-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
The Imagineer 2-- Practice Project 2 (Due 2/21 8pm EST)
- Thread starter MaterA113
- Start date
TrevorA
Active Member
- In the Parks
- Yes
Here are mine, in no particular order:
Tazer19 - I like how in-depth your project was. It seems a bit unrealistic for the space you chose, but I'm no expert. Over the two projects, you did a good job.
Tiki - I really enjoyed how concise your project was, and yet you explained everything (if not more) needed to understand your thought process. And I agree with you on the crocodiles.
stitchcastle - The first part of your project, as I said earlier, was not the sort of redo we were looking for in this project. Conversely, you provided a well though-out and satisfying ending for a staple to the Movie Ride, and I applaud you.
MEW - I love the way that you form your projects in the form of a story, as opposed to just explaining the scene - the reader really gets lost in the action. However, I also appreciate the explanation of a scene, if only for technological clarification. Your project was very advanced, but I had no idea how you planned on pulling the effects off.
MathewGW - Lord of the Rings and the Great Movie Ride have been brought up together in conversation since 2001. You realized an idea that many have only dreamed about - good work.
CharlieD - I like the idea of reusing the Tiger River Rapids concept, the original idea would have made the attraction an instant classic. But, the Imagineers tried the "dead animal on the side of the road" trick at Kilimanjaro Safaris, and it didn't go well. That is not to say that it wouldn't work, but we have to account for past mistakes. Other than that, nice job.
Fractal514 - Your project was simple; my comments are similar. Opposite to stichcastle, you gave the Great Movie Ride a fitting opening act, and I could really see the scene in the attraction.
Jasonflz - I always thought that Star Wars wouldn't be a good fit in the Movie ride, considering that Star Tours is just down the road (I understand the double standard for Indiana Jones, that didn't change my thoughts). Your project proved me wrong, and it got you a spot as a Team Leader.
WDW_Vacationer - Don't ever forget to provide the subject of your work. I haven't seen the movie in a while, and I had to google the character names. Nice work, but don't forget vital information.
circusole' - I think yours was one of the best, not counting the automatic bonus points you got for using (in my opinion) the hardest attraction. You used a theme that has not yet been covered on the ride, and the pictures were nice to look at. I think, with a couple more projects under your belt, you would make a very good team leader.
Mewhunter67 - I agree with Mater in that it seems more like a refurb than anything, but it was a good effort nonetheless. I liked it.
chronomymous - Finishing an attraction about the environment with a environmentally-friendly ending - what a novel idea! You are in a similar situation to circusole'; I think you would make a good team leader, but you need to have a little more experience. Keep up the good work!
figmntal95 - A lot of people are opposed to Marvel in the Disney parks, but I see things differently. Good job on placing the franchise in a place where it can thrive.
kermitdefrog - This was an improvement over Practice Project 1. If you gain nothing else from this contest, at least you will have become a better Imagineer than when you started.
futureimageneer - I don't know if this movie is necessarily a classic yet, but it is a movie, and therefore fits in the ride. After all, it's not the Great Classic Movie Ride. Anywho, good work on modernizing the attraction.
---TrevorA
Tazer19 - I like how in-depth your project was. It seems a bit unrealistic for the space you chose, but I'm no expert. Over the two projects, you did a good job.
Tiki - I really enjoyed how concise your project was, and yet you explained everything (if not more) needed to understand your thought process. And I agree with you on the crocodiles.
stitchcastle - The first part of your project, as I said earlier, was not the sort of redo we were looking for in this project. Conversely, you provided a well though-out and satisfying ending for a staple to the Movie Ride, and I applaud you.
MEW - I love the way that you form your projects in the form of a story, as opposed to just explaining the scene - the reader really gets lost in the action. However, I also appreciate the explanation of a scene, if only for technological clarification. Your project was very advanced, but I had no idea how you planned on pulling the effects off.
MathewGW - Lord of the Rings and the Great Movie Ride have been brought up together in conversation since 2001. You realized an idea that many have only dreamed about - good work.
CharlieD - I like the idea of reusing the Tiger River Rapids concept, the original idea would have made the attraction an instant classic. But, the Imagineers tried the "dead animal on the side of the road" trick at Kilimanjaro Safaris, and it didn't go well. That is not to say that it wouldn't work, but we have to account for past mistakes. Other than that, nice job.
Fractal514 - Your project was simple; my comments are similar. Opposite to stichcastle, you gave the Great Movie Ride a fitting opening act, and I could really see the scene in the attraction.
Jasonflz - I always thought that Star Wars wouldn't be a good fit in the Movie ride, considering that Star Tours is just down the road (I understand the double standard for Indiana Jones, that didn't change my thoughts). Your project proved me wrong, and it got you a spot as a Team Leader.
WDW_Vacationer - Don't ever forget to provide the subject of your work. I haven't seen the movie in a while, and I had to google the character names. Nice work, but don't forget vital information.
circusole' - I think yours was one of the best, not counting the automatic bonus points you got for using (in my opinion) the hardest attraction. You used a theme that has not yet been covered on the ride, and the pictures were nice to look at. I think, with a couple more projects under your belt, you would make a very good team leader.
Mewhunter67 - I agree with Mater in that it seems more like a refurb than anything, but it was a good effort nonetheless. I liked it.
chronomymous - Finishing an attraction about the environment with a environmentally-friendly ending - what a novel idea! You are in a similar situation to circusole'; I think you would make a good team leader, but you need to have a little more experience. Keep up the good work!
figmntal95 - A lot of people are opposed to Marvel in the Disney parks, but I see things differently. Good job on placing the franchise in a place where it can thrive.
kermitdefrog - This was an improvement over Practice Project 1. If you gain nothing else from this contest, at least you will have become a better Imagineer than when you started.
futureimageneer - I don't know if this movie is necessarily a classic yet, but it is a movie, and therefore fits in the ride. After all, it's not the Great Classic Movie Ride. Anywho, good work on modernizing the attraction.
---TrevorA
WDW Vacationer
Active Member
Nope it's,in there.
I'm sorry about the spelling,it was terrible. I went back and fixed it.
Fractal514
Well-Known Member
Lol, yeah, it's in there NOW! 
WDW Vacationer
Active Member
Lol, yeah, it's in there NOW!
Nope,it was in there yesterday when I posted it. I posted,read it was missing,and put it in soon after,within the window of time in which edits do not appear below the post. What you see there,is when I fixed the horrid spelling today.:wave:
WDW Vacationer
Active Member
I'm not mad at the judges,but I just didn't like being accused of changing something after-the fact.
As always,thanks to judges for the comments,they are always appreciated,and should make me a better contestant.:wave: