Wishes is much better... and, I'll tell you why...
Let's put it this way...
Because I live relatively close to Orlando, when our family goes to WDW, we usually only spend holiday weekends there. Because people have to wake up and go to work, we usually leave early on the third day. Because or that, we only have the opportunity to see two nightime shows.
Back in the day, it was easy to figure out how to handle the situation... One night, we watch Fantasmic, the next we watch Illuminations. Fantasy in the Sky fell by the wayside. Now, I've seen the show a few times, because I used to go to WDW every other week or so, but I don't think my folks have seen it in a long time.
Now, with Wishes, it's almost impossible to decide what we're going to do... usually, it has to do with watching two shows in one night, which can be diffriclut sometimes.
i suppose my point is, when FiTS was around, it wasn't even an issue and now it is.