Excellent question. I've never seen it as more than a 'B', personally. A spinner with very limited capacity, with basically no 'scenery' or show pieces or theming.
I think Marni stating that Dumbo may be a C ticket nowadays is referencing how standards have dropped. For example, FEA, NRJ, and 7DMT have all had exaggerated ticket ratings in comparison to past standards. (Hope I interpreted that correctly!)
Edit: whoops I did get it backwards
So I guess this isn't green lit anymore then? I was really hoping we'd hear about this attraction as one of the 12 days announcements
Seems like it's changed spots a couple times
At no point in the course of this 135 page thread did anyone classify this as a "Big new attraction". In fact check out item #4 on Magic Feather's list from March as he was predicting what would be announced at D23."B" ticket or "A:" ticket, looks like we are getting a very lame Carousel as the big new attraction...Such a shame...
Last I saw, Spain is actually at 2. Maybe 3.
Indeed. IMO regarding likely hood rankings-
4. UK Add (the small one)
5. New WS Country #1
6. Land Reno
This alongside other near guaranteed projects.