The Sorcerer's Apprentice Season 4: Homecoming Edition - Discussion Thread

[spacemt354]

 

[spacemt354]

 

[spacemt354]

 

[D Hulk]

 

[spacemt354]

Tomorrow will be Mountain Monday!

Followed by Topiary Tuesday

and then on alternate weeks -- Throwback Thursday

If I come up with some more aliterations they will also be included lol

 

[tcool123]

I've been hunting down this version ever since the Japanese Trailer of Coco was released, but it featured this great ska version of Remember Me. While parts of it are in Japanese it is definitely a fun cover.

 

[AceAstro]

Duke was just eliminated!! Feels good!

 

[spacemt354]

Duke was just eliminated!! Feels good!

All is right with the world.

 

[TheOriginalTiki]

Join SandyClaws, Jacob Wile and myself as we debate the following subjects on the latest Oscar-themed installment of Disney Debates, going live in about 20 minutes!

1. Who is the best Disney director of 2017?
2. Which movie should have won Best Picture out of "Up", "Toy Story 3", and "Beauty and the Beast"?
3. Which 2017 Best Picture nominee should be remade with Muppets?

 

[AceAstro]

Which 2017 Best Picture nominee should be remade with Muppets?

All of them

 

[spacemt354]

I haven't seen it but

Best Disney Director of 2017 - Taika Waititi
Which movie should have won best picture - Toy Story 3
The Shape of Muppets

 

[spacemt354]

My second choice was for director was Rian Johnson *dodges flaming pitchforks*

 

[Suchomimus]

My second choice was for director was Rian Johnson *dodges flaming pitchforks*

If Rian Johnson wrote Independence Day

 

[Suchomimus]

My second choice was for director was Rian Johnson *dodges flaming pitchforks*

 

[Suchomimus]

Rian Johnson

 

[spacemt354]

Lol after seeing it 4x now -- there are three things that now bother me on repeat viewings

1 - Admiral Holdo is a complete waste of time.
2 - Needs more Swolo less Canto Bight
3 - Rose kissing Finn is the worst romance since Episode II lol

But otherwise I still love it *dodges second round of flaming pitchforks*

 

[spacemt354]

I cannot be beaten

*5 seconds later*

 

[Suchomimus]

Lol after seeing it 4x now -- there are three things that now bother me on repeat viewings

1 - Admiral Holdo is a complete waste of time.
2 - Needs more Swolo less Canto Bight
3 - Rose kissing Finn is the worst romance since Episode II lol

But otherwise I still love it *dodges second round of flaming pitchforks*

4 - It panders to SJW
5 - They polarized Luke’s character
6 - Snoke was killed off two movies too soon with no background information on him
7 - #1 Also applies to Rose
8 - They Skyped Luke to death

 

[Suchomimus]

I cannot be beaten

*5 seconds later*

Old tyrant gets cut in half while sitting in a chair? The Simpsons predicted it!

 

[spacemt354]

4 - It panders to SJW
5 - They polarized Luke’s character
6 - Snoke was killed off two movies too soon with no background information on him
7 - #1 Also applies to Rose
8 - They Skyped Luke to death

I think Luke would have been less polarizing if he didn't die after the big twist was revealed. If after he saved the Resistance, then went to his X-Wing in the water, raised it up, and flew off to join them...I think people would have not cared about the hologram.

I just think Holdo had no purpose...she takes over for Leia, and then doesn't tell anyone her plan, which causes Poe to go rogue and causes the entire Canto Bight sequence. What if she just said...hey...we're going to Crait, it's a former Rebel base, that's the plan. You can't tell me Poe would then go rogue and start a whole rebellion against her. So that is a huge plot hole to me.