Well Disneynutcase, it's fine that we disagree.
I'll agree there is a big difference between show, and themed.
Rock N Roller Coaster has a show, because there is somewhat of a story to it. The preshow sets it up mostly though, the actual ride is not much of a show, but I'll still give it to you, however, if you were really racing across town on LA freeways, you also probably would not start with an LIM launch, or even more so go upside down. If I literally went upside down on the LA freeways, my ride surely would not make it to the concert, so I don't really get your double standards why it's ok for some attractions to add effects probably not realistic, and yet you seem to accept other effects that are just as unlikely on rides you seem to like, such as an earthquake at the end of a runaway train ride, or a snowman in a Swiss mountain. I guess it's simply because you like one coaster better then another.
I never once called BTM, Space Mountain, or Matterhorn Mountain, "just coasters", any more then you called California Screamin one, so I don't see what's so "ridiculous". I merely pointed out, they are still coasters, whatever you think of their theming. Love them or not, California Screamin, Space Mountain, Matterhorn Mountain, and Big Thunder Mountain, are "just coasters". Definition of an object, and a description of its' appeal are two different things.
Why do the details of Matterhorn Mountain, or BTM count, yet the details of California Screamin don't? So Matterhorn is a coaster with a mountain built around it, and California Screamin is a steel coaster made to look like a wooden one. That's a one on one relationship. I never once denied the details that exist in DL's coasters. I notice the specifics you provide in BTM, which seem to try and say a runaway train is "themed" even though a steel coaster, built in 2001, to replicate a hundred year old wooden coaster is not. Sure the earthquake scene is nice, but what did it have to do with a run a way tram?
If the tram ran away "because" of the quake, that scene would be in the beginning of the ride, not the finale. So BTM has an earthquake, and California Screamin has a wave effect, both are cool, and still both don't really have a thing to do with the theming of the ride in general, but just attempt to provide more theming in general, whether it fits specific to the actual attraction or not.
Sure the scenes in BTM are wonderful, but it's telling a very different story, nobody ever said that DCA's themes and stories, are not more realistic then the ones across in Disneyland, which theme to a more "make beleive" idea.
I never once said the "theme" to California Screamin is the launch, nor the soundtrack. Rather I said those elements, as well as the loop and giant Mickey, didn't fit the theme, and were simply added elements.
I'm aware of the coasters at Knotts, and although I've not yet had the priveledge to experiance Xcelerator, since Windjammer's demise, I never claimed a LIM launch and sountrack made a themed coaster. In fact, a much older coaster at Knott's has been launching us long before any coasters we mentiond, Montezuma's Revenge.
You give much to much credit, as to my opinion of the ride, having "theme" to have anything to do with the soundtrack. Your analgy of how BTM could be replaced by wood is pretty far fetched. How does rustic wood tell the story of a runaway train? Yet it has eveything to do with the theming of California Screamin, because, it's NOT supposed to resemble a steel coaster. Could BTM's mountain be removed, and have Big Thunder Adventure still be a runaway train? Perhaps, would I support this? Absolutely not.
Did I ever say that California Screamin was the best themed coaster of Disney's? I don't think so. I only pointed out what it had, and compared it to other's at Disney.
I go back to the example of Matterhorn. Is it themed? Yes, but to what, nobody really understands. Is it an adventure on the actual mountain in Swatzerland? Is it a fantasy where you encounter a snowman? Or is it themed to the 1959 film, Third Man On The Mountain? You could get three different answers, or possibly more, depinding on who you ask. The bottom line is it's got a mountain. I don't know of any defination that says, in order to theme, you must build a mountain around it.
DCA's own Grizzly Mountain, has only about an equal amount of theming to it as California Screamin, even though it has a mountain.
I'm not trying to make DCA, or Paradise PIer more then it is, DCA still ranks lowest of all the six Disney parks I've been to, but California Screamin, is "themed". Likewise, so are some coaster's at non Disney parks, but Xcelerator would not be one of my choices to illustrate that. Riddler's Revenge or Batman are better examples for California Coasters. Hulk or Dueling Dragons for east coast picks.
Is California Screamin the best ever "themed" coaster? Not by a long shot.