My personal opinion on DisneySEA's Fantasmic.
I just watched the DisneySea version of Fantasmic on Youtube. I wanted to post my honest thoughts on the show. I have seen, in person, both the Disneyland and WDW version of Fantasmic and I have very mixed thoughts on this new show.
Let me start with the things I just didn't like.
I must first agree with steve2wdw's comments about the theme for this new show. There really is little copy of the WONDERFUL theme to Fantasmic. To me, a good night-time show is one that you not only hum the theme on your way out of the park, but one you can easily remember. Some that come to my mind include Fantasmic (US versions), Main Street Electrical Parade, and the "Glow in the Park Parade" (Six Flags....I reference to this because I have heard there was someone that used to be an imagineer working on that parade). This new theme is just not one that sounds very memorable. During the finale, I always get a cold chill (the good type, the one that makes you want to smile and cry). I'd hear it in the DisneySea version, get that cold chill, then all of a sudden lose that feeling when the newer theme is intermixed with it. And what's this with vocals in the last few seconds? Hearing them sing the word "Imagination" with the music just really doesn't sound right to me.
Another thing I didn't like, apart from the theme, was during the Princesses scene. I think I really only saw one (live) princess during the scene and I think it was Cinderella. I didn't see any of the other princesses (Belle, Ariel).
The only other thing I didn't like which gave me a "HUH?" moment was seeing STICH?!?! Is there anything at the Disney Parks that he doesn't get his hands into?
Anyway, let's get on to the things I actually did like.
The Lion King scene was very interesting, and I liked that they used several things from that movie during the scene as well as the water screen usage.
I liked the Genie/Pink Elephants scene (perhaps they could incorporate that scene into the current US versions next time they do an update to the show).
I also liked that they used a bit more fireworks than they do in the US versions, and fireworks can always add to a good show!
I also, like Disney_Geek, really thought the projection onto the hat was pretty snazzy. It did give a nice enhancement to the scenes of the show.
In conclusion, I'd probably give this version of fantasmic a 3 out of 5. I still think the US versions are one of the must see shows at the parks, and would really drag people with me to see it. I wouldn't make a special trip to head to Japan to see this version, but if I was already out there I'd aim to see it.
That's about it for my personal opinion.