What WDW does worse than the DLR

Phroobar

Well-Known Member
I find it perplexing that anyone who loves Disneyland would actively dislike WDW, or vice versa. It doesn’t make sense to me.
Even though Epcot is my second favorite park after Disneyland, I need more of an excuse to travel across the country and deal with terrible weather when I can do almost everything twenty miles from my house. DAK, DHS and MK just don't cut it.
 

shortstop

Well-Known Member
It’s the absurd bias, especially when one makes ridiculous claims about “soulless” artificial things in WDW.
Agreed, and the fact that you are saying this as a Disneyland fan is pretty telling!
Even though Epcot is my second favorite park after Disneyland, I need more of an excuse to travel across the country and deal with terrible weather when I can do almost everything twenty miles from my house. DAK, DHS and MK just don't cut it.
Of course. But I like to think if/when you visit WDW, you still have a good time.
 

TP2000

Well-Known Member
I know it's still a week until Halloween, but let's talk Christmas trees. At WDW they are really, really hokey. It's like WDW management wants them to look fake. Perfectly conical, obviously fake, like a styrofoam cone covered lightly in KMart decorations.

fa38677b40ac8666c42eae49fcbc5dbf.jpg


And just so you don't think there's a 10% chance it might be real, they levitate it 15 feet off the ground for some unknown reason.

Holidays-at-the-Magic-Kingdom_Full_31506.jpg


The tree in the Magic Kingdom is actually the flagship. It gets progressively faker looking at the other parks, and by the time you get to Epcot it's just kind of sad.

Disney's Hollywood Studios Christmas Tree
IMG_1624.jpg


Disney's Animal Kingdom Christmas Tree
%255BUNSET%255D


Epcot Christmas Tree
Holidays-Around-the-World-at-Epcot_Full_14730.jpg
 

Californian Elitist

Well-Known Member
Agreed, and the fact that you are saying this as a Disneyland fan is pretty telling!

Of course. But I like to think if/when you visit WDW, you still have a good time.

I’m not biased lol. I haven’t spoken directly about the topic because I haven’t visited WDW yet, so I can’t and don’t have an opinion. I don’t rely on second-hand experiences. But some people can be a little ridiculous.
 

cheezbat

Well-Known Member
My 'home' Park here on the East Coast was WDW.
From my first visit in the late 70s, to living in Florida in the early 80s when EPCOT Center opened and blew me away, to the many years i loyally kept returning yearly even after moving back to the Boston area.
It was 'it' for me.

Then, something happened.

I visited Disneyland for the first time during a trip to California in 2007.
I had been wanting to check it out after watching from 3,000 miles away the 50th Anniversary celebration two years prior.
That campaign really got my attention and made me want to experience ' Walt's Park' after all of these years.
Well, I finally did....and it intrigued me.

I came back a few years later on my own to better immerse myself in that unique environment and Disneyland left quite a impression.
I was 'hooked' and soon after in the following years I was absolutely 'spoiled rotten' by the Park experience.
Everything felt like such a step up from Florida.
I even liked the Castle better.
( "size matters not!" - Yoda, Jedi Master 1980 )

So now, Disneyland is 'it' and I am constantly recommending it to people I know who are thinking about 'going to Disney'.
Even after experiencing WDW again this September after a five year hiatus, I still prefer the Disneyland experience.
So much so, I'm heading back in January with a friend I convinced to 'do California' instead of the Florida property.



Here are my own personal observations regarding the two properties, and how very different they feel to me on each coast.


At WDW, I feel like a number being 'processed' in a giant cog wheel of automation.
There is very little personal interaction.
At Disneyland, I feel like a 'guest' that was invited by Walt to come visit for the day.
Cast welcome me by name into 'his' Park and the interactions in general throughout the day feel more personal.

Disneyland has a far more laid back and relaxed atmosphere.
WDW is the complete opposite, with people rushing about in a crazed 'commando touring' state of mind.
The clientele, and different audiences, have a bit to do with that...but even when I have been at a sold out event at Disneyland Park the crowd never feels as anxious and crazy as a afternoon at WDWs Magic Kingdom these days..

Disneyland has great entertainment options.
Roaming characters, roaming musicians, roaming randomness.
WDW has some good entertainment, but lacks the spontaneous 'unexpected surprise' element I am constantly finding at DLR.
This 'unexpected' element truly sets them apart in my mind.

Disneyland - eat off of real ceramic dinnerware and metal cutlery, even at a counter service, during any time of day.
WDW - eat off of branded paper plates and plastic cutlery, even at said Signature resturant 'Be Our Guest' ( breakfast / lunch )

Disneyland - far superior versions of the 'classic' Attractions, some fantastic 'exclusives', and in general, upkeep of said Attractions.
WDW - some of THE best Attractions it had are now long gone...and those that remain often have issues.
A few gems remain however.

Disneyland - 'Fantasmic!' with a incredible 'real' fire breathing, fully moving, gigantic dragon.
Brand new score and show ( might be a 'minus' )
WDW - 'Fantastmic!' with the 'dragon head on a stick' ( use your imaaaagination..!)
Original show score ( a plus ) and East Coast version of original show ( a minus )

Disneyland - Walk in the front gate on a whim, and decide spontaneously what you feel like doing and just do it.
No major advanced planning really needed.
WDW - Decide six months in advance where you want to eat, and three months in advance what you want to ride long before you attempt to walk in the front gate.


I enjoy both properties on both coasts, and both of them are very different beasts.
That is what I like about them.
Each has it's own 'character' and flavor.
Both have fantastic highlights, and both have questionable low points.

If I were to choose just ONE Park out of them all however based on the current Guest Experience, Disneyland Park wins hands down for me.
No contest.

Can't wait to get back there come January!
:)

-
I was right there with you in 2007(initially there to celebrate the Rat! 😉)...that was my first visit too! Man oh man did Disneyland blow me away. I grew up going to Walt Disney World and absolutely loved everything about it, but Disneyland showed me so much of what WDW lost over the years.

I make a trip out to Cali as often as possible just to go there. Heck, last year I was working in Phoenix for a few weeks and when I had two days in a row off I got up at like 3am and drove all the way to Anaheim just to enjoy Disneyland yet again.

Walt’s touch is all over that place. Wish I could say the same for WDW.
 

Phroobar

Well-Known Member
Agreed, and the fact that you are saying this as a Disneyland fan is pretty telling!

Of course. But I like to think if/when you visit WDW, you still have a good time.
I would have a good time but there are too many other things in the world that sound a lot more fun. Heck, even visiting the Museum of the Potato in Idaho for a couple of hours last summer was fun.
idaho-potato-museum.jpg
 

shortstop

Well-Known Member
I would have a good time but there are too many other things in the world that sound a lot more fun. Heck, even visiting the Museum of the Potato in Idaho for a couple of hours last summer was fun.
idaho-potato-museum.jpg
Next time I’m near Blackfoot, Idaho I’ll have to try it out.
 

THE 1HAPPY HAUNT

Well-Known Member
I find it perplexing that anyone who loves Disneyland would actively dislike WDW, or vice versa. It doesn’t make sense to me.
I will admit I am being totally biased but even if I wasn't I would still make the argument but I am very biased and I am not going to hide it or apologize for it.
 

THE 1HAPPY HAUNT

Well-Known Member
So the last time you visited was back in the 20th century?
lol that is a funny way to ask it. making it seem like my last visit was over a 100 years or so ago. but the answer is yes. look I know a lot probably has changed since then, hell things in my own neighborhood have changes since then and I understand that but from my experience Disneyland is flat out better.
 

Californian Elitist

Well-Known Member
lol that is a funny way to ask it. making it seem like my last visit was over a 100 years or so ago. but the answer is yes. look I know a lot probably has changed since then, hell things in my own neighborhood have changes since then and I understand that but from my experience Disneyland is flat out better.

Well, your responses make sense now.
 

Phroobar

Well-Known Member
Why does the MK insist on keeping a huge crane out behind the castle throughout the entire year? How hard is it to decorate the castle at night for a couple of days and drive the thing off stage during the day?
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
Why does the MK insist on keeping a huge crane out behind the castle throughout the entire year? How hard is it to decorate the castle at night for a couple of days and drive the thing off stage during the day?

Bad planning?
Is it like when you paint yourself into a corner?
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom