member
Thanks for all of the information!

I am looking at September 13, 2014 7-day cruise and I am going to get a Verandah room. I was reading your TR when you went on a cruise and you had mentioned a Supervisor's Desk. What time should I get to the port in order to get a good place in that line? I am going to be driving from Louisiana and stopping in Tallahassee the day before and I hope to get to the port around 10:30am the next morning. Is that too early?


10:30 is not too early, but if you have a late arrival time you may have to wait until 12:30 or so to board. :)
 

Zman-ks

Well-Known Member
I'm firmly in the camp of Disney Cruise. I love WDW, but if given a choice I'll pick the cruise every time!
75.gif
Same here! :)
 

EOD K9

Well-Known Member
Between WDW, DL, and DLP, I have been to those places over 30 times. I took my first cruise back in February with one day on either side in the parks. As soon as we were in the parks, we were talking about how great the cruise was (it was a 4 night on the Dream). We are taking a three nighter later this year with a stay at AKV the day prior with no parks. A short stint in the parks with a DCL heavy schedule would be best now for us I believe. I've been a DVC member for 8 years and don't regret it. My new thing will be to rent my DVC points, maybe do a day in the World on the front and back, and spend my time cruising.
However, I think even if you stay on land, you are luckier and more fortunate than many people. While the state of the parks is declining steadily, I'd rather be in WDW than nowhere at all. I really doubt you could go wrong by being in WDW, but since I've discovered DCL, that is where I'd lean. I think most people here would agree.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom