It really depends on your expectations . We have stayed off-site 4 times now , 3 times at LBV Clarion Inn and once at Hilton Disney springs tower apartments . Both were more affordable than onsite . Both hotels had excellent free Disney transport. The Hilton you could walk to Disney springs via walkway in about 5_6 mins. The Hilton had a huge wind away river which the kids loved. Food at the hotel was pricey , although the character breakfast with Pluto and friends was reasonable. The clarion is basic , staff are friendly , 10 minute walk to IHOP . Breakfast at the hotel was good and you make Mickey waffles which was good . If you request a room facing the car park at the back you won't get road noise . The clarion also has shuttles to SeaWorld and universal. The bus stop for normal bus service is right outside the hotel which we used several times. The bus right into
to Disney's transportation centre and only cost 1_2 dollars per person. You can also get to SeaWorld , the mall , and the Walmart at Turkey lake road by bus . Taxis were reasonable which we caught at nighttime only 15_20 USD to get back from Disney to hotel.
So for us we love the Clarion , cheap , friendly and convenient and also really allows for less driving and has free parking as well as great transportation. Only about 15 minute drive to magic kingdom
We love the Hilton hotel , can walk to Disney Springs , love the windaway river which is open late at night , love Disney buses and character breakfasts , also now benefits from EMH as a guest at a Disney neighborhood hotel. This is a new perk. Parking at this hotel is expensive though . I believe 15_20 USD per day. As a virgin holiday guest this was waived. Only about 10 minute drive to the magic kingdom
I would say to check out some YouTube room and resort tours as it can give you a good visual and feel for the resort's . You can really tell if it is for you or not .