MerlinTheGoat
Well-Known Member
As a massive fan of the Pan ride at Cali/Paris, the new Neverland model wouldn't bother me if not for two very major problems-Just wanted to second the idea that their Peter Pan's Flight refurb was actually a step backward rather than an forward - losing the Fly-thru Neverland Room in favor of Fly-over Neverland models zapped a lot of the richness and environmental feel out of the ride. The ride was absolutely deserving of improvements, but they should have just punched up the execution of what was there already. Instead the result is far fewer show elements and much more negative space.
I'm constantly grateful WDW's PPF didn't take notes from Tokyo's redo. Our version desperately needs love, but I think Tokyo lost the plot here and shouldn't be followed.
1- Whoever sculpted the new Neverland model did a horrendous job. It's insanely misshapen and terrible. They had literally three other quality references as Cali, Paris and Shanghai all look right. Still messed it up. It was even worse when it first opened as it had this really poorly designed plume of smoke sticking out of the volcano. They have since removed this plume at least, but the model remains very ugly.
2- They didn't add any painted murals on the walls from those other three versions of the ride. So arguably the largest issue with the WDW/Tokyo version, how black and empty the walls are, was not really fixed at all.
They did add a bunch of fiber optic curtains to the black backgrounds. Which is a good and welcome addition in the Neverland flyover room specifically since the island is essentially literally floating in space. The problem is they used these star curtains throughout the other rebuilt and relocated Neverland sets for the Lost Boys, Indian Camp and Mermaid Lagoon. These models no longer look like an organic part of the island, they're just these small setpieces randomly floating in outer space for no reason.
Incidentally speaking of fiber optics, I don't know why but Paris still has the best pixie dust effect on the ship deck to this very day. Disneyland uses some dull sparkle projection, and Tokyo only covered a small corner of the boat in the effect. Whereas Paris' is a full curtain that covers that entire scene and looks spectacular. Paris overall is my favorite version even now.
As I mentioned in the TBA thread though, WDW's Pan ride has many flaws of its own. I still think it has the best London flyover (especially with the more 3-dimensional buildings), but i'm otherwise much more partial to the versions at CA/Paris. And over the past 5 years, someone has been swapping out a number of the UV lights on a number of scenes with bright spotlights. It has ruined a lot of the scenes and caused a ton of previously hidden walls and backstage stuff to become very visible. Whoever has been doing that needs to be told off.