Agreed, try for an earlier time as they will let you in as early as 4pm. We usually eat a late lunch before the event which let's us enjoy treats throughout the night. This was last year's guide map. I anticipate this year's will be similar in show, parade, and firework times.Neither, I'd try for an earlier reservation...otherwise you'll end up missing parts of what makes the party worth it. (BOG seems to run behind time on ADRs as well which doesn't help the situation). You can still get in with your party ticket at 4pm.
Have you been before? If so, then consider Liberty Tree about a half hour to forty-five minutes before party time. The CMS will dress for the occasion.
BOG would be my choice, especially if you've never eaten there. Food is good, and it's a nice touch with atmosphere and being able to meet Beast!
If you've already dined at BOG, and it's not your absolute favorite, then I'd go for something else.I have been there. 8:25pm too late? No other times available. Although as @Diznyfan shows from last year's schedule, Boo To You is at 8:35. If I dined at 8:25, I would have to see the late parade. (Aside: I made the mistake of only going to the late parade at the MVMCP two years ago -- it got rained out.)
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.