Ultimate Resort Poll

[captainkidd]

Hopefully this should be some fun, plus give a good idea as to what the forum's favorite resorts are. Here's what to do - Rank every resort starting from the number 1. Number 1 is your favorite. Whatever is the highest number is your least favorite. Even if you haven't stayed at particular resort, just rank it based on how interested you'd be in staying there. I'll leave poll open for 1 month so everybody has a chance to vote. I'll list all resorts below to save you the work. Just copy and paste, and rank them. At the end of the month, I'll tally the total and see where we end up. Just please keep them alphabetical so it will be easier to do the counts at month's end.

All Star Movies
All Star Music
All Star Sports
Animal Kingdom Lodge
Bay Lake Tower
Beach Club
Boardwalk Inn
Caribbean Beach Resort
Contemporary
Coronado Springs
Dolphin
Fort Wilderness
Grand Floridian
Old Key West
Polynesian
Pop Century
Port Orleans French Quarter
Port Orleans Riverside
Saratoga Springs
Swan
Wilderness Lodge
Yacht Club

 

[melflip8]

All Star Movies 20
All Star Music 21
All Star Sports 22
Animal Kingdom Lodge 6
Bay Lake Tower 9
Beach Club 7
Boardwalk Inn 1
Caribbean Beach Resort 13
Contemporary 8
Coronado Springs 11
Dolphin 19
Fort Wilderness 19
Grand Floridian 2
Old Key West 15
Polynesian 4
Pop Century 18
Port Orleans French Quarter 12
Port Orleans Riverside 10
Saratoga Springs 16
Swan 17
Wilderness Lodge 3
Yacht Club 5

 

[melflip8]

Any reason for the resentment towards Old Key West?

I will be staying there in December and have read a lot of good reviews. Now I see everyone ranking it low and it has me wondering?

OKW is a great resort...however, its primarily ALL DVC, much like Saratoga..and therefore maybe doesn't get as much "press" as the others. The best part about the Disney resorts, is that you really can't go wrong where ever you choose. You receive most of the same amenities (besides perks like animals or monorails, etc.) and you're ON property and in the middle of the magic.

Either way, you are going to have a fantastic time and be able to offer your own perspective on it here when you get back! Have a magical time! :wave:

 

[designermv]

All Star Movies-20
All Star Music-21
All Star Sports-22
Animal Kingdom Lodge-8
Bay Lake Tower-7
Beach Club-9
Boardwalk Inn -5
Caribbean Beach Resort -11
Contemporary - 4
Coronado Springs -16
Dolphin -17
Fort Wilderness -12
Grand Floridian -3
Old Key West -10
Polynesian - 1
Pop Century -19
Port Orleans French Quarter -13
Port Orleans Riverside -14
Saratoga Springs -15
Swan -18
Wilderness Lodge -2
Yacht Club -6

 

[captainkidd]

Bump.

 

[iconjunkie]

All Star Movies - 20
All Star Music - 21
All Star Sports - 22
Animal Kingdom Lodge - 4
Bay Lake Tower - 17
Beach Club - 3
Boardwalk Inn - 5
Caribbean Beach Resort - 9
Contemporary - 16
Coronado Springs - 10
Dolphin - 18
Fort Wilderness - 13
Grand Floridian - 1
Old Key West - 12
Polynesian - 14
Pop Century - 15
Port Orleans French Quarter - 6
Port Orleans Riverside - 7
Saratoga Springs - 11
Swan - 19
Wilderness Lodge - 8
Yacht Club - 2

 

[afr117]

All Star Movies - 15
All Star Music - 21
All Star Sports - 22
Animal Kingdom Lodge - 8
Bay Lake Tower - 7
Beach Club - 10
Boardwalk Inn - 9
Caribbean Beach Resort - 11
Contemporary - 2
Coronado Springs - 13
Dolphin - 19
Fort Wilderness - 18
Grand Floridian -16
Old Key West - 17
Polynesian - 3
Pop Century - 6
Port Orleans French Quarter - 1
Port Orleans Riverside - 4
Saratoga Springs - 14
Swan - 20
Wilderness Lodge - 5
Yacht Club - 12

 

[KCheatle]

All Star Movies 21
All Star Music 20
All Star Sports 22
Animal Kingdom Lodge 9
Bay Lake Tower 1
Beach Club 7
Boardwalk Inn 8
Caribbean Beach Resort 16
Contemporary 2
Coronado Springs 13
Dolphin 11
Fort Wilderness 18
Grand Floridian 4
Old Key West 17
Polynesian 3
Pop Century 19
Port Orleans French Quarter 14
Port Orleans Riverside 15
Saratoga Springs 10
Swan 12
Wilderness Lodge 5
Yacht Club 6

Fun thread!

 

[Dukie]

1. Coronado Springs
2. Grand Floridian
3. Polynesian
4. Bay Lake Tower
5. Contemporary
6. Animal Kingdom Lodge
7. Wilderness Lodge
8. Boardwalk Inn
9. Beach Club
10. Yacht Club
11. Swan
12. Dolphin
13. Saratoga Springs
14. Old Key West
15. Fort Wilderness
16. Port Orleans French Quarter
17. Port Orleans Riverside
18. All Star Music
19. Pop Century
20. All Star Movies
21. All Star Sports
22. Caribbean Beach Resort

 

[PRNCSAurora]

All Star Movies 20
All Star Music 21
All Star Sports 19
Animal Kingdom Lodge 9
Bay Lake Tower 17
Beach Club 4
Boardwalk Inn 10
Caribbean Beach Resort 11
Contemporary 18
Coronado Springs 12
Dolphin 13
Fort Wilderness 22
Grand Floridian 1
Old Key West 14
Polynesian 6
Pop Century 16
Port Orleans French Quarter 5
Port Orleans Riverside 7
Saratoga Springs 15
Swan 8
Wilderness Lodge 2
Yacht Club 3

 

[surfsupdon]

All Star Movies 20
All Star Music 22
All Star Sports 21
Animal Kingdom Lodge 16
Bay Lake Tower 17
Beach Club 6
Boardwalk Inn 2
Caribbean Beach Resort 3
Contemporary 14
Coronado Springs 13
Dolphin 11
Fort Wilderness 15
Grand Floridian 8
Old Key West 18
Polynesian 4
Pop Century 7
Port Orleans French Quarter 10
Port Orleans Riverside 9
Saratoga Springs 19
Swan 12
Wilderness Lodge 5
Yacht Club 1

 

[Keri]

Coronado Springs
Wilderness Lodge
Fort Wilderness
Animal Kingdom Lodge
Caribbean Beach Resort
Port Orleans Riverside
Port Orleans French Quarter
Boardwalk Inn
Beach Club
Yacht Club
Old Key West
Saratoga Springs
Polynesian
Bay Lake Tower
Contemporary
Dolphin
Swan
Pop Century
All Star Movies
All Star Music
All Star Sports
Grand Floridian

 

[yankspy]

All Star Movies 16
All Star Music 18
All Star Sports 17
Animal Kingdom Lodge 9
Bay Lake Tower 8
Beach Club 5
Boardwalk Inn 4
Caribbean Beach Resort 19
Contemporary 7
Coronado Springs 22
Dolphin 14
Fort Wilderness 10
Grand Floridian 2
Old Key West 11
Polynesian 3
Pop Century 15
Port Orleans French Quarter 20
Port Orleans Riverside 21
Saratoga Springs 12
Swan 13
Wilderness Lodge 1
Yacht Club 6

 

[EvilQueen-T]

All Star Movies 19
All Star Music 20
All Star Sports 21
Animal Kingdom Lodge 17
Bay Lake Tower 12
Beach Club 11
Boardwalk Inn 16 (beautiful resort but worst service i've ever had...sigh)
Caribbean Beach Resort 8
Contemporary 7
Coronado Springs 6
Dolphin 13
Fort Wilderness 22
Grand Floridian 1
Old Key West 14
Polynesian 2
Pop Century 18
Port Orleans French Quarter 3
Port Orleans Riverside 4
Saratoga Springs 9
Swan 15
Wilderness Lodge 5
Yacht Club 10

 

[Earful]

Resort rankings

All Star Movies
All Star Music
All Star Sports
Animal Kingdom Lodge < 3
Bay Lake Tower
Beach Club
Boardwalk Inn
Caribbean Beach Resort
Contemporary
Coronado Springs
Dolphin
Fort Wilderness
Grand Floridian
Old Key West
Polynesian < 2
Pop Century
Port Orleans French Quarter < 1
Port Orleans Riverside
Saratoga Springs
Swan
Wilderness Lodge
Yacht Club

We dont have any experience with the remaining resorts.

 

[MagicKat103]

Great poll! I'm always interested in seeing where other people like to say too!

All Star Movies 11
All Star Music 10
All Star Sports 9
Animal Kingdom Lodge 3
Bay Lake Tower 8
Beach Club 7
Boardwalk Inn 1
Caribbean Beach Resort 21
Contemporary 20
Coronado Springs 22
Dolphin 19
Fort Wilderness 18
Grand Floridian 12
Old Key West 13
Polynesian 4
Pop Century 15
Port Orleans French Quarter 6
Port Orleans Riverside 16
Saratoga Springs 5
Swan 14
Wilderness Lodge 2
Yacht Club 17

 

[jjdisney]

Resort Rankings

We stay at the Yacht Club for 3 weeks every summer. It is hard to beat the location, pool, peace and quiet, and view from a balcony with a full view of EPCOT and the Boardwalk. Much quieter than the Beach Club or
Boardwalk and all rooms have a full balcony unlike the Beach
Club. We have stayed at most other deluxe resorts and the Yacht Club is the most magical experience for us.

All Star Movies 20
All Star Music 21
All Star Sports 22
Animal Kingdom Lodge 4
Bay Lake Tower 9
Beach Club 5
Boardwalk Inn 6
Caribbean Beach Resort 17
Contemporary 2
Coronado Springs 14
Dolphin 15
Fort Wilderness 18
Grand Floridian 3
Old Key West 13
Polynesian 7
Pop Century 19
Port Orleans French Quarter 10
Port Orleans Riverside 11
Saratoga Springs 12
Swan 16
Wilderness Lodge 8
Yacht Club 1

 

[HumblePirate]

All Star Movies 20
All Star Music 21
All Star Sports 22
Animal Kingdom Lodge 6
Bay Lake Tower 3
Beach Club 9
Boardwalk Inn 8
Caribbean Beach Resort 12
Contemporary 5
Coronado Springs 13
Dolphin 17
Fort Wilderness 19
Grand Floridian 4
Old Key West 15
Polynesian 1
Pop Century 18
Port Orleans French Quarter 10
Port Orleans Riverside 11
Saratoga Springs 14
Swan 16
Wilderness Lodge 2
Yacht Club 7

 

[DisneyJunkie]

All Star Movies - 20
All Star Music - 22
All Star Sports - 21
Animal Kingdom Lodge - 7
Bay Lake Tower - 4
Beach Club - 9
Boardwalk Inn - 8
Caribbean Beach Resort - 11
Contemporary - 3
Coronado Springs - 10
Dolphin - 12
Fort Wilderness - 6
Grand Floridian - 5
Old Key West - 18
Polynesian - 1
Pop Century - 19
Port Orleans French Quarter - 14
Port Orleans Riverside - 15
Saratoga Springs - 16
Swan - 13
Wilderness Lodge - 2
Yacht Club - 17

 

[tarjaybuff]

That was tough! You may be surprised.

All Star Movies-20
All Star Music-21
All Star Sports-22
Animal Kingdom Lodge-3
Bay Lake Tower-11
Beach Club-12
Boardwalk Inn-10
Caribbean Beach Resort-4
Contemporary-15
Coronado Springs-13
Dolphin-18
Fort Wilderness-6
Grand Floridian-7
Old Key West-19
Polynesian-5
Pop Century-2
Port Orleans French Quarter-9
Port Orleans Riverside-1:sohappy:
Saratoga Springs-14
Swan-17
Wilderness Lodge-8
Yacht Club-16

 

[tarjaybuff]

And the #1 WINNER is . . .

:sohappy:POLYNESIAN!!! - with 22 votes

:king:I love statistics so I compiled all the #1s, and this is what I came up with.

Polynesian- 22 votes
Grand Floridian- 16 votes
Wilderness Lodge- 10 votes
Tied with 5 votes- PORS, AKL, Boardwalk, and Beach Club
Tied with 2 votes- POFQ, Yatch Club, Coronado, and Bay Lake
Tied with only 1 vote- POP Century, F Wilderness, and Contemporary

RIP- those not mentioned:fork:

Thank you to everyone who took the time to rate the resorts.:wave: