UNCgolf
Well-Known Member
I disagree. Walt Disney World has plenty to do to keep you busy for a week, which is how long most Americans take vacation. The questions is whether they have enough that people want to do. Many more people will ride Guardians than rode Ellen.
That doesn't matter, though. There were still people who would ride Ellen, so if you have both attractions there's more stuff that at least some people want to do. It's not about choosing Ellen over Guardians; it's about having both as options.
With that said, Ellen to Guardians also isn't a very good example, because Ellen was obviously outdated and needed an significant overhaul regardless -- it couldn't continue to exist as Ellen. Replacing GMR with MMRR is a much better example. Plus, Guardians itself doesn't have a huge number of people who want to ride it (obviously more than the corpse of Ellen, though), which is why it's so easy to get a VQ spot.
Outside of examples like Ellen (i.e. a ride that had to change), it's always better to add. Even if you only have 400 people an hour using the older attraction, that's still 400 people who aren't taking up capacity elsewhere.
Last edited: