News The Walt Disney Company Annual Meeting Of Shareholders 2025

AidenRodriguez731

Well-Known Member
I predict that if they go through with the removal of RoA for Cars at MK, it will be one of those rare DCA 1.0 moments when EVERYONE who goes there will say, "Well, this was a stupid change." Even if the ride itself is a popular hit, the removal of what guests have been trained to expect from a castle park for 70+ years will make a dent in the heart of even the most insensitive park goer.

It will give the average joes their own little "But I liked the Animation Tour" or "But I liked Horizons" moment. It wouldn't be as much of a nostalgic-breaking earthquake as tearing down the Haunted Mansion, but it will, like DCA 1.0, be noted by average people (and pop culture).

(Of course, unlike DCA, it won't be skewered by the Simpsons. It will probably be South Park or something like that.)

And when that happens, that's when narratives really start to shift. DCA 1.0 was one of the straws that broke Eisner. If RoA is replaced with Cars, it will either increase the demands to replace Iger (who honestly could still be in when it opens) or it will make the new CEO do a lot of "My predecessor did things that we're not going to do anymore."
I can guarantee me and a lot of people won't care. My whole family didn't care, the kids didn't care. I've seen so many people on social media joking to just tear the thing down. I think you might be slightly overestimating how much people really love the river atleast in the traditional sense. Now, putting Cars there can be another story and I see the idea but still don't 100% jive with that specific IP there.
 

MisterPenguin

President of Animal Kingdom
Premium Member
Still no news on CEO succession.

Don't you read all your stockholder reports? That's what this meeting was for, not for park fans on a parks discussion board.

Filed Mar 10, 2025...


1742520563068.png
 

MisterPenguin

President of Animal Kingdom
Premium Member



 

britain

Well-Known Member
I can guarantee me and a lot of people won't care. My whole family didn't care, the kids didn't care. I've seen so many people on social media joking to just tear the thing down. I think you might be slightly overestimating how much people really love the river atleast in the traditional sense. Now, putting Cars there can be another story and I see the idea but still don't 100% jive with that specific IP there.

Well, maybe. Especially people who've never been there before. They won't know what's missing. I just think it's going to cause a major tonal shift for a third of the whole park. It would be sort of like replacing the front of Tomorrowland with a lake, removing Buzz, Stitch and the rockets and the Peoplemover. Just imagine a lake from the plaza to Space Mountain, and you get to Space Mountain via many bridges over water. There are people who never went on those Tomorrowland attractions, but having a big lake there is going to impact their nostalgia/desire to return.
 

Agent H

Well-Known Member
I can guarantee me and a lot of people won't care. My whole family didn't care, the kids didn't care. I've seen so many people on social media joking to just tear the thing down. I think you might be slightly overestimating how much people really love the river atleast in the traditional sense. Now, putting Cars there can be another story and I see the idea but still don't 100% jive with that specific IP there.
I feel like we’re underestimating how much the general public actually cares. People won’t stop going but I think they will notice a difference. Nostalgia drives people to buy and experience a Lot of things these days. They are removing something that has been a fundamental aspect of Disney parks for 70 years.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
Well, maybe. Especially people who've never been there before. They won't know what's missing. I just think it's going to cause a major tonal shift for a third of the whole park. It would be sort of like replacing the front of Tomorrowland with a lake, removing Buzz, Stitch and the rockets and the Peoplemover. Just imagine a lake from the plaza to Space Mountain, and you get to Space Mountain via many bridges over water. There are people who never went on those Tomorrowland attractions, but having a big lake there is going to impact their nostalgia/desire to return.

You’ve turned very pessimistic. I’m not an advocate for the ROA removal nor Cars by any stretch of the imagination.

But I think you are off by a factor of 100 for how little Magic Kingdom is at risk of being turned on.

Maybe, maybe in isolation if Villains was canned. But given what this project actually entails and Villains is part of the replacement project, your analogy to replacing Tomorrowland attractions with landscaping isn’t really on the mark.

There’s always a strong desire to see things fail so the company ‘learns something’, but they never learn anything. They’ll just take away even more bad lessons if it does poorly… which it most assuredly won’t.
 

britain

Well-Known Member
You’ve turned very pessimistic. I’m not an advocate for the ROA removal nor Cars by any stretch of the imagination.

But I think you are off by a factor of 100 for how little Magic Kingdom is at risk of being turned on.

Maybe, maybe in isolation if Villains was canned. But given what this project actually entails and Villains is part of the replacement project, your analogy to replacing Tomorrowland attractions with landscaping isn’t really on the mark.

There’s always a strong desire to see things fail so the company ‘learns something’, but they never learn anything. They’ll just take away even more bad lessons if it does poorly… which it most assuredly won’t.
I didn't say the MK would be 'turned on'. I'm saying average joes will notice and complain, and it will add to a general narrative that Disney's leadership has lost its mojo. Not just theme park nerds.

But sure, if they are firing on all other cylinders... if there's nothing but high-quality popular additions everywhere else, maybe it won't matter.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
I didn't say the MK would be 'turned on'. I'm saying average joes will notice and complain, and it will add to a general narrative that Disney's leadership has lost its mojo. Not just theme park nerds.

But sure, if they are firing on all other cylinders... if there's nothing but high-quality popular additions everywhere else, maybe it won't matter.

Not just everywhere else, specifically additions in the space that you are highlighting. Average Joe’s opinions I would be surprised if they don’t generally *significantly* improve in that corner of the park.

We’ll see!

A good comparator might actually be Jaws to Diagon Alley for a few different similar reasons. And I love(d) Jaws. I think that was even a harsher trade off than the one Disney is engaging in.
 

Stripes

Premium Member
"We can't wait for guests to experience this retelling of the classic animated film,"

That's the problem with Iger's Disney. They've run out of ideas, they can only rehash old ones.
Elio, Hoppers, and an original untitled Disney Animation film slated for November 2026 are original animated movies set for release over the next 2 years.

Recently, we got Encanto, Elemental, Turning Red, Luca, Soul, Onward, and more. In fact, 2020-2022 saw the second longest streak of original movies in Pixar’s history.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom