You have some really good choices.I'll list our "favorites" - but I definitely wouldn't say these are the "best" - that's the beauty of the many choices Disney gives us. There are so many diverse resorts with so many different looks/feels/sizes/etc. Our current favorites are POP, POFQ, and AKL, but I'm sure we'll have different favorites in a few years. I know it sounds like a cliche, but you really can't go wrong. Choose a different one each time you go and get a new experience.
No flames from me, I think that is one of the things Disney does best. offer such a wide variety of things to attract different taste.I have stayed at the Wilderness Lodge, Beach Club, French Quarter and now at All Star Sports. In my humble opinion, I liked All Star Sports the best. You can flame away.