TOT: Disneyland Walt Disney World Comparison (SPOILERS)

paulcmartens

Account Suspended
Original Poster
Well, this is news since I just got off of TOT during the Annual pass previews with RU42 at DCA.

And since my throat is sore from yelling/screaming...I'd say the ride get's a thumbs up.

That said, there are obvious differences:
1) you can tell they spent less on the ride. The cue, the interior of the hotel isn't as large. The outside area isn't so hot (although today it was 102).
2) they hydraulics mechanisms are smoother than WDW TOT I'll give you that. And the ride seemed long enough.
3) Boiler room is two stories
4) Seatbelts are neat. You don't push in, you just touch them like a button and they come undone. Spiffy!


O.k. here's one interesting factoid. The Boiler Room is two stories, but you arrive on the main floor. So, everything is at ground level. You have the option of going to the second floor (RU42 and I were allocated to the far left shaft - the middle one wasn't loading).

O.k so, the loading is done top, bottom, top bottom. In other words, while you are loading, the other floor is using the shaft for the vertical elements of the show. Once its done, you start and pull back into the shaft and use the vertical elements of the show (aside from that there are no horizontal elements to the show - you move in and out of the bay)

So its great, although it takes a while for you to get into your vehicle, once you have access to it...you have a nice long time to get settled in you don't feel rushed at all (incidentally, the door opens, however there is a hallway between the outerdoor in the boilerroom and the elevator itself, that's the exit hallway. Not really themed, which was a bummer, but oh well.

O.k. so you are in the car, and its all theatrically lit and pull back to see the door and wall become a starfield (1st of two)....then the rest is a blur...you have to ride it for yourself.

In my opinion WDW TOT is better in all respects except ride mechanics (its old?)...DCA is really superior in smootheness and quietness (like when you latch in to the vertical shaft for vertical movement).

Yes, there is a scene which WDW does not have...a mirror effect where you become the ghost (seriously, wave your arms, they turn blue and electrified)...but the lack of the horizontal movement midway the ride starts to grate on you when the disappearing hosts beckon you to follow them, because you can't...you won't move horizontally towards them (they should have changed this, like the ghosts should have walked towards you and you escape by jumping upwards.

The program I rode caught me by surprise, so that was good. But over everything, I would have to say (Besides the mechanics) WDW is better.


http://homepage.mac.com/paulcmartens/PhotoAlbum17.html

Some pics...and the movies:

http://homepage.mac.com/paulcmartens/iMovieTheater18.html
http://homepage.mac.com/paulcmartens/iMovieTheater19.html
http://homepage.mac.com/paulcmartens/iMovieTheater20.html
 

marni1971

Park History nut
Premium Member
Thanks for posting - sound interesting. I agree - I would prefer to have the horizontal movement too. That really got me at WDW: an elevator moving out of its shaft mid ride...

Nice to see a spoiler alert too!
 

wdwmagic

Administrator
Moderator
Premium Member
Thanks for the comparison :)

How did you find the voice-overs during the attraction? I heard some people mention it didnt sound to accurate?
 

paulcmartens

Account Suspended
Original Poster
well...

Well, I've only ridden each ride once...so I'm not that authoritative! (Cal Disney pointed out that the television is very 50's not 1939).

Anywho...the voiceover work was fine. Very consistent in my books. I looked real, real hard at the mouth of Mr. Sterling and it was a bang up job.

SPOILER:

Does WDW's 'library' have a window outside that is all stormy a la Haunted Mansion? Just curious. DO check out RU42's videos coming up. He did a great job (while I blabbed away in the background).

Also, another 2 bones of contention: lighting was far too dramatic in the boiler room. Very colored/unrealistic. 2nd. I didn't get the impression that I was in a themed environment when I walked into the tower. Everything was far too detailed, not enough strong visual elements...get's boring...where is the 'bang'? (and I don't mean drama).
 

DisneyFan 2000

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by wdwmagic
How did you find the voice-overs during the attraction? I heard some people mention it didnt sound to accurate?

If you mean narration, it sounded very bad! The WDW Tower sounds so much 'spookier'! :p

Thanks for the comparison! I too agree that the one at WDW is by far better because of it's setting (A whole street built especially for Tower) and because of the 5th Dimension! :)
 

imagineer99

New Member
Re: well...

Originally posted by paulcmartens


Anywho...the voiceover work was fine. Very consistent in my books. I looked real, real hard at the mouth of Mr. Sterling and it was a bang up job.


That's because that IS Rod Serling saying that. The imagineers took the intro from a Twilight Zone entitled the "Good Life" Every shot you see of Serling while talking is his actual dialogue.

However, the rest of the intro (where serling is off screen) and during the rest of the ride, is a voice impersonator.

Just so you know...:)
 

paulcmartens

Account Suspended
Original Poster
I was wondering...

I thought that dub work was phenomenal...ha. Well then, the rest of the voiceover was spectacular. Sorry, who ever was saying it bit...well, the ride opened today for the public for the first time. So whoever said it sucked, well, wasn't on it were they?
 

paulcmartens

Account Suspended
Original Poster
Wow, online video...what a great quality to judge a ride's voiceoever on :rolleyes:

Please..caveat your comments until you've actually ridden the ride! (or say so...online source).

Don't try to sound so authoritative! :hammer:

And no...WDW does NOT 'OWN' DCA. DCA has a few good tricks up its sleeve. I'd say: if WDW is 100, DCA is 87.
 

DisneyFan 2000

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by paulcmartens
Wow, online video...what a great quality to judge a ride's voiceoever on :rolleyes:

The video quality was excellent! It's just a matter of taste... IMO the voice at MGM is much better but that is just MY opinion! And I find it quite insulting when you use the roll eyes smiley.... Uncalled for!
 

paulcmartens

Account Suspended
Original Poster
How much do you want to bet that its the same thing between the two parks!?

Also, are you talking about the commercial for TOT DCA? Just what great 'video' are you talking about?
 

CTXRover

Well-Known Member
The voice impersonator used for both versions of TOT is the same guy, Mark Silverman. Some say it sounds different even though the same guy did both, but even just from the video, the lines that are the same between the two versions sound very similar, IMO. Its the new lines that I think are catching people, who've experienced both versions (either in person or on line), off guard.
 

DisneyFan 2000

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by paulcmartens
How much do you want to bet that its the same thing between the two parks!?

Just what great 'video' are you talking about?

The video is from the remainseated.com site! And no thank you, I think I'll pass the bet! I've compared the both fair and square! (Two videos from Disneyforever.com back to back). This is just my opinion! Why do you want to argue about it?
 

MrNonacho

Premium Member
Re: Re: well...

Originally posted by imagineer99
That's because that IS Rod Serling saying that. The imagineers took the intro from a Twilight Zone entitled the "Good Life" Every shot you see of Serling while talking is his actual dialogue.

All the lines in the video, including the ones spoken when Serling is visible, were dubbed over by the impersonator. That way people won't notice that he isn't a perfect match (not to mention the potential problem of the background music). Listen to the "Introduction Clip From 'It's a Good Life' Episode" clip from this page. It does sound different from the one in the library.
 

paulcmartens

Account Suspended
Original Poster
I just think its ridiculous that you believe a home made video can substitute for hearing it in person. :rolleyes:

Huh...so...it is a dub. Phenomenal. That guy has real talent. And the audio was so seamless with the lips.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom