Which one ya got and why?
Personally, I really enjoy them both, but I probably give the slight edge to Shula’s.
Personally, I really enjoy them both, but I probably give the slight edge to Shula’s.
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
Yachtsman vs Shula’s
- Thread starter JusticeDisney
- Start date
zurgandfriend
Well-Known Member
I like them both also and I usually have lobster bisque, a New York strip with creamed spinach at either. I would give the edge to Shula's I love the key lime pie.
ajrwdwgirl
Premium Member
I haven't been to Shula's, but I adore the Yachtsman. My rib-eye has always been excellent and the truffle mac and cheese is so yummy!
That is a tough one, but I would give a slight edge to Yachtsman. We have always had better service there. The food quality is a toss up, they are both top notch. The scallops appetizer at Yachtsman is probably my favorite.
Disneyfan_76
Well-Known Member
Shula's for sure. The food was just ok at Yachtsman and we have had poor service both times we dined there.
TheGuyThatMakesSwords
Well-Known Member
Shula's, hands down.
TheGuyThatMakesSwords
Well-Known Member
Try the Molten Lava Cake
. If there are TWO? Order ONE and split it . It would take a Pro Linebacker to devour a Molten Lava Cake individually .
joejccva71
Well-Known Member
If I had to pick, Shula's. I have ADR's for both on my May trip.
I love Lobster, and I don't care if it's $80-100 at Shula's....I will feast.
I love Lobster, and I don't care if it's $80-100 at Shula's....I will feast.
Scuttle
Well-Known Member
Looks like Shula's gets the edge. I forgot to add the Parmesan Crusted Potatoe gratin is an unbelievable side item to go with your steak. Pan seared scallops are a great starter as well. We've even had them split that for us.
I need to try that molten lava cake next time it sounds like!
I need to try that molten lava cake next time it sounds like!
TheGuyThatMakesSwords
Well-Known Member
I wish we had a "love" button
. You, and I, may be the only ones that realize Shula's is a TOP-NOTCH Lobster destination .
OneofThree
Well-Known Member
This seems to be the consensus when the question is posed elsewhere as well.
The lobster's that good, is it? I hesitate to order lobster when I'm out these days because I'm so jaded by the many excellent seafood restaurants I used to frequent back home in New England. I'm headed to Shula's during my next stay -I'm going to have to seriously consider trying theirs.
joejccva71
Well-Known Member
Scuttle
Well-Known Member
This! We've also been going for years and not once have had a bad experience. Waiters and waitresses are actual professional servers. Which on Disney property isn't common. People used to buy Tables in Wonderland for V&A's but since that's been discontinued Shulas is the new gem on property for the discount.
Lobster and molten lava cake will be on my table next visit!
Last edited:
Exacta
New Member
I have not been to Shula's. I had a fantastic experience at Yachtsmans though. Our waitress was phenomenal. Being from Iowa, I'm skeptical of steakhouses in Florida, as corn fed beef has more flavor. I mentioned this to our waitress and she said that he beef is flown in from Iowa, interesting. It was very good.
Wait what??? Corn fed beef is inferior in everywhere compared to grass fed high quality beef...
Last edited:
joejccva71
Well-Known Member
Yea I always thought grass fed beef was higher quality and flavorful than corn fed.
I
It is... Not even close...
MikeyK72
Well-Known Member
Just don't expect to pay at Shula's with your Magic Band; please bring a credit card.