Rotten Tomatoes "verified' reviews only started May 2019. So you can only use that new process to compare theatrical movies that opened after that time.
"All Audience" is an apples to apples comparison for all films since they started the website, which is why I use it (and for Strange World it is currently sitting at 39%).
If one was to only use "verified' you couldn't compare Toy Story 4 vs. Toy Story 3 (doesn't have verified) or compare Encanto to Turning Red (also doesn't have verified because wasn't released in theaters). It also doesn’t allow people who watch the film on home video to rate it as well so the rating is frozen in time during its theatrical release.
So recapping, no films that existed before May 2019, no movies without large theatrical releases (Turning Red, Luck, Marcel the Shell, etc, etc), and no post theatrical voting - in other words a very limited use metric.
But hey, this is fun, let's try to find a single way that this movie is not a complete disaster!
- Box Office of $73M global on a reported budget of $180M - CHECK!
- CinemaScore from those who paid to see it on opening weekend - lowest of all time in Disney animated history of a B - CHECK!
- Rotten Tomatoes - "All Audience" score of 39% one of the lowest of all animated films in history (theatrical or direct to home video) - CHECK!
- Rotten Tomatoes - "Verified Audience" score of 66% is the THIRD WORST score for an animated film in the history of the rating (only beating something called Arctic Dogs and Playmobile:The Movie) - CHECK!
- Unceremoniously dumped on to Disney+ at 30 days after release and on sale for $9.99 in the bargain bin by 60 days - CHECK!
And just to compare that “verified” score to recent releases:
Strange World 66%
(A massive gap)
Lightyear 84%
Minions: Rise of Gru 89%
Encanto 93%
Puss In Boots: The Last Wish 94%
Paw Patrol: The Movie 97%
Sing 2 98%
31 percentage points below Paw Patrol. Impressive.