Challenge 3 - The Art of the Resorts
Reviews
Disney's Waters of the World by Magic Feather
Right off the bat, you bring out a theme that I don't believe I've ever seen before. It is an interesting choice, and I do believe that the theme works well for a Value. However the map is somewhat unclear, and I wished you could've had a better key that said what those numbers correlated too. I think the entry cover with the wavy design will me modern, but yet invoke that feeling of water. I like the names you chose for the restaurant and store, and that pun was cleverly hidden.
The Princess and the Frog area will be a great way to welcome those staying at the resort, and Mama Odie's sounds like it will be breathtaking at night. I like how the blue wavy design is incorporated on the buildings, and throughout the resort's buildings themselves. I wished you have gone into more detail for the room itself, as I'm still left clueless to how everything else will look. In fact as you went wing by wing you just entirely forgot to describe the rooms or give a hint as to what to expect. Furthermore wouldn't this be a bit too similar to the New Orleans resort given that Tiana has her own rooms over there? The Tangled Towers area sounds like it'll be beautiful, and a great place to stay. And similar to the tree house, I bet Rapunzel's hair will be stunning at night. Also the song is called Healing Incantation not Gleam and Glow
The rest of the wings fit in well with the resort, but other than Paradise Fall is there really much of a water presence in that film?
I'm not sure if Disney would really go for that Tangled to Frozen change as Tangled is still widely popular. Perhaps a Frozen overlay of the Pocahontas Wing. However my next issue is that I don't see Disney rethemeing any hotel before it even turns five. I just don't think that it's very realistic that Disney would do something like that.
Disney's Hasbro Games Resort by kmbmw777
I'm going to be honest when you first posted this I wasn't really sure how it would fit in. But as you described it more, I can totally see this working at Disney World, and perhaps an extension of the Pop Century theme as a Board Game through the Ages resort. I like how you included a map, but what happened to rooms 5000 - 5999
I actually really like how interactive your lobby is, and how you incorporated other classic games that just don't warrant a full on wing. I like the concept of the board game rooms, but I think it should've been incorporated into an arcade with video games as board games can take a long time such as Monopoly and Risk. I feel like you should've been more descriptive of your store and restaurant, and their names leave something to be deserved.
The Monopoly wing, I feel is executed well, and while you didn't really describe your room you had a picture, and sometimes when describing a room with a picture is all that's needed. Luckily this picture fit perfectly. The Clue section fit well, and I have no real comments. The Candyland section fit well. However I disagree with your choice to targeting a specific demographic by making your rooms girly. It should've been open to more varieties of color, and a broader demographic. The Wreck it Ralph additions were a nice addition, and I feel like they will fit in well with the current theme of the wing. Heck i'm surprised there isn't a Wreck It- Ralph version of Candyland they fit perfectly. The Battleship wing sounds like another wing which will bring guests into the world of the board game, and provide plenty of interactive elements.
Disney's Dream Village by spacemt354
Right off the bat you impress me with a theme that would have never crossed my mind, but is the perfect counterpart to Pop Century. The Horizons theme is very clever, and fits in well with a hotel. In fact I would be excited to stay here, at that's coming from someone who has never experienced the ride itself. I love all the little touches you include within the resort such as the timeline, the times board, the murals depicting the three wings, etc.
In general I feel that each and your wings are well themed, and fit the theme of what you have set out for. Also nice to see some original art. The first thing I noticed was that you repeated paragraphs in the desert themed wing. Overall each wing is well themed, and is very cohesive.
I liked the Millennium Cafe, but would've wished for a description for some items like the Horizon Burger. The gift shop was another nice nod to Epcot, and fits in well with this futuristic theme. The name for the child care services would get Disney sued, as there's already company with said name, and in act they have many locations throughout the states. However the general concept of it is great. The Astonomy via the Telescopes throughout the resort was a nice touch that would be super cool. On a side note this Disney Springs, what is it?
Disney's Animation Resort by Tegan pilots a chicken
Woo art!
As the only resort to keep the same theme, I'm interested in how you have your resort differs to what exists today. However looking at it now it seems that you kept half of the wings. Off the bat your resort doesn't give off the feeling of a Value, but more of a Moderate this is due to you describing the buildings as recreations of various villages and towns. Or maybe it is a value, because according to your amenities there's no pool
Lastly the Sci-Fi Drive In is a great concept, bit a bit vague. Is it the restaurant at DHS that is hosting this? Will there be two Sci-Fi Drive Ins, or would it be moved over here.
Disney's Space Port Resort by AdventurerEllie
Another unique theme for a Value. I also like the little touch on the map with each umber being laid over the planet the building represents. I like the themeing of space throughout the lobby. Like the gift shop, but not sure who would be wishing to buy Witch Mountain anything... The Milky Way Eatery is a bit disappointing, but at least the deserts can be iconic.
The half moon pool sounds fun, and the room's are cleverly made using the warm color palettes. Ontot he asteroid belt, you should probably do some research when writing about characters your not 100% aware of. Lilo and Stitch have two blueish big guys, Captain Gantu (Dark Blueish) and Dr. Jumba (Blue-Purpleish). Other than that everything else seems fine in the asteroid belt. Nothing that really pops out, other than those unique drinks. Actually yeah the wings are pretty much the same with different color palaettes. Hoever one thing that did grab my attention again was when you have fountains jump over the pool. That sounds really cool and eye catching. Also by purchasing a future Space Ip you mean, Space Jam right?
Disney's Saturday Afternoon by TheOriginalTiki
Another original concept, but I'm not exactly sure if this resort has longevity. I mean the shows your talking about for your resort were long off the air by the time this decade started, and by the year 2030 many wouldn't be familiar with at least half the properties present. We would be in a similar situation as the one at All Star Movies where The Mighty Ducks is largely unknown by those who stay there, and Herbie is beginning to fade as people forget about Lindasy's Herbie film. In this case The Mighty Ducks would be Recess and Kim Possible would be Herbie.
The lobby is a bit unoriginal as you have the concept sketches decorating the walls, but you do have the portraits of characters in the lobby. The arcade is an interesting concept, and the waiting area is a nice touch. By the way by favorite Disney Channel shows do you mean 2012 Disney Channel or 90's Disney Channel?
The DuckTales wing I think will be rather fun, and I think it can have a real chance to be remembered given the roots of the DuckTale Characters being part of the Mickey & Co line. However the water slide isn't really what is to be expected at a Value. Or even a moderate as there are none that tall
Not much can be said about Mermaid because its unchanged. The Recess playground sounds fun, but I'm not sure how many people would be happy about staying inside a school for their vacation. The Kim Possible Wing has an interesting set up, but perhaps guests would get lost with the story, or rather the lack there of. Also is there three restaurants here? There's the School Cafeteria, Loco Nacho, and the House of Mouse. Speaking of which, a fine dining buffet with characters, animatronics sounds better fit for something at Hollywood Studios.
Disney's Echo of Hollywood Resort by IDInstitute
I saw real potential in this hotel, but its unfinished. However you did turn something in, so that's a plus
Disney's Seasons of Magic Resort by MonorailRed
This theme has great potential, but I'm not sure if you were really able to deliver upon the theme. First of why is Flynn's Arcade from Tron here?
I get synergy and all, but how does fit any season? The wing's themes are great fits, but feel sadly underdeveloped.