I stayed at Paradise Pier for the 50th anniversary and LOVED IT! Beds were very comfortable, the room looks just like the Beach Club at WDW. (I stayed at BC in Feb 2007) I had an 11th floor Park View room and it was amazing! Left the curtains open the entire time (well not the ENTIRE time, but you get my drift). It is closer than the good neighbor hotels because you can take the Monorail to the Disneyland Hotel and PP is a 5 minute walk (10 minute slow, end of park hopping day, crawl). I felt the theming was great. Of course the GC is going to be better, its a 4 star hotel/spa that costs about $300 a night (give or take $50 depending on time of year). The DH has great theming, a FANTASTIC POOL (Neverland Pool) and some great restaurants. If you want a Disney hotel at a good price, go with Paradise Pier. Disneyland Hotel is nicer, but does cost a little more.