Yes, park closing means the park is closed. However, theme parks don't turn into pumpkins at closing time. The sidewlks don't get rolled up; the doors aren't immediately locked.
Service has alawys been, and should always be, the hallmark of Walt Disney World. When you start treating some people differently because of their choice of accomodation, you wipe away the biggest reason people choose Disney over other vacations destinations.
-This would be a good point, except Disney has ALWAYS offered 'perks' to stay on property. Used to be they would ship all purchases right to your room, now its to the resort gift shop pick up area, still a 'perk'. They don't deliver packages to the Holiday Inn. On site guests can park for free at all of the parks, off site guests have to pay for parking, is anyone having a melt down at the parking lot entrance because the guy in front of you didn't have to pay to park? These are just two examples that show Disney does treat on site guests differently. Disney is still providing wonderful service to every person who comes through the gate, for the daily park hours. It's not like those extra 3 hours are going to ruin someone's vacation. If you didn't pay for it why worry about it?
Extra Magic Hours is a perk for Resort Guests, and NOT a reason to penalize those Guests whose circumstances prevented them from the opportunity to stay on-property.
-I don't think Disney is trying to penalize anyone. They are trying to provide the 'perk' that was offered to resort guests. The parks are open for long hours, plenty of time to grab a snack/ shop etc.
-some of the 'perks' that we go for include the early entry (yes,we go before the gates are even open for the EMH!), package delivery, & bus transportation (once we get to WDW we don't want to drive anywhere!). Mostly we go for the theme of the resorts, the ease of the stay, cleanliness of the resort and the value. With codes and AP discounts we never pay rack rates.
-I am not a resort snob. I am a mother who wants to go on a family vacation, relax and have fun. As I stated, we have stayed on and off property. Don't be mad at me because I want to use the 'perks' Disney offers as a resort guest.