Walt Disney – A Magical Life

donaldtoo

Well-Known Member
I could be wrong, but weren’t we told for many years that a Walt AA show would never happen, and was out of the question, because it was looked upon as sacrilege.
What a bunch of turds, including any Disney family worms that are allowing this to happen with their, apparent, blessing. Just plain tasteless, IMO.
 
Last edited:

BasiltheBatLord

Well-Known Member

PiratesMansion

Well-Known Member
I get every objection to this project, including the fact that Walt himself and his family have made their feelings known on projects like this.

*BUT*

As much as the company is guilty about spinning myths about itself using Walt's quotes, it's also true that much of society, spurred on by the internet, has been spinning their own tales about Walt, who he is, and what he believed, and these tales have become informed fact for an unfortunate number of people. The knowledge of who Walt was has largely been lost to people who aren't already heavily invested in the company and the stories it tells. To see and hear Walt in an AA capacity may inspire more people to learn more about who he really was and what he really believed and work to counter a lot of those nonsense urban legends. Will it work 100%? No, of course not. But the company taking on the opportunity to set the record straight on some level, so long as it is done honestly and sincerely, is ultimately a net positive IMO.

If you take out the AA aspect out of it, this seems remarkably similar in content to Walt Disney Story, which itself used actual Walt audio to frame a story about the man and his legacy.

Part of the reason the family signed off on Partners was because at that time, knowledge of Walt was already starting to fade from public consciousness; it is undoubtedly worse now. A well-done Walt AA show could help fix that.
 
Last edited:

chadwpalm

Well-Known Member
In the Parks
No
I'm not a die-hard historian on all things Disney, so I don't read books about Walt or the parks histories aside from things I happen to read or hear online.

Are there actual documented factual quotes from Walt that he didn't want his likeness in the parks, or is most of this information from his friends and family, therefore, 3rd party?

I'd be curious if his sentiments leaned toward "I NEVER want my likeness in the parks" vs. "I'd be uncomfortable seeing my likeness in the parks while I'm alive" like most people would.

I know if I achieved something great, I would feel awkward seeing a statue or animatronic of myself while I'm still alive...mostly out of a sense of humbleness. I'd be okay if people wanted to tastefully memorialize me after I'm gone.

So, I mean, was Walt actually adamant about never being memorialized in that way, or is it just an interpretation passed around like the game telephone? At the end of the day, I'm not personally offended by it and will probably check the show out when I'm there.
 

Mark Dunne

Well-Known Member
When i heard this news, i was kinda pleased in a respectful way, that they could create a brilliant looking Walt, i didnt release he and his family were against this, and for that reason they should leave it alone , you should never go against the family wishes, i think dreamers point is well done, so yeah should prob leave this on the cutting room floor. :)
 

Mark Dunne

Well-Known Member
The reason the Trump AA was so ugly was because they built a Hillary figure expecting her to win. Although the replacement animatronic they built for Trump doesn't speak, it's much more faithful to his appearance (other than having far too much hair).
View attachment 808205

Point being, I think the sculptors at work will do a fine job of getting Walt's likeness. Probably helps they have his frozen head to cast a death mask out of.
That left image is truly scary, Haunted mansion next for that one. :eek:
 

networkpro

Well-Known Member
In the Parks
Yes
So they've finally done it, Walt has been transitioned from the founder to yet another IP mascot.

1723463927210.png
 

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
Another spin on this. Great moments with Mr Lincoln was one of Walts biggest achievements and might be why we still have disney parks. Imagine Disneyland (that might have been the only park we ever got), if the worlds fair didnt happen. The money given to Walt to try AAs at this scale then bring that cheaply to disneyland is what changed disneyland from a park with mickey mouse and friends, to something people had to see.

Great moments with MR Lincoln, might be the most historical attraction of all Disney. Even more than small world or COP.

So showing Walt here kind of makes sense, but the bigger thing is it pretty much SAVES the attraction for ever. Attractions like great moments with Lincoln, COP, hop all could eventually be seen as expensive to upkeep with low customer scores and removed. Once Walts AA is put in, there is no chance it will EVER be touched.

I think COP should do this for its last scene or somehow add it to the first scene.

I have heard for years that Walt didnt want himself made into an AA, all I have ever seen is the old imagineers saying they felt it was creepy and it never felt right. I have never seen anywhere that Walt said that, but would love too see a quote.
 

mickEblu

Well-Known Member
If his family is Ok with it, I'm ok with it. I think it reaffirms Walt presence at the park. It was getting scary for a second when they were considering retheme-ing Main Street to Mickey Ave. and not playing Walt's opening day speech on Disneyland's 67th birthday especially with climate the country was in and all the other changes that were happening at the park. We cant bump into “Uncle” Walt at the park anymore and most of us here never have but I think a tasteful show featuring Walt would be nice at Disneyland. As long as they are using quotes he actually used and not pushing any weird agendas. The AA needs to be top notch, a spitting image and I need that voice actor to be spot on if they use one.

Now just to play Devils advocate, Walt did create a Lincoln AA nearly 100 years after Lincoln's death (Walt died nearly 60 years ago) but he didn't put the AA in Lincoln's family home or the Whitehouse. Haha.
 

TrainsOfDisney

Well-Known Member
Well they re not Disney’s. So they have no say. Jk jk
I know it’s a joke - but there are issues here. The Roy family seemed to have issues with the Walt family - hence Roy E. Getting Miller fired.
I really wish Walt’s Family could have continued to operate the company a little while longer…. Maybe the “Disney Family Museum would be in Anaheim :)
 

DLR92

Well-Known Member
I don’t know how I feel about this. How is the family reacting to this news?

I can watch an educational documentary about him. But to glorify him in an attraction seems too much.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom