Why staying on site is worth it?

I am planning a trip in sep 13, with my GF and we are planning to go with one of my friends and his GF.

To cut along story short I am after some testimonials for why staying on site (with free ddp) is better than a villa, which is what they would prefer to do, I have stayed on site and would never stay off site again as I love the whole on site experience.

I am aware that there are threads with a similar theam but want to consolidate as much info in to one thread.

Also anyone who prefers off sight id like to here your views on why on site is less preferable.

Thanks
 

bethymouse

Well-Known Member
The experience

If you are off-site, most hotels have a "free shuttle" to Disney Parks, but it just isn't the same!:(
The Disney hotels/resorts are well -themed and worth every penny, but some may disagree since the "value" and "moderate" resorts have "outside" entrances a bit like a "motel" atmosphere rather than a "hotel".
Overall, it's up to you. I just don't think you save money unless you are a very "frugal" vacation planner and really know how to "cut costs" during a vacation!:shrug:
Personally, if I'm going on vacation, I have saved the money to enjoy the experiences Disney offers!:animwink:
You can't beat Disney transportation, although some would seriously disagree! You can't beat Disney dining either: again some would truly disagree!
It's a matter of opinion and taste!:wave:
 
Upvote 0

Poofiesdream

Well-Known Member
I have done both. Rented a 5 bedroom house because we were having a family reunion and had lots of people. It was Ok but a hassel to drive back and forth to the parks. You have to pay to park also. Prefer on site. Drive there, park the car and don't see it again till we leave. Have you ever tried driving around Disney? There are roads going all which ways! It is a very big property. Usually stay at POFQ, but when money gets tight we stay at the value resorts. We go 4 or more times a year since we only live 3 hours away and my daughter-in-law works at Disney. There is a lot of choices for on site resorts according to your budget. Go off season and save even more. You can get a value resort for $69.00 a night off season! Good Luck:wave:
 
Upvote 0

C.FERNIE

Well-Known Member
Well flying in from the UK.Sorry Scotland.There's so much to see in Florida as a holiday vacation,Seaworld,Bush gdns,shopping malls,etc,etc. We've done all that in the past so the reason we stay onsite is just to get immersed in the whole Disney thing.It's hard to explain why WDW has converted me into an old Grumpy fan,but it just has.:ROFLOL:Some of my friends can't believe that I spend two weeks inside the magic bubble.I love it to pieces.:wave:

We like to get immersed to, we have never stayed off site and i am pretty sure we will never either! Package delivery to your hotel is awesome! No need for a car with DME, we stay at the boardwalk and we have epcot and dhs on our doorstep which is awesome, but with any disney hotels you have the buses free to use! :wave:
 
Upvote 0

SMS55

Well-Known Member
If you stay on site then you don't have to worry about driving. Sounds like it's couples only so there are no kids involved. You can drink around the world for example and not worry about who is sober enough to drive. There is no fee for parking staying on site. If you are staying off site and you are flying in then you have to rent a car, so there is more money. Then let's not forget about parking. If you drive you can eat in Kissimmee, or west of World Drive on 192. That's cheaper than eating onsite, but you want the dining plan. If you want the dining plan then it's best to stay on site. We always drive and we do eat off site at time, but we don't have the expense of a car rental.
 
Upvote 0

RedBaron

Active Member
The last time we went, we brought my mom, so that made 5 people. There are not many resorts that will let 5 in a room, so staying offsite was definitely more cost effective. We stayed at a Marriott and had 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a living room, dining room and kitchen with laundry. I loved every minute at this resort and would have liked to move right in. It worked out great for our family since I could not imagine all 5 of us sharing 1 bathroom. it would have taken an eternity to get ready in the morning. This year it will just be the 4 of us and we are staying on property. I had looked into staying at the Holiday Inn (based on reviews from Trip Advisor) which I guess is a downtown Disney hotel . It did have a free bus to the parks, and the cost was a little less than a Disney Moderate, but not much, and I think it was more than staying at a Value.
 
Upvote 0

ratherbeinwdw

Well-Known Member
I am planning a trip in sep 13, with my GF and we are planning to go with one of my friends and his GF.

To cut along story short I am after some testimonials for why staying on site (with free ddp) is better than a villa, which is what they would prefer to do, I have stayed on site and would never stay off site again as I love the whole on site experience.

I am aware that there are threads with a similar theam but want to consolidate as much info in to one thread.

Also anyone who prefers off sight id like to here your views on why on site is less preferable.

Thanks
The extra magic hours are enough of a reason for young people with no children with them. Those after hours can simply make your trip. You will be there at a pretty good time, as far as crowds and weather. It will still be hot enough to swim, but not so hot the pool water is hot. It will be crowded, but not as crowded as it will be the last week of the month. We'll be there this month, but since we're doing Star Wars Weekend, we don't need the extra hours, and since we have annual passes, we don't have to pay for parking; therefore, we stay at the Doubletree. We'll be at POR in June and Arts in Sept. We always stay in the parks for our main vacation or any trip longer than three nights. The afterhours are a must for us. I can't take the sun because of skin cancer, so the evening and afterhours are wonderful for me. During the last hour or two of afterhours, we have been able to get on the usually crowded/long lined rides over and over. As I stated on another thread, we were able to ride Pirates seven times in a row. We walked straight on Buzz with 0 wait time, and five minutes for Space Moutain and Splash Mountain. Can't say that for Soarin, however. Line was much shorter, but still a little wait. But, in general, you won't do much if any waiting in the last couple of afterhours. The same is true for morning hours, if you're an early bird, but early hours are actually early hour; just one hour. Whereas, the evening hours are usually three hours. The later they start, the easier to get on the rides.
We are glad to pay the extra to have the buses, pools and afterhours during our longer visits. And, if you watch for deals, you can stay onsite as cheaply as offsite, if you add in transportation, parking etc.
As to food, that depends on what you like to eat. We save tons by getting a discount on a room and paying for our food. Most rooms have a fridge, so we eat most breakfasts in the room except for breakfast at Crystal Palace or Sunshine Seasons.
We eat most reservation meals for lunch, then eat places like Pecos Bill or Plaza-MK, Sunshine Seasons- Epcot, Restaurantosauros - AK, and Backlot Express - DHS. There are many of these types of places to eat. We go so often, we only eat at one or two reservations places each trip. We found on our long trips, that we never spent anywhere near the amount we saved on a room discount. If they have some kind of deal where you get a room discount and free meal plan, then that would be different; even though, it usually says with non-discounted room. There are three of us- a 16-yr-old and two adults. This may be different for families with more than one child, or those who want to do several character meals or signature dining.
You could go to allears.com and see the menus for every restaurant and the cost and figure out if you need the ddp or a room discount. It will totally depend on how much and what you like to eat.
All this to say, "Stay onsite if possible!" You will be glad you did.:sohappy:
 
Upvote 0

Disnee4Me

Well-Known Member
Let's not forget package delivery back to your resort. Who wants to lug around your purchases all day long. We used to stay off property until it took us over 2 hours to get out of the MK on New Years Eve '94 and I was 6 months pregnant with a 4 year old. After that told the DH we are staying on property ... now he would NEVER stay off property.
 
Upvote 0

ddbowdoin

Well-Known Member
it's only worth staying offsite if you have a large party... such as 5 couples who all want to stay together, then renting a home is significantly cheaper. The savings also extend if you rent a large vehicle and carpool with one car to the gates.

otherwise, it's such a pain to have to drive and pay 14 bucks a day.... and then head home past all the strip malls and chain to get back your offsite hotel. The only way I'll ever stay offsite again is if I'm headed down for a 2nd or 3rd trip (first time getting AP's this year) and just don't have the cash.
 
Upvote 0

ddbowdoin

Well-Known Member
The extra magic hours are enough of a reason for young people with no children with them. Those after hours can simply make your trip. You will be there at a pretty good time, as far as crowds and weather. It will still be hot enough to swim, but not so hot the pool water is hot. It will be crowded, but not as crowded as it will be the last week of the month. We'll be there this month, but since we're doing Star Wars Weekend, we don't need the extra hours, and since we have annual passes, we don't have to pay for parking; therefore, we stay at the Doubletree. We'll be at POR in June and Arts in Sept. We always stay in the parks for our main vacation or any trip longer than three nights. The afterhours are a must for us. I can't take the sun because of skin cancer, so the evening and afterhours are wonderful for me. During the last hour or two of afterhours, we have been able to get on the usually crowded/long lined rides over and over. As I stated on another thread, we were able to ride Pirates seven times in a row. We walked straight on Buzz with 0 wait time, and five minutes for Space Moutain and Splash Mountain. Can't say that for Soarin, however. Line was much shorter, but still a little wait. But, in general, you won't do much if any waiting in the last couple of afterhours. The same is true for morning hours, if you're an early bird, but early hours are actually early hour; just one hour. Whereas, the evening hours are usually three hours. The later they start, the easier to get on the rides.
We are glad to pay the extra to have the buses, pools and afterhours during our longer visits. And, if you watch for deals, you can stay onsite as cheaply as offsite, if you add in transportation, parking etc.
As to food, that depends on what you like to eat. We save tons by getting a discount on a room and paying for our food. Most rooms have a fridge, so we eat most breakfasts in the room except for breakfast at Crystal Palace or Sunshine Seasons.
We eat most reservation meals for lunch, then eat places like Pecos Bill or Plaza-MK, Sunshine Seasons- Epcot, Restaurantosauros - AK, and Backlot Express - DHS. There are many of these types of places to eat. We go so often, we only eat at one or two reservations places each trip. We found on our long trips, that we never spent anywhere near the amount we saved on a room discount. If they have some kind of deal where you get a room discount and free meal plan, then that would be different; even though, it usually says with non-discounted room. There are three of us- a 16-yr-old and two adults. This may be different for families with more than one child, or those who want to do several character meals or signature dining.
You could go to allears.com and see the menus for every restaurant and the cost and figure out if you need the ddp or a room discount. It will totally depend on how much and what you like to eat.
All this to say, "Stay onsite if possible!" You will be glad you did.:sohappy:


I will gladly take a room discount any day over DDP... only because DDP is all about perceived saving. If someone offers me 30 percent off my room I know that will save me X dollars period, regardless of what occurs. When you offer free dining you enter the element of chance and the unknown and ultimately Disney makes money this way. If you go for a week and on your DDP eat 3 full meals and snacks each day for a week then yes you will save. But what if one day you don't feel well and you want something small and light, sure... you didn't have to pay for that small meal but what you consumed was only worth Y, and Y could be anything... overhead costs vary for food types, etc etc etc

I eat a small breakfast... who wants to be walking around in the AM full of bacon and grease? That certainly slows me down and makes me feel lethargic.
 
Upvote 0

Sunshineglow68

Active Member
I have stayed on site twice and off site once and staying on site is so much nicer. It's convenient and with us only being there 3 days, I want to make the best of it. Our next trip is Sept. and we are staying at the WL. Can't imagine being off site.
 
Upvote 0

ParentsOf4

Well-Known Member
With 4 adults going, I assume the options being compared are a two-bedroom condo offsite vs. two rooms onsite. I also assume you'll get Free Dining if you stay onsite in mid-September.

Onsite advantages:

1) Cost - If you stay offsite, you'll need to rent a car, pay for parking each day you visit, pay for gas, and pay for food. These are taken care of if you stay onsite in September. If you take these into account, staying onsite with Free Dining may cost less than staying offsite.
2) Extra Magic Hours - Do you want to be able to get to parks 1 hour early in the morning or stay 3 hours late at night? You can only do this if you are an onsite guest and take advantage of Disney's Extra Magic Hours.
3) Transportation - Assuming you fly into MCO, Disney will do all the driving for you for free. They'll pick up your luggage, get you to your resort, and transport you to anywhere within WDW for free. They'll take your bags and return you to the airport when you leave. Some offsite hotels offer free transportation to WDW. Trust me; you don't want to use this. One of the most common complaints is from people who stay offsite and then rely on the hotel's transportation to get to and from WDW. Usually it's a disaster.
4) Convenience - Assuming the 4 of you are adults and like to drink, you can enjoy yourselves without worrying about who is driving. You also can come-and-go as you please. If somebody wants to head back to the room early or separate during the day, there is no need to inconvenience each other, having to drive someone back to the condo. Disney's transportation system allows you the freedom and flexibility to do as you please.
5) Atmosphere - There is something very special about staying onsite and immersing yourself in the entire Disney experience. You are, after all, going to WDW so you can experience WDW! Imagine (for example) going to London or Los Vegas but then leaving the city every night to get back to your hotel. Except for cost (see #1 above) why wouldn't you want to stay in the middle of it all?

Offsite advantages:

1) Space - Most two-bedroom condos consist of 2 bedrooms plus a common living space, 3 rooms in all. Unless you want to stay in a very expensive Disney Villa, you'll get more space by staying offsite.
2) Variety - If you don't want to experience Disney 24-hours-per-day, staying offsite give you some variety.
3) Cooking - If you want to cook you own meals, this will be cheaper to do if you are offsite.

The major reason most people stay offsite is cost. September's Free Dining significantly changes the equation. With this being offered, why wouldn't you stay onsite?
 
Upvote 0

Disney05

Well-Known Member
I love staying on site. But this August we are trying an off site condo. We are traveling with 5 of us this time. We 're heading to an All Star Condo in Reunion. I have to say I'm looking forward to my own bathroom. We'll have a 3 bedroom 3 bath condo. Will have to rent a car for the first time too. I am a little down not to be immersed in the magic 24/7 but we thought this was a good year to try something different.
 
Upvote 0

Sans Souci

Well-Known Member
I love staying on site. But this August we are trying an off site condo. We are traveling with 5 of us this time. We 're heading to an All Star Condo in Reunion. I have to say I'm looking forward to my own bathroom. We'll have a 3 bedroom 3 bath condo. Will have to rent a car for the first time too. I am a little down not to be immersed in the magic 24/7 but we thought this was a good year to try something different.

I have used All Star numerous times and you will not be disappointed. We have rented a 2 br condo at Windsor Hillls and it was a very enjoyable stay. I keep looking at the Reunion condos and I am tempted to cancel my reservation at BVC, but my husband likes to stay onsite.

As far as the topic at hand, I am ok with either option, there are definite advantages and disadvantages to both. Personally, I like the extra room offsite, but if it's your first trip, I would try to stay onsite.
 
Upvote 0

PolynesianPrincess

Well-Known Member
Last week (4/27-5/4) we stayed at Orange Lake Resort which is off-site on 192. Since our :home resort" (Vistana) is within 30 miles of Disney (its actually about 1/2-1 mile from the DTD entrance) we cannot trade for the Disney DVC properties :( We get our timeshare every other year. We love the extra room (2 bedroom unit) but we don't love the fact that it is off-site. The last 2 nights of our trip (5/4-5/6) we stayed in a studio villa at the Villas at the Wilderness Lodge. NOTHING beats staying on property. The EMH... convenience of the boat to MK from WL... Having your packages sent directly to your room. All of this makes our stay so much better.

In September we are staying at All Star Sports. We haven't stayed at a value since 2006. I'm hoping the transporation for the All Star isn't a disaster! We've always had such good luck with WL transportation our last 2 stays.
 
Upvote 0

PolynesianPrincess

Well-Known Member
Last week (4/27-5/4) we stayed at Orange Lake Resort which is off-site on 192. Since our :home resort" (Vistana) is within 30 miles of Disney (its actually about 1/2-1 mile from the DTD entrance) we cannot trade for the Disney DVC properties :( We get our timeshare every other year. We love the extra room (2 bedroom unit) but we don't love the fact that it is off-site. The last 2 nights of our trip (5/4-5/6) we stayed in a studio villa at the Villas at the Wilderness Lodge. NOTHING beats staying on property. The EMH... convenience of the boat to MK from WL... Having your packages sent directly to your room. All of this makes our stay so much better.

In September we are staying at All Star Sports. We haven't stayed at a value since 2006. I'm hoping the transporation for the All Star isn't a disaster! We've always had such good luck with WL transportation our last 2 stays.
 
Upvote 0

DVCOwner

A Long Time DVC Member
Here is way I always stay on site:

1. Always travel with large groups (this year 20 of us going) and I do not have to worry about transportation to the park, around the park, and going home. Disney provides Magical Express and buses, boats, monorail, etc.
2. Everyone can come and go as they want. People meet in the morning and head in small groups where they want to go. Some want to stay at the park and some want to go back in the afternoon to lay by the pool.
3. Always have kids along and it is easy to get them back to the room if they need a nap.
4. Do not worry about young teens going places in groups, I know they can always get back to the rooms.
5. Extra Magic Hours gets me to ride the big attractions without standing in lines.
6. If I want to have a drink with dinner, I do not have to worry about drinking and driving.
7. Disney 24/7 is really special.
 
Upvote 0

Sunshineglow68

Active Member
I will gladly take a room discount any day over DDP... only because DDP is all about perceived saving. If someone offers me 30 percent off my room I know that will save me X dollars period, regardless of what occurs. When you offer free dining you enter the element of chance and the unknown and ultimately Disney makes money this way. If you go for a week and on your DDP eat 3 full meals and snacks each day for a week then yes you will save. But what if one day you don't feel well and you want something small and light, sure... you didn't have to pay for that small meal but what you consumed was only worth Y, and Y could be anything... overhead costs vary for food types, etc etc etc

I eat a small breakfast... who wants to be walking around in the AM full of bacon and grease? That certainly slows me down and makes me feel lethargic.


I have the FREE DDP this time and am so excited about it. It is going to save me roughly $800 for a 4 night stay for the 3 of us. We get 1 quick meal, 1 snack and 1 table meal a day. For us, it is going to be well worth it. I got to make reservations at places that I normally would have avoided due to the price.
 
Upvote 0

JiminyandTink

Well-Known Member
1)Magical Express
2)Disney Buses, Boats and Monorail
3)Extra Magic Hours
4)On-site dining and shopping
5)Beautifully themed resorts and pools
6)Excellent service

and last but not least... You never have to leave the magic!!!
 
Upvote 0

Tinkerbella16

Well-Known Member
In September we are staying at All Star Sports. We haven't stayed at a value since 2006. I'm hoping the transporation for the All Star isn't a disaster! We've always had such good luck with WL transportation our last 2 stays.

See ya there in September! :wave:

I don't think the busses will be a disaster at the All Star's.. you are staying at Sports, so you are the first to be picked up and the first dropped off when you share with the other two All Stars! :)
 
Upvote 0

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom