Yeah, we had Written Theory for 2 years, from 8-9 on M-W-F, but that was the only time it was offered and it was cumulative. Written Theory I the first semester, II the second semester, III in the fall of the second year, IV in the Spring. But if you failed one, you had to wait a whole year before you could try again. It was considered a "Weed-out course" because a lot of people majored in music thinking it would be easy. When I got straight As my first semester, my high school English teacher was very excited for me, and commented that I had finally gotten better grades than my brother. (He had gotten a B in something. He was an English major) And my brother said that it didn't count because I was a music major and all I had to do was sing all day. I'd have liked to see HIM do my aural theory class! But anyway, a lot of people think it's easy and then fail Written Theory and end up changing their majors because they find out it was harder than they expected. Then we had Aural theory on the Tuesday Thursday spot for 2 years, and we had Historical survey for 2 years....that's another weed out course, but that one was actually pretty easy IF you went to class and took notes, but a lot of kids didn't. There were kids who were in their 3rd year, still taking Written Theory and Historical Survey I.
I think the professor of the Early Childhood development class was probably right about MOST freshman, but only because most freshman weren't particularly motivated. It was one of those classes that filled up very quickly because it knocked out a LOT of different requirements with just the one class. It was a Writing class, a humanities, a research or something....I don't even remember all the requirements it covered, but it was 3 or 4 credit hours and then you didn't have to take a Writing course AND a humanities class or whatever the requirements were. It credited for like 4 different things. With music, we weren't at all short on humanities credits, but anyone who was undecided on a major would just knock out as many credits as they could. But anyone who was in education had to take THAT specific class. Class registration was tiered, so I think seniors got first pick of classes, because they only had the one year left to get everything in. But if you didn't sign up right away, certain classes might be full before you got the chance to sign up for them. So this particular professor did not accept freshman in her class as a general rule, because the juniors and seniors needed it more, and because most freshman weren't taking it because it was required, but because they wanted to knock out a bunch of credits. But most freshman also had no clue how much work was involved in that class. Again, they think it's an easy class because they think it's just watching kids play. She didn't want people taking up space in her class that someone else actually needed when they weren't going to apply themselves. She was quite happy to be wrong in the case of my brother and in me. She WANTED us to succeed, she just knew the average freshman wasn't taking their college education seriously at that point. UW is known for being a party school....ANYONE in Wyoming can get in there. As long as you graduate from high school in Wyoming, they HAVE to accept you, even if your GPA is super low. Most kids who go there only go to college because it's what you do after high school and it's what their parents want. And their parents pay for it. If they fail a class, they take it over and mommy and daddy pay for it again. I was there on academic scholarship and had to maintain like a 3.5 GPA or something? I couldn't afford to fail a class. If I did, I lost my scholarship and couldn't afford school and there was no one to pay for it for me because Dad didn't believe that girls should go to college, and didn't think anyone really NEEDED college....HE didn't go, and he turned out fine. Not that he had much money anyway. And mom's income was below poverty level....she didn't contribute a penny to my college education. So if I failed a class, there was no fallback for me, I was done. And I think that's part of what made a difference. The average college student, at least at UW, was lucky enough to have their parents paying, and didn't even know what they wanted to do yet....they weren't ready to settle into adulting. They were just having fun partying and hopefully getting a few classes in while doing it.
As for 4 years instead of 5, there were people who managed it, but I really don't understand how. There were 2 girls in my senior year pedagogy class and Student teaching group with me who were freshmen the year after me. So I know they DID it in 4 years, and one of them is really amazing...she's got her doctorate now and has gone all over the world doing field research in music. She went to Africa somewhere, and she was supposed to be in Spain for a year, but they had JUST moved there when the pandemic hit and they were sent home. She's written books and developed materials....it doesn't really suprise me that she kicked some tail. But I don't know how she fit everything in! And there were more people who took more than the 5 years even. Her husband was a Junior when I was a freshman, and he finished the year before we did. And now he isn't even teaching music....He taught Spanish I think? (He's a native speaker) and when I went back a few years ago to our choir director's memorial, he was working on becoming a principal, or he WAS a principal or something. But I remember my first quiz in Written Theory...I had never had theory before really....well, I had the basics in 5th grade band, but it was sporadic and not great. I arrived at college not knowing my key signatures, not understanding time signatures, etc. It was tough. I got a C on my first quiz, and I had always been a mostly A student. I was in tears. Carlos saw me (the girl's now husband), and knew I was a freshman. He says "Just got your first Written Theory quiz back?" And he was really nice and said EVERYONE does poorly on the first one. And when he found out that I got a C, he was like "Oh wow! You're golden then!! Most people fail the first one completely!" And he gave me the advice to give myself a break on the first test in any class because you don't know what the teacher's expectations are yet. But he took 6 or 7 years to get through, And my friend Becky took at least 6, though she also had a baby when I was a freshman, so she had more to deal with than most people. But I don't think you could do it in four years without taking some summer classes at least, and taking the max credit hours every semester.