Three Broomsticks or Leaky Cauldron?

[cslafferty]

First trip to WWoHP. Just wondering where to eat. I figure the food will be very similar; does one have a better atmosphere than the other?

 

[TubaGeek]

I find the atmosphere of Three Broomsticks to be VASTLY superior.
I find the food and drink of Leaky Cauldron to be VASTLY superior.
I'm guessing that didn't help too much, but there it is.

 

[BrianV]

I find them to be nearly identical in food and atmosphere. Go wherever matches your itinerary. If you go in off hours or right before closing you can walk right in without a line..

 

[Tom Morrow]

I much prefer Three Broomsticks, both in atmosphere and food offerings.

 

[sporadic]

We did both. Had fish and chips at leaky and did the feast for four at broomsticks, both were good but omg that feast was a lot of food. We couldn't finish it. Our favorite non-potter though was Mythos. Sooooo good.

 

[Disneyhead'71]

I really like the atmosphere of the 3 Broomsticks. The noises, house elf shadows, and The Hog's Head all add a lot to the "Potter" feel.

 

[JassiSidhu2000]

Food in leaky couldron was extremely good.

 

[RandomPrincess]

The food is similar but not identical. Check out the menus and see what you might like as some items are exclusive.

 

[fosse76]

The food is similar but not identical. Check out the menus and see what you might like as some items are exclusive.

This. I think both offer the same breakfast (mostly), but lunch/dinner options are different.

 

[trr1]

found here
breakfast is the same at both the Leaky Cauldron and the Three Broomsticks

Traditional Breakfast
Farm fresh eggs, sausage links, black pudding, English bacon, baked beans, grilled tomato, sautéed mushrooms and breakfast potatoes
Pancake Breakfast
Three fluffy buttermilk pancakes, crisp bacon and link sausage with butter croissant
American Breakfast
Fresh scrambled eggs, breakfast potatoes, crisp bacon, and link sausage with butter croissant
Apple Oatmeal Flan with Yogurt & Fruit
Freshly baked flan of apples and oatmeal. Served with yogurt and seasonal fruit.
Egg, Leek & Mushroom Pasty
Pastry wrapped scrambled eggs, mushrooms, and leeks. Served with breakfast potatoes and fresh fruit.
Kid's Breakfast
Choose traditional, pancake, or American
BEVERAGES (6)
Pumpkin Juice
Hot Tea
Fresh Brewed Coffee
Apple Juice
Orange Juice
Milk
leaky cauldron dinner
Fish & Chips
Ploughman's
Scotch egg, 3 kinds of cheese, fresh bread, miniature pickles, chutney, grilled tomato, green salad and creamy horseradish-mustard dipping sauce (serves 2)
Bangers & Mash
Toad in the Hole
Beef, Lamb & Guinness Stew
Cottage Pie
Fisherman's Pie
Mini Pie Combination
Soup & Salad
Banger Pub Style (Sandwich)
Served with wedge fries
Specialty Chicken (sandwich)
Served with wedge fries
DESSERTS (3)
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Cranachan
Chocolate Potted Cream
BEVERAGES (14)
NON-ALCOHOLIC
Butterbeer
Frozen Butterbeer
Pumpkin Juice
Tongue Tying Lemon Squash
Otter's Fizzy Orange Juice
Fishy Green Ale
Peachtree Fizzing Tea
Gillywater
Hot Butterbeer
ALCOHOLIC
Wizard's Brew
Dragon Scale
Draught Beer
Fire Whiskey - Single Shot
can be ordered neat or added to another beverage
Fire Whiskey - Double
can be ordered neat or added to another beverage
Three BroomSticks
Great Feast
Garden Salad, Rotisserie smoked chicken and spareribs, corn on the cob, roast potatoes. Serves 4, additional servings $12.99 per person.
Shepherd's Pie with Garden Salad
Ground beef and vegetables crowned with potatoes
Fish and Chips
Fresh North Atlantic cod battered and fried with chips and tartar sauce

Cornish Pasties with Garden Salad
3 small empanada-like potato crust pastries stuffed with seasoned ground beef and vegetables. Served with a side garden salad and choice of packaged dressing.


Rotisserie Smoked Chicken Platter
Served with Corn on the Cob and Roast Potatoes


Spareribs Platter
Served with Corn on the Cob and Roast Potatoes


Chicken and Ribs Platter
Served with Corn on the Cob and Roast Potatoes

$14.99
Smoked Turkey Leg
Served with Wedge Fries


Soup and Salad Combo
Leek and Potato or Split Pea and Ham Soup. Side Salad and choice of dressing

Rotisserie Smoked Chicken Salad
over a bad of fresh greens, with choice of dressing


SIDES (5)
Garlic Herb Roast Potatoes
Baked Potato
Topped with Butter and Sour Cream


Garlic Herb Corn on the Cob
Seasoned Wedge Fries
Fresh garden Salad
SNACKS (1)
Fruit Salad
DESSERTS (3)
Cup of Ice Cream
Strawberry and Peanut Butter, Vanilla, or Chocolate


Chocolate Triffle
Layered Chocolate Cake with Fresh Berries and Cream


Freshly Baked Apple Pie
BEVERAGES (16)
NON-ALCOHOLIC
Butterbeer (regular)
Frozen Butterbeer
Hot Butterbeer
Pumpkin JuiceComes in a bottle - tastes like a spiced apple juice with holiday pumpkin notes. Shake before drinking!
Tongue Tying Lemon Squash
Otter's Fizzy Orange Juice
Fishy Green Ale
Peachtree Fizzing Tea
Gillywater
Sparkiing Water
Natural Spring Water
ALCOHOLIC
Hog's Head Brew Draught BeerA watered-down red ale. Not great, but better than a Bud.
» pyrusj on February 28, 2013 gave it 2 stars.

$7.99
Wizard's Brew
Dragon Scale
Wine By The Glass
Domestic Beer on Tap

 

[Demeter Tess]

Breakfast is great at either, but I vastly prefer Three Broomsticks for lunch or dinner. A lot of the offerings at Leaky Cauldron are not to my taste, and the things that I have tried I haven't liked. But give me that roast chicken, potatoes, and corn from Three Broomsticks and I'm a happy camper!