Before I thought that the CBR had a pirate themed pool but for some reason I'm being told it's square? Anyway, what's your favorite pools? Is it realistic that after a day at the Parks y'all just chill by the pool?
CBR's main, themed pool (Fuentes del Morro) is designed to mimic a Spanish fort, complete with turrets, cannons and the like -- it's very fun and not remotely square. There are also quiet pools, which might be what whomever you spoke with was talking about, OP. A 30-second Google image search for the "Fuentes del Morro pool" will tell you all you need to know.
As for me, my favorite pools so far are the Mayan pyramid-themed one at Coronado Springs, and the Volcano pool at the Polynesian. In both cases, it's more because I love sitting and taking in the surroundings after a dip (and keeping an eye on the kids), rather than because I do lots of swimming myself. Both pools are just beautiful to look at (and have a slide), and offer an impressive amount of seating despite being relatively compact.
Strangely enough, we just got back from a split stay at Beach Club and Polynesian (staying at both for the first time), so you'd think I'd be raving about Stormalong Bay at the Beach Club, which is the biggest and most elaborate pool on property (with a sand bottom, beach, slide that extends from a full-size "ship," and lazy river), but after experiencing it, I decided I liked it much better in theory than in reality. The slide is separate from the rest of the pool (you literally have to go outside of the fence and across a walkway to get to it), the lazy river barely moves, the fencing is like a giant white jail cell and inconvenient to get around if you want to go inside the hotel or reach the pool bar/CS location, and the pool area is so sprawling and oddly-shaped and covered with various bridges, a lighthouse, and other thematic elements that it is impossible to safely keep an eye on your kids, or have them keep tabs on you, without constantly changing position. I feel like I spent half of my time there swimming/lounging, and half of it just wandering around LOOKING for people. It was exactly the opposite of relaxing.
Well, to be honest:
Four Seasons
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.