Yeah, I think you’d be disappointed if you actually visited Super Hero Island in person.
I get what you’re saying. We can all see the difference between the two approaches. To me, the IOA land feels very cheesy and dated. The CAMPUS looks like a Marvel take on a real-world place (with fantastical elements).
The problem with the IOA’s is that while it looks like “fun for the whole family,” it really isn’t. Spider-Man is great. Hulk and Doom’s Fearfall are not really kid-friendly, and the Storm teacups is like, well, the Teacups only without the whimsy. The land feels comic booky, but the theming is thin.
Again, Avenger’s CAMPUS is based on the MCU, so it’s basically a superhero office park in California. I get that not everyone is excited about this, but from the looks of it, I think I will prefer hanging out at the PYM bar to sitting in “Cafe 4.”